By Charles C. W. Cooke
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
At Reason, Jonathan Adler rips the New York Times apart for once again trying
to read the Second Amendment out of the Constitution. This time, the Times
is pretending that a key part of the Heller decision, penned by Justice
Antonin Scalia in 2008, was predicated upon a misquote. As Adler — and others —
have noted, the Times is simply wrong. Scalia did not make the claim
that the Times insists that he did, and, by all accounts, the Times
knew that when it went to print. Now, instead of acknowledging its error, the Times
is using its PR department to go
after those who have pointed it out. Classy!
The details of this particular mistake are quite
complicated, and, if you wish to dig into them, Adler’s piece is instructive.
But what interests me more than the particulars is that, after all this time,
the enemies of the right to keep and bear arms are still trying this absurd
game. As I have written many times, the notion that Heller “invented”
the Second Amendment — either perniciously, or by mistake — is the legal
equivalent of moon-landing trutherism. I daresay that, by this point, a good
number of left-leaning people have come genuinely to believe in that
trutherism. But it is trutherism nevertheless.
In 1989, Sanford Levinson wrote in the Yale Law
Journal that:
the best explanation for the
absence of the Second Amendment from the legal consciousness of the elite bar,
including that component found in the legal academy, is derived from a mixture
of sheer opposition to the idea of private ownership of guns and the perhaps
subconscious fear that altogether plausible, perhaps even ‘winning,’
interpretations of the Second Amendment would present real hurdles to those of
us supporting prohibitory regulation.
Fortunately, this tendency proved no match for the sheer weight of the historical evidence, which shows that,
without a shadow of a doubt, the Second Amendment (like the 40+ state-level
equivalents that existed prior to Heller) protects an individual right
to bear arms, and always had. Writing a year before Heller, the Times’
own Adam Liptak observed that the now-crumbling revisionist case that the
gun-control movement had developed in the mid-20th century had:
reflected received wisdom and
political preferences rather than a serious consideration of the amendment’s
text, history and place in the structure of the Constitution.
In 2008, the Supreme Court ignored all that, and, having
seriously considered the amendment’s text, history, and place in the structure
of the Constitution, ruled correctly that “the right of the people to keep and
bear arms” meant . . . well, “the right of the people keep and bear arms.” Its
case was unanswerable. And yet, as the Times’ latest attempt shows, we
are all still at the mercy of a bunch of ridiculous die-hards who remain
desperate to find that elusive One Weird Trick that will finally remove part of
the Bill of Rights.
That trick does not exist. One can not find it by
butchering the preamble, or by pretending that Antonin Scalia wrote something
that he plainly did not, or by falsifying the historical record, or by redefining the word
“militia,” or by pretending that originalism works in ways that it does not. If the Second Amendment is to be
excised out of the Constitution by judges, it will be not be achieved by
scholarship, but by the exercise of raw power. The Times’ erroneous
piece arrived a few days after the Democrats won a big political victory.
Coincidence? I think not.
No comments:
Post a Comment