Friday, November 20, 2026

The Replacement

By Nick Catoggio

Thursday, November 19, 2026

 

We don’t need to spend much time today on fascist Yalta.

 

Nearly everything I have to say about it was said in other recent editions of this newsletter. This morning’s summit “appeared to achieve little,” CBS News observed, which is no surprise given that Xi Jinping’s trip to Washington earlier this fall also achieved little. In both cases, the president’s interest in diplomacy had nothing to do with resolving disputes and everything to do with luxuriating in the prestige he feels whenever some A-list tyrant greets him as a peer.

 

“The point of the meeting is the meeting,” I wrote in September of Xi’s visit. “Trump palpably envies the autocratic power [leaders like Xi and Vladimir Putin] have accrued and admires the ruthlessness with which they wield it.” Rubbing elbows with them gives him a contact high. As if to prove it, he took care to remind the two at this morning’s meeting that they lead three of the world’s largest nations, that their decisions affect the entire planet, and that they were “making history” by gathering.

 

For the president, the essential thing about this conference of the modern “Big Three” was its bigness. That’s him all over.

 

Last week, in a separate newsletter, I speculated on why Trump reportedly did nothing upon being told that the head of Nvidia was literally in bed with a Chinese intelligence asset. Wasn’t he worried that the company’s most advanced chips, the key to America’s advantage in the race to develop artificial intelligence, would fall into Beijing’s hands?

 

Probably not, I argued. He regards both Jensen Huang and Xi Jinping as “friends,” and we all trust our friends, don’t we? “The president seems to believe that America’s best defense against the threats it faces are the personal relationships he’s cultivated with influential people,” I said of Trump’s approach to foreign policy. In his mind, “the better his personal relations with an adversary are, the less threatening that adversary is to the United States.”

 

Fast-forward to this morning. Upon encountering the butcher of Ukraine, a visibly delighted Trump declared “he’s my friend” before shaking Putin’s hand. (“God, protect us from such friends,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk lamented afterward.) Later, addressing Xi at a meeting, the president told his host, “You’re my friend, and we have a very special relationship. As long as you and I are in charge of things, we’ll never have a problem.” QED.

 

After 10 years, nothing about this is shocking or even very interesting. No one blinks anymore when Trump responds to a question about Putin’s conduct in Ukraine with “I think he could be tougher. I think he could be a lot tougher, frankly.” He is who he is, and Americans knew it when they reelected him.

 

The only surprising thing this morning was seeing Marco Rubio seated next to Trump as the president cooed about Xi. Our wildly overrated chief diplomat normally doesn’t involve himself heavily in important diplomacy, as you may have noticed in Iran, Ukraine, and Gaza. Yet there he was, passive as usual as his boss humiliated the United States by schmoozing with two illiberal enemies eager to usurp American power.

 

What was he supposed to do, tackle Trump? Rubio’s apologists will reply. Of course not.

 

What he was supposed to do was resign in protest after any one of the dozen or so previous disgraceful foreign policy chapters of the president’s second term. The reckless gutting of USAID by DOGE, the inhumane rendition of illegal immigrants to an El Salvadoran dungeon, the NATO-breaking power play to annex Greenland, the rapacious collusion with Delcy Rodríguez’s despotic regime in Venezuela, the strategic foolishness of war with Iran, the Putin-esque threats about swallowing Canada, the horrendous treachery of taking sides with Russia against Ukraine, and the gross negligence of failing to intervene in what Jensen Huang was up to: If any of it bothered Marco Rubio, the alleged adult in the room in this administration, it didn’t bother him as much as it should have.

 

That’s why I’m inclined to take seriously the new rumors that Rubio might be supplanting J.D. Vance as the president’s preferred successor. The secretary of state may not have sold as much of his soul as the vice president has, but he’s surely sold enough of it to lead this party.

 

The gravest sin.

 

It’s absurd that Rubio’s political stock is rising as he goes about doggedly defending an unpopular war while Vance’s is falling because he hasn’t, but that’s life in a personality cult.

 

Although Trump hasn’t attacked his VP publicly the way he typically does when he feels betrayed by a deputy, it’s obvious that he resents Vance’s postelection statement blaming the war for the GOP wipeout. In the days since, the president has observed that “a lot of people didn’t like [Vance’s] comments,” has removed the vice president from his role leading U.S. negotiations with Iran, and called the failed peace deal that Vance brokered this past summer with Iran “a waste of time” in an interview yesterday.

 

In the same interview, he said he thought the VP should have made clear in his statement that, in spite of everything, war with Iran was the right choice. As if the whole point of the statement wasn’t to reassure prospective 2028 voters that a Vance administration would not have chosen it.

 

The grumbling has continued behind the scenes, allegedly. Last week the Wall Street Journal claimed that Trump groused to deputies that Vance’s defunct deal with Tehran, in the paper’s words, “gave Iran critical time to regroup and rake in oil revenues before the U.S. imposed a naval blockade.” And the New York Times reported yesterday that “Mr. Trump has grown increasingly frustrated with how his vice president framed his assessment of what went wrong, complaining to aides and allies that Mr. Vance should have made a point of saying the president made the right decision in going to war with Iran.”

 

Failing to defend the president against his detractors is one of the gravest acts of disloyalty a Trump crony can commit, a true mortal sin in the MAGA faith. Vance is now guilty of it. But you know who isn’t? Per the Times:

 

Mr. Trump has continued to praise Marco Rubio, his secretary of state, in private conversations, and has suggested that he could be a strong presidential candidate, according to the people, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe discussions going on behind closed doors. Mr. Trump’s allies have noted that Mr. Rubio has repeatedly said the president’s move to attack Iran was essential for the country’s national security.

 

As it happens, since the election more than one major news outlet has alleged that Vance is wavering about whether to run for president in 2028. As it also happens, a CNN story published on Wednesday claimed that Rubio has begun “more seriously weighing a 2028 run.” He’s no longer insisting that he won’t run if Vance does whenever he’s asked about the next cycle, and he’s “grown vaguer in private as well about his post-State Department plans,” according to CNN’s sources.

 

If you want to tell yourself a story about what might be happening behind the scenes, it isn’t hard. As it becomes clearer that the president is more inclined to endorse his ever-loyal secretary of state over his anti-war vice president, both men’s calculations about succeeding him have changed. Vance can’t win the nomination without Trump’s support and his future prospects probably can’t survive a snub by the boss, so he’s begun concocting a pretext to bow out of the race on his own terms before the president knifes him. He wants to spend more time with his family, perhaps—until 2032, when the GOP will be licking its wounds after a likely defeat in 2028 and possibly eager to give a true “America First” candidate a try.

 

And as Vance is stepping back, Rubio is stepping forward. With Trump and the right-wing donor class behind him and the vice president out of the race, Rubio would be a heavy favorite in the next primary despite the antipathy diehard postliberals feel for his Reaganite/neocon (and Hispanic) pedigree. Don’t kid yourself that because Tucker Carlson dislikes him, so must the grassroots GOP: Two new polls out today have Rubio ahead of Vance in the coming primary, in one case by double digits.

 

Loser vibes.

 

Part of the reason that some Republicans have soured on the vice president surely has to do with his dovishness toward Iran and his ambivalence toward Israel. (Another subject on which the wider Republican base and its postliberal faction disagree, by the way.) But I think Vance has also contracted a fairly severe case of “loser vibes,” in the words of one Dispatch colleague, from this month’s epic electoral drubbing. The magnitude of the Republican wipeout raises an obvious question: Is Donald Trump’s inexperienced, less charismatic running mate really the right choice to win an election in a country that’s grown to hate Donald Trump?

 

As a proponent of the Iran war and an enemy of Carlson’s, Ben Shapiro might be biased against Tucker’s buddy Vance—but even so, I find it hard to argue with his analysis of the VP’s presidential chances:

 

Does he do better with Hispanics than Trump did in 2024? There’s no way. Does he do better with blue-collar white voters than Trump did? There’s an outside argument, but is it possible to do better with blue-collar white voters than Trump did in 2024? Very difficult to imagine that. Is he going to do better with married women? Probably not. Is he going to do better with single women given many of his comments? I think probably not. Is he going to do better with college-educated people because he’s steered so hard into sort of the populist online right? I think it’s going to be very difficult for him to pull that out.

 

An “America First” platform shorn of Trump’s second-term failures could win back some of those groups, especially blue-collar whites. But therein lies the problem: Vance, uniquely among Republicans, will wear those failures in the next cycle. He’s free to go on putting out statements distancing himself from them, but as the president’s right-hand man, voters will hold him accountable for Trump’s mistakes regardless. And every time he tries to wash his hands of them between now and 2028, the resentment that the president and some of his devotees feel for his “disloyalty” will grow.

 

Until two weeks ago, the vice president’s great asset in a primary against some refugee from the pre-Trump GOP was that he was entirely a creature of the Trump era, having first sought public office as a loud-and-proud postliberal in 2022. Someone like Rubio or Ted Cruz could never be fully trusted by the base by comparison because they spent years as members of “the uniparty,” converting to postliberalism only belatedly. As Sarah Longwell once put it, to the average populist Republican, the Trump revolution of 2016 was “Year Zero.” Anyone who was part of the ancien regime was suspect.

 

The remarkable irony of this month’s landslide is that it may have flipped that calculus on its head. Because Republicans now have no choice but to prioritize electability, figures who built a political “brand” independent of Trump suddenly may seem more appealing as candidates than the “Year Zero” crop. Figures like, say, Marco Rubio, a man who’s never fully disgorged his Reaganite identity but has worked hard and cagily to try to synthesize it with Trumpism (unsuccessfully).

 

That probably explains why the public perceives Rubio but not Vance as meaningfully distinct from Trump even though it’s Rubio, not Vance, who’s defending the president unreservedly on the radioactive subject of the Iran war. Politically, the president is a wet gremlin and the vice president is a furball that spawned off his back. Rubio, who spent five years in the Senate before Trump entered politics, is different.

 

His tone is different too, and it matters—and that, too, is ironic. The astounding scale of the blue tsunami suggests a degree of hostility to Trumpism that might run deeper than policy, extending to the type of politics that the president has mainstreamed in America. If voters go to the polls in 2028 desperate to move past this ugly era, Vance—who spends his time hurling insults at opponents and demagoging immigrants and minorities—-will not be a viable choice for Republicans. A better choice would be someone who’s restrained, professional, even a minority himself. The sort of figure whom millions of college grads who’ve drifted left over the past decade might listen to and think, “This guy’s different, more my speed.”

 

That’s Rubio, not Vance. Imagine it: After 10 years of treating politics as pro wrestling and celebrating ruthlessness as a cardinal virtue, the president and his party might now be pivoting to one of the few figures left on the right who can still credibly affect a sense of dignity in public. Sure, the secretary of state has spent two years as the chief diplomatic henchman in a fascist project to dismantle the post-war American-led global order, but fair is fair—he seems darned statesmanlike as he goes about it.

 

Pitfalls.

 

I do hope that Rubio usurps Vance as the presumptive Republican nominee and not just because I find him considerably less obnoxious personally and marginally less obnoxious politically. In a few ways, I think his candidacy would be amusing.

 

It would be amusing if the president endorsed him for the explicit reason that he’s been a loyal apologist for the Iran war as that’s the last thing Rubio would need in the general election, knowing what an albatross the subject is likely to be. He’s spent the last nine months doing what he can to keep his fingerprints off the mission, letting Vance and figures like Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff take the lead on negotiations with Tehran. It’d be funny if all of that went up in smoke because Trump insisted on giving him the kiss of death: The one guy who never had second thoughts about Iran was Marco.

 

It would also be amusing to see the president, after rewarding Rubio for his loyalty by crowning him heir apparent, have to cope with watching his secretary of state try to distance himself from Trump’s unpopular policies in the general election. Vance’s statement blaming the war for the GOP’s midterm rout may have been foolishly hasty, but it wasn’t incorrect on the political merits; whoever succeeds the president as nominee will have no choice but to disown toxic Trump failures like Iran, tariffs, and letting ICE run wild.

 

Rationally, the president understands that, I’m sure, but as I said earlier, he is who he is. Trump anointing Rubio as his successor and then predictably blowing a gasket when Rubio panders to voters by sharing their misgivings about Trump’s agenda will be tons of fun.

 

Most amusing, though, will be watching the chaos in the GOP field unfold amid a shocking new reality in which Vance is out of politics and Rubio is Trump’s chosen successor.

 

One compelling argument for the vice president’s candidacy, I’ve always thought, is that it could dissuade “America First-ers” from mounting a primary challenge that could make real trouble for the party. Vance is postliberal enough to satisfy most postliberals and well-credentialed enough as vice president to satisfy most normie Republicans, making it difficult for both the far right and center right to gain traction against him. His value proposition as a potential nominee is that he might win a primary more or less uneventfully, keeping the right more or less united heading into the general election.

 

But if Vance is out and Rubio is in, there will be a postliberal challenger in the field and possibly a formidable one. Maybe it’ll be Carlson, maybe Rep. Thomas Massie, or maybe someone who’s not on anyone’s radar yet. (Expect Ron DeSantis to start sounding more like Tucker if Vance bows out and the postliberal “lane” in the race opens up.) But it’ll be someone, because the thought of Trump’s movement being inherited by one of the conventional Republican candidates whom he trounced in 2016 will infuriate devout “America First-ers.” As will the prospect of postliberalism losing control of the GOP to a guy who once supported legalizing illegal immigrants.

 

Nominating the secretary of state would be a supreme test of the decade-long Republican hostage crisis, in other words, a sort of dare to the far right to boycott the 2028 general election. And they might: A Rubio defeat due to lower Republican turnout would show the rest of the party that it can’t win without appeasing postliberals, a perfect set-up for Vance’s big comeback attempt in 2032.

 

But a Rubio victory, especially one driven by college grads and Hispanics returning to the GOP as the party turns the page on lowbrow populism? That could be the end for Vance and his ilk. If you’re looking for a reason to root for a Rubio presidency, that’s the best I can do.

No comments: