By Matthew Loftus
Monday, November 16, 2026
There’s a popular story about trauma and stress you’ve
probably heard over the past few years. “Toxic stress” causes cells in your
body to die, and social or cultural ills as broad as racism or sexism can be
responsible for this cellular-level toxicity. People who experience trauma—and
just about anything bad that happens to you can be considered a trauma if you
think about it hard enough—store this trauma in their bodies until it causes a
“trauma response” that’s uncontrollable. If they’re kids, trauma might cause
them to act out at school or engage in other negative behaviors. Few works have
helped to promulgate these ideas more than Bessel van der Kolk’s The Body
Keeps the Score, a 2014 book that has remained on bestseller lists for more
than a decade.
When I first read The Body Keeps the Score, it
felt like a revelation: I’d wished that I’d had those insights while I was in
my medical training to help me understand and help my patients who had been
traumatized. Those patients often acted in ways that sabotaged their own
wellness, and van der Kolk’s book was helpful in understanding those
frustrations. They often had chronic pain and other difficult-to-treat
conditions that seemed to obviously be the result of emotional pain manifesting
as physical symptoms. I drew on The Body Keeps the Score as I taught
medical learners and helped start a mental health clinic in rural Africa.
Over time, though, as I read more of the scientific
literature, I saw that van der Kolk was presenting one side of a complex debate
rather than sharing a balanced perspective on the research around trauma.
The idea of psychological trauma, from the Greek word for
“wound,” has undergone more than one transformation over recent decades. The
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, now in its fifth
edition, initially limited the diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder
(PTSD) to people who had undergone “an event that is outside the range of usual
human experience and that would be markedly distressing to almost anyone.” The
fourth edition changed this to events that were life-threatening, and the fifth
edition now says that a person can develop PTSD after learning about a trauma
that their close friends or relatives have experienced.
This expansion of PTSD’s definition is just one example
of medicalization: taking nonmedical problems and making them medical,
adding a clinical dimension where once there was none. In my new book, Resisting Therapy Culture, I show how medicalizing
normal life experiences and judging institutions by their perceived mental
health impact lead to a loss of agency as people define themselves by diagnoses
and view their entire lives through the lens of being mentally ill. The idea of
trauma is particularly pernicious because the definition of trauma is flexible,
a “trauma response” is considered involuntary, and trauma is often alleged to be stored in
our bodies in ways that are beyond our control.
Let’s start with the settled science: PTSD is a disorder
of memory. People with PTSD can have a variety of symptoms, but some of the
most prevalent are intrusive thoughts related to the trauma they experienced,
nightmares, unwanted and unexpected reactions to having a memory of that trauma
brought up (sometimes through benign triggers like loud sounds or even scents),
hypervigilance, and feelings of guilt and depression related to their trauma.
Many of these symptoms are related to the sympathetic nervous system—the
“fight-or-flight” response that is designed to help us respond to acute dangers
but causes problems when overstimulated or never turned off. Many of these
immediate reactions are involuntary, making PTSD a difficult illness to treat.
In this sense, people with PTSD do have a body “keeping the score” and causing
chronic problems long after the trauma has passed. Still, there are many
different therapies that help people with PTSD “restore” their memories in ways
that decrease their symptoms, from trauma-focused
cognitive behavioral therapy to eye movement desensitization and reprocessing therapy.
We also know that traumatic experiences can be bad for us
physically. People who live through adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) such
as sexual abuse, living with a parent addicted to drugs, or severe neglect are
more likely to develop a variety of health problems like heart disease or
chronic pain. The first wave of studies on ACEs in the late ’90s looked to
individuals’ choices as the mechanism by which these traumas were responsible
for physical issues—such as women who overate and became
obese in response to sexual abuse so that they would be less likely to be
victimized. Since people who use drugs or engage in risky sexual behavior are more likely to report a lot of
ACEs in their past, this is a plausible explanation. However, some researchers
felt that these theories were incomplete or “stigmatizing,”
and the field shifted to a greater emphasis towards a less accusatory
explanation: the toxic stress or “allostatic load” model.
Whenever we are in stressful situations, our bodies
release stress hormones like cortisol and adrenaline that allow us to respond more effectively. Toxic stress
theory takes this observation and argues that these stress hormones are “toxic”
when they are too highly concentrated, or when the body is exposed to them for
too long (that is, when the “allostatic load” is too high). This fits into the
idea of “the body keeps the score” even as it expands it: Anything traumatic
enough can cause toxic stress, which then causes long-term cellular damage in
our bodies and brains or modifies gene expression through epigenetics. (Epigenetics
also allows for explanations in which trauma can be “passed down” from one
generation to the other.) Taking it a step forward, some people argue that any
negative feeling or behavior can be understood as a “trauma response” similar
to the symptoms that PTSD sufferers experience, and since some of those
responses are involuntary, any behavior can be viewed similarly.
The challenge is that none of these assertions have been
proven. There’s a lot of conjecture about how toxic stress could
possibly cause physical damage, but no one has ever done a study that
measures brain structures in healthy people and then observes what happens to
them after they’ve been traumatized. Likewise, research about ACEs shows that
while people with more physical and mental illness issues are more likely to
recall traumatic events, we
can’t use ACE scores to predict who is going to have more problems as they
grow up.
Dr. Michael Scheeringa’s 2024 book The Body Does Not Keep the Score discusses the
scientific evidence in much greater detail, but the gist is that certain people
seem more vulnerable than others to developing mental illnesses like PTSD in
response to trauma. Their brain structures, hormone levels, predisposition to
heart disease, predisposition to autoimmune disease, or anything else we can
measure may look different because of their underlying genetics—and thus they
look different from controls.
But as important as arguments over how to interpret
scientific research are, the larger problem with pop theories of trauma has to
do with misapplications of that research and outright misinformation. You may
have seen ads, videos, or blog posts proclaiming that procrastination is a trauma
response, a statement with no basis in scientific research but still accepted
easily because it’s far easier to let go of one’s guilt over procrastination if
it’s linked to trauma. The Canadian physician Gabor Maté argues that most mental illness is somehow linked to
trauma—another baseless assertion that is nonetheless very popular.
Expanding the definition of trauma can be powerful
because it gives people a story that explains how they got to where they
are—regardless of whether or not that story is true. We can’t always draw a
hard-and-fast line to say “this is psychological trauma” while “that
is just a very stressful experience” because stress and trauma are more of a
continuum than two distinct categories. However, what we see now is an attempt
to maximize the number of things considered as trauma, even using the language
of “microtrauma.”
***
There’s a strong social component to today’s trauma
narratives. As the writer Freddie deBoer argues in his new book All in Your Head, having a mental health diagnosis
has become a status symbol in some cultures, particularly among young people.
More importantly, though, medicalization and diagnosis-as-identity give people
a sense in which their pain is legitimate and legible to others, especially in
contexts where mental health disorders are romanticized. If a teenager notices that supportive online
communities cluster around people with diagnoses of depression or PTSD, they
may self-diagnose so that others can affirm that their emotional turmoil is
real, even if that turmoil doesn’t meet the definition for any mental
disorders. As one commenter described her
experience in OCD forums:
Hope for recovery, real recovery
and not just partial improvement, was considered naïve. And it seemed there
were benefits to holding on to the diagnosis: identity, community, an
explanation for bad habits, and sympathy from others. Why give all that up?
Thanks to modern therapy culture, mental illness had become almost cool. People
seemed to, for lack of a better word, enjoy their suffering.
Medicalization, therapy culture, and the misuse of trauma
studies are harmful because they encourage people to think of themselves as
helpless victims, defining their entire lives through the lens of a mental
illness and using the language of “trauma response” (alongside a great deal of
other therapy-speak) to avoid
accountability. Olga Khazan of The Atlantic even reported that some couples therapists are sick of people
picking up concepts and language from social media and then weaponizing those
concepts in their relationships.
These ideas and practices also hurt people who really
have PTSD through linguistic inflation—if I say that working under an obnoxious
boss or being a part of a legalistic church is the psychological equivalent of
repeated sexual abuse or growing up with an alcoholic parent, that demeans the
experiences of people who have suffered genuine trauma. When people who don’t
really need therapy or psychiatry clog up the patient rolls, it becomes harder
for people who are suffering from serious mental illnesses to get the help that
they need.
How do we make this better? The first step is getting rid
of mental health awareness programs in schools. More and more evidence is
accumulating that these programs actually make kids psychologically sicker by encouraging them to reframe their
normal experiences as symptoms of a mental illness. In conversations about Resisting
Therapy Culture, I’ve had American educators tell me that more and more
kids these days are saying, “I have [X mental illness], so I can’t do [Y],” and
that attitude is destructive to a flourishing life, no matter one’s
limitations.
Second, we should stop telling people to “go to therapy” for everything. People who are having mental health
symptoms that cause severe disruption to their lives should still be referred
to a professional clinician for evaluation and treatment, but rather than
making medicalization the first response to every emotional difficulty, we
should ask what kinds of self-driven changes someone can make in their life to
improve their mood before reaching for expert treatment. The best therapy is
going to focus on those self-driven changes anyway, and a lot of problems that
people go to therapy for can be fixed with good sleep, vigorous exercise, and
deeper friendships.
Third, we should read better research about trauma. I now
recommend Dr. Joel Paris’ book Myths of Trauma as an alternative to The Body
Keeps the Score because he has a much fairer summary of the evidence and a
balanced understanding of how therapy culture has shifted so much in the past
decade. (Other books that I would recommend on mental health can be found here.) New theories are challenging our understanding of
what PTSD is and how it might work.
Finally, we should actively reject any psychological
framework that encourages people to diminish their own agency. Good therapeutic
practice for any mental illness aids suffering individuals by helping them see
how they can change their own thoughts and responses to whatever is happening
to them. Time-tested therapeutic practices like cognitive-behavioral therapy
and acceptance and commitment therapy are designed around accepting that while
we cannot change what others do, we can accept reality and modify our own
behavior in order to feel better. A worldview that tells people they can’t push
themselves to overcome or mature through suffering is a worldview that will
make people less capable of flourishing.
Does the body really keep the score? I certainly still
see patients whose symptoms reflect unresolved emotional turmoil, chronic
stress, and unhealed trauma. However, I’m far less likely now to go digging
around for traumatic events in those patients’ pasts because I’m not sure that
will help me fix the problem, and I’m more cautious to interpret experiences in
my own life as traumatic because I know that doing so could make me less
willing to change and overcome the trials I face. PTSD is absolutely a real
condition that usually needs professional help to fix. Self-diagnosing as
“traumatized,” on the other hand, is usually a recipe for people making
themselves sicker.
No comments:
Post a Comment