Showing posts with label Tort Reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tort Reform. Show all posts

Sunday, August 2, 2020

It’s Time for Action on COVID Liability

By Kevin D. Williamson

Sunday, August 02, 2020

 

Republicans have been hoping that Mitch McConnell can deliver a coronavirus liability fix in Washington. Question: Why haven’t Republicans already delivered coronavirus liability fixes in Tallahassee, Phoenix, and Boise?

 

Maybe they were too busy off attending lectures on federalism.

 

The coronavirus liability shield authored by Senators Mitch McConnell (R., Ky.) and John Cornyn (R., Texas) would redirect lawsuits accusing businesses of exposing employees or customers to the coronavirus, diverting them into the federal system. It would limit the cases to those in which the businesses could be demonstrated to have shown “gross negligence” and would exempt from liability those businesses that can prove they made “reasonable efforts” to comply with government guidelines.

 

Senator McConnell has held fast to the liability shield, and President Donald Trump did his standard thing of standing tall right up until the moment Nancy Pelosi bullies him into rolling over, which he did on Thursday, offering to support a deal without the liability provision that was, until five minutes ago, the top legislative priority. Instead of having to fight Pelosi, McConnell and Senate Republicans now have to in effect fight the speaker of the House and the president together. As usual, Mr. Art of the Deal cannot figure out how to make a deal with his own team.

 

Republicans have for years made a big noise about tort reform in the states, and they have made some progress on that front, most notably in Texas. (That policy victory for Texas Republicans made independents and Democrats out of a whole bunch of rich Republican lawyers in Dallas and Houston — politics is all about tradeoffs.) But these advances have been for the most part halting and partial. If, as seems likely, January brings with it some very good reasons and excellent opportunities for Republicans to turn their attention to the state capitals, tort reform should be near the top of the agenda.

 

It should be already. In the particular matter of the coronavirus epidemic, several states have passed very limited liability protections, mostly for health-care facilities. Republican-governed Iowa has passed a broader bill that would apply a good-faith exemption similar to the one in the federal shield to most businesses; Democrats bitterly opposed this, licking their chops at the potential gravy train of litigation against meat-packing facilities and retirement homes. A Utah bill offers blanket protection to businesses save those that have engaged in “willful misconduct, reckless infliction of harm, or intentional infliction of harm.” Democrats bitterly opposed it, licking their chops at the potential gravy train of litigation against restaurants and landlords. North Carolina has created broad protections for businesses that enacted coronavirus-mitigation plans and has enacted other measures that in some cases enjoyed bipartisan support and in other cases were — sing along, now — bitterly opposed by Democrats dreaming of a once-in-a-lifetime payday for the trial lawyers.

 

The coronavirus epidemic is an extraordinary event that requires an extraordinary legislative response. But the workaday problem of excessive and abusive litigation, especially against businesses, has been around since long before the coronavirus, and almost certainly will still be a problem when we have put this ghastly epidemic behind us. This is a fight worth having, and the reformers have not yet begun to fight — at least, they have not pressed the fight to anywhere near the point they must. There has been some encouraging action, notably in Louisiana. There is room for much more.

 

Tort reform presents a classic case of concentrated benefits vs. dispersed costs. The lawyers who get rich by suing businesses — in response to legitimate abuses or for purely mercenary harassment — have fought reform tooth and talon, and they can be counted on to continue doing so. Business leaders understand the issue from the other side, though it does not land on them with great weight until they find themselves in the crosshairs. Most of the real cost is borne by third parties, meaning consumers, meaning you and me. We pay more for food and medicine, for housing, for everything that moves in a truck, for everything that requires labor — for everything, effectively — in order to enable the nation’s trial lawyers to make the payments on their G550s.

 

I do not mean to suggest that the trial bar is purely parasitic. Individuals and institutions sometimes damage the well-being of others in a way that violates the law, and the trial bar, when it is functioning as it should, works as a kind of supplementary regulatory apparatus. There are even some kinds of lawsuits that we do not have enough of, notably libel and lawsuits against the likes of the Washington Post and Joy Reid. But the loosey-goosey norms of American tort action create powerful incentives for irresponsible and opportunistic litigation, which can impose very high costs, e.g. contributing to the high cost of doctors’ fees by making malpractice insurance radically more expensive than it needs to be. Texas has made some progress on that front, with the predictable result of the Texas Medical Board licensing a record number of new physicians in the years after the reforms were implemented. Fewer lawsuits means lower insurance costs means more doctors and more competition.

 

Texas imposed controversial caps on noneconomic damages in medical liability cases, and that is a tricky policy to get right. A more straightforward model for reform would be wider application of the so-called English Rule, the “loser pays” model. That would discourage the most parasitic kind of lawsuits, those in which the plaintiffs have no real case but the defendants (usually businesses) are financially better off settling the case than they are winning it, because winning it means being crushed by heavy legal fees.

 

The coronavirus epidemic has revived interest in tort reform, not just among big national lawsuit firms whose deep pockets are lawsuit bait but also among small and independent businesses whose owners have suddenly been made acutely aware of the depth and immediacy of certain liability risks. Republicans looking for something to offer other than tax cuts — or even dreaming of finding a way back into competitiveness in California or New York — have a rare opportunity here that combines good politics with good policy.

 

And they don’t have to wait on Mitch McConnell or Donald Trump to get to work.

Wednesday, December 21, 2016

The Jihad Online



By Kevin D. Williamson
Wednesday, December 21, 2016

Omar Mateen murdered 49 people in an Orlando nightclub, and Mark Zuckerberg did not.

But Omar Mateen was an Islamic jihadist who now is as dead as fried chicken, while Mark Zuckerberg is a Silicon Valley billionaire who is very much alive.

Hence, the lawsuit.

The families of Tevin Crosby, Javier Jorge-Reyes, and Juan Ramon Guerrero, three men killed at the Pulse gay club by Mateen in the purported service of Allah, are suing Twitter (market capitalization $12.5 billion), Facebook (market cap $341 billion), and Alphabet (that’s Google and YouTube to you, market cap $557 billion) on the theory that these technology companies did not do enough to keep the Islamic State and sundry Muslim radicals from using their platforms to recruit and inspire such acts of savagery as that in Orlando.

This is partly, perhaps mainly, a case of defendant-shopping: The families in question might plausibly have sued everybody from the Islamic State to the government of Iran to the FBI in this case, but good luck collecting on a judgment against any of them. The nerds who run Facebook and Google have billions of dollars at their disposal, no sovereign immunity, and no proclivity for cutting the heads off of those who oppose them.

Suing Mark Zuckerberg because the wack-a-doodle school of Islam uses social media is a little like suing Johannes Gutenberg for all the evil that has been done by readers of Mein Kampf, The Communist Manifesto, or The Protocols of the Elders of Zion. But at the same time, Zuckerberg et al. are inviting such litigation.

The question here involves the interaction between distinct but overlapping activities: creating new kinds of communication technology; creating commercial spaces in which that technology is deployed to create a platform; producing content on those platforms, or exercising editorial control over content on those platforms.

A few examples might be illuminating. As I pointed out at the time, my hometown newspaper, the Lubbock Avalanche Journal, committed a gross and obvious libel against Rick Perry when he was the governor of Texas, (the libelous column is still on the newspaper’s website), falsely claiming, among other things, that he is a felon. When challenged on this by me and by others, the newspaper’s editors (who really ought to know better or see if their insurance plan covers self-respect implants) protested that they assumed no editorial responsibility for material published on their website, which is, as a matter of law, absurd. This is not something like, say, Daily Kos, where basically anybody can write “diaries” or the like, or the intellectual sewers that we call “comments sections.” The only reason that Rick Perry hasn’t sued the pants off of the editors and publisher of the Avalanche Journal is that doing so apparently isn’t worth his time.

Twitter, Google, and, to a much greater extent, Facebook do exercise some editorial control over their services, usually incompetently. But what they exercise is mainly either negative control (banning certain individuals, groups, or points of view, or removing material) and curatorial control. Conservatives complain, rightly, that they do this in a way that reflects their biases, which are those of corporate Democrats of the Clintonian variety. But being biased is neither a crime nor a tort, in spite of the dearest wishes of the president-elect.

Facebook and YouTube will remove certain kinds of material, either on their own volition or in response to complaints. (For YouTube, this is at least as often in response to copyright complaints as to anything else.) One line of thinking might lead us to believe that in exercising this editorial control they assume general editorial responsibilities, i.e., that by deleting material or suppressing jihadist propaganda they acquire a legal liability if they fail to do so, or fail to do so extensively and quickly enough. Under this model, these companies are more like a newspaper and less like the companies that build the newspaper’s presses or manage its fiber-optic networks.

The downside of that model of liability is obvious: If exercising some editorial discretion creates a broad and general liability for content on the site, then Facebook and Twitter have a very strong motive to exercise no responsibility at all, and to treat NAMBLA, the Islamic State, and the National Model Railroad Association as though there were no difference between any of them. Failing that, there is a motive to swing too far in the other direction, to engage in heavy-handed editorial exclusion of controversial and radical points of view, to overreact to strong language and powerful images, and to draw the boundaries of social-media discourse in the narrowest commercially viable fashion. That would not be a good outcome, either.

As imperfect, biased, and editorially incompetent as Facebook and Twitter’s ad hoc approaches are, there is not any obviously preferable alternative to them, and certainly not one that respects our free-speech traditions and the fact that these very public forums are, after all, the private property of the firms that create and operate them.

This will continue to be a very delicate negotiation: We certainly want Alphabet and Facebook to do what they can, including working with intelligence and law-enforcement agencies, to curtail jihadist recruiting and radicalization. But we also want them to keep intelligence and law-enforcement agencies at arm’s length in the service of truly free and open speech by and among marginal and radical groups, including groups of people who are engaged in illegal activity, such as prostitutes agitating for the legalization of their trade or marijuana users advocating the liberalization of drug laws.

And we should bear in mind that this is not a new phenomenon: A great deal of white-supremacist and neo-Nazi literature made its way around the world in the 1980s via mimeograph and fax machine, and PLO terrorist Yasser Arafat never sent or saw a tweet. The technological means of radicalization is secondary to the existence of Islamic radicalism and the activities of organizations pursuing that radicalism through both violent and non-violent means.

Lightening Mark Zuckerberg’s wallet is not going to do very much to improve that, and it might create a precedent that would damage free speech and free enterprise both. And if we take an honest and steely-eyed look at the facts about the organizations and individuals that fell down on the job before Orlando, Silicon Valley looks pretty good compared to the FBI.

Sunday, June 12, 2016

Gawker Is Bankrupt, And Now Liberals Are Pretending To Care About Free Speech



By David Harsanyi
Friday, June 10, 2016

So Gawker and its owner Nick Denton filed Chapter 11 today to avoid paying Hulk Hogan the $140 million they owe him after losing an invasion of privacy trial. The suit was funded by libertarian billionaire Peter Thiel, which, according to many liberals, makes this the most vital First Amendment case of our lifetime.

In a spasm of hypocrisy, many of the same people who don’t believe corporations deserve constitutional rights; who think allowing the state to ban political movies and books is a fine idea; who are constantly telling us how important the courts are in realizing a just society; who are in the pocket of the trial lawyer lobby; and who have achieved almost every major political victory through third-party-funded court battles (sometimes taxpayer-funded) now worry about slippery slopes because a libertarian has funded a successful lawsuit.

Take the illiberal New York State Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman, a proponent of censorship who is considering using racketeering charges against global warming skeptics. A government official who wants to punish people for thought crimes now has the temerity to talk about freedom of the press. Gawker, by the way, once favorably wrote about arresting climate change deniers. Unlike Michael Mann and Bill Nye and a bunch of AGs, there are those who believe political speech should be protected, and yet also that media organizations should not be immune from the law.

It’s worth once again pointing out that the trial was okayed by judge, the verdict was rendered by a jury, and the decision was upheld by a circuit judge. In no sense does this suit fall under the concept of “frivolous.” Yet liberal writers do not like the outcome mostly because Thiel is politically unacceptable to them and because they don’t like that he was driven by revenge.

I wrote this when the ruling came down:

Moreover, if Thiel’s motivation were a cause liberal pundits felt some moral or ideological affinity towards, they would be cheering him on. Vox asserts that Thiel ‘sees his lawsuit as a public-spirited attempt to enforce norms of decency and respect for personal privacy.’ Or, in other words, he uses the judicial system the same way liberals have for decades when trying to enforce their own norms—including ones on abortion rights, gay marriage, and basically everything else they value.

Actually, every contemporary major lawsuit of any political consequence has probably been funded in some way by a third party. If Thiel is a problem, so is the pro bono legal work of wealthy lawyers who donate their time and resources to causes that move them. So is contingent litigation. So are class-action lawsuits. So is every advocacy legal group. Start with the ACLU, which is backed by hundreds of One Percenters and works to enforce its own norms of ‘decency and respect’ when it comes boys’ and girls’ bathrooms and leads crusades to do away with the Free Exercise Clause.

You think these awards are out of control? Let’s talk about tort reform. If you have a problem with the merits of the case, we can debate it. Let’s remember, a Gawker editor claimed that he was okay with publishing sex tapes for anyone older than four. Is that covered under the First Amendment? Let’s discuss.

But if you’re okay with empowering government to ban a political documentary during an election season by overturning Citizens United, but lament that Hulk Hogan won a suit against a tabloid site that ran a sex tape of him without his permission, you’re not serious about freedom of expression. If you’re anxious about Thiel’s solid suit but not about multimillionaires like Nick Denton regularly destroy people’s lives — people who often don’t have the resources to fight back — you don’t really care about the little guy. Is Gawker beyond the reach of the law? Or should it just be beyond the reach of third-party funders that liberal pundits don’t like? Because it sure sounds like the latter.

Thursday, August 20, 2015

As the EPA and IRS Have Shown, with Big Government Comes Little Accountability



By Victor Davis Hanson
Thursday, August 20, 2015

Social observers from Aristotle and Juvenal to James Madison and George Orwell have all warned of the dangers of out-of-control government. Lately, we have seen plenty of proof that they were frighteningly correct.

The Environmental Protection Agency spilled 3 million gallons of toxic sludge into a tributary of the Animas River in Colorado. The stinky yellow flume of old mine waste — rife with cancer-causing mercury and arsenic — threatens to pollute the drinking and recreational water of three states.

Had a private oil company acted so incompetently and negligently, it would have been fined billions of dollars by the same EPA. The company’s top executives might have been subject to criminal prosecutions. The business’s reputation would have been tarnished for years. Just ask BP officials what the Obama administration did to the corporation after the Deepwater Horizon oil spill of 2010 in the Gulf of Mexico.

But who will police the green police at the EPA?

When EPA administrator Gina McCarthy promises that the agency will take “full responsibility,” what does that tired banality mean? Will she resign? Will bureaucrats responsible for the toxic spill face fines and jail sentences? Will residents be able to sue McCarthy and her subordinates for diminishing their quality of life? Will the Sierra Club and the Environmental Defense Fund rush to federal court to file briefs?

Consider the vast bureaucracy of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Is it culpable for knowingly not enforcing immigration law and thus allowing some undocumented immigrants to commit violent crimes?

In cases where innocent Americans are killed by undocumented immigrants with long histories of felonies and deportations — such as the recent killing of Kate Steinle in San Francisco — can the victims’ families sue ICE or sanctuary cities for either releasing or hosting criminals who were residing in the U.S. illegally?

In our litigious society in which plaintiffs sue fast-food franchises for serving excessively hot coffee, why do government bureaucrats escape culpability when the innocent die or are injured as a result of bureaucratic negligence?

When the IRS hounds citizens about their taxes, can Americans inform the agency that they are invoking the Fifth Amendment and refusing to answer out of fear of self-incrimination — and expect to face no criminal consequences?

No? Why, then, was high-ranking IRS official Lois Lerner able to sign off on the excessive scrutiny of some conservative nonprofit groups, lie about it, and then invoke the Fifth — without any legal consequences?

Presidential candidate Hillary Clinton likely broke a number of federal laws while secretary of state in using a private e-mail server at her home to conduct both private and public business. One, she kept documents containing classified information at an unauthorized location. Two, she either destroyed or removed official communications entrusted to her as a public servant. Three, she was legally responsible for the loss of information involving national defense. Four, she likely destroyed documents to block federal agencies’ examination of them.

So far, Clinton had escaped any consequences.

What is the common denominator in these government scandals — as well as the recent scandals involving the needless deaths of veterans waiting for care at Veterans’ Health Administration facilities, the sex and booze escapades of Secret Service agents, the Las Vegas junketing at the General Services Administration, the snooping at the National Security Agency, and the lack of cyber-security at Office of Personnel Management?

The bigger that government gets, the more employees who are hired, and the more unaccountable power that accrues to bureaucracies, the more government takes on a life of its own. Public grandees resemble Hollywood’s out-of-control androids or Frankenstein monsters that turn on their creators — in these cases, us, the taxpayers.

Secure, high-level government administrative jobs — where dismissal is rare and automatic promotion common — promote mediocrity. Institutionalized incompetence explains why NASA can no longer launch its own astronauts into space without help from Russia, or why the cost of the California high-speed rail project soars before an inch of track is laid.

Clearly, Clinton and Lerner apparently assumed that as federal officials, they were not subject to the same laws imposed on other Americans. They reckoned that others in the fraternity of big government would protect them from legal jeopardy. And they are probably right.

Under the Obama administration, there is also a more disturbing trend: the equation of big government with social justice and hostility to private enterprise. If the EPA and other federal agencies are felt to be on the “right side” of fairness and equality, then why object when their means to supposedly noble ends violate or neglect the law?

Big government has become the new Terminator, at war with those who created it, who fund it — and who must obey it.

Friday, December 19, 2014

Signposts of a Broken Culture



By Sonny Bunch
Thursday, December 18, 2014

So, Sony has pulled The Interview—its upcoming comedy about the assassination of Kim Jong Un by James Franco and Seth Rogen—due to threats of violence. A bunch of hackers who appear to be affiliated with North Korea warned of a 9/11-style terrorist attack if the release went forward. Many people (including myself) are not thrilled by the development and have called the studio cowardly for kowtowing to a gout-riddled tinpot dictator with a horrible haircut presiding over “a nation of racist dwarfs.”

Others responded, rightly, that Sony and the theater chains engaging in this cowardly behavior would be sued out of existence if screenings went ahead and such an attack were to go down. Jonathan Chait suggested the United States should promise to make whole any organization that was sued as a result of an (incredibly unlikely) attack. That’s not a terrible idea. I’d like to focus my attention, briefly, on this entirely accurate, utterly insane sentence of Chait’s, however:


    In the unlikely (but far from impossible) event that terrorists carried out their threat to attack a showing of the film, the legal liability to Sony would be immense.


This is totally true. The legal liability to Sony would be immense. They would be inundated by lawsuits. We’re talking about hundreds of millions in potential liability, probably. Consider that Cinemark is still dealing with a lawsuit related to the mass shooting that happened at a midnight screening of The Dark Knight Returns—a shooting for which there was no warning ahead of time, no reason to expect violence. There are trial lawyers out there who will sue whomever has the deepest pockets on whatever flimsy pretense they can muster because, hey, dolla dolla bill y’all!

This is also totally and completely bonkers.

Think about this for a second. What we are saying—nay, what we have accepted, as a society—is a situation in which a totally blameless third party would be held responsible for the evil committed by an irresponsible actor. Sony and the theater chains are being punished for the mere potential of a terror attack against them.

I joked with a friend that tort reform immediately became my number one concern for 2016. He pointed out, rightly, that this is a much larger issue. Tort reform? That’s just futzing around at the edges. Our problem runs much, much deeper than concerns over insurance costs for doctors. Our true problem is that, again, we have accepted, as a society, that it’s okay to sue a party for the bad behavior of a second party even if the first party has no role whatsoever in the malfeasance.

That’s the saddest part of all this. Yes, Sony and the theater chains have acted cowardly and without honor throughout this ordeal. But it’s not their fault. It’s ours. We made this world. They’re just living with the rules we adopted.