Monday, November 16, 2026

The Many Forces Pulling at the Democratic Agenda

By Noah Rothman

Friday, November 13, 2026

 

On Friday, the likeliest next Speaker of the House, Hakeem Jeffries, gave the public a glimpse at the incoming Democratic House majority’s legislative priorities for the year ahead:

 

 

We’re unlikely to get a better illustration of the many competing and, in some ways, irreconcilable political forces pulling on his majority from so many angles.

 

Who could have predicted, for example, that this ideologically progressive class of lawmakers would make tax relief their foremost priority? Sure, the child tax credit is popular. And as a form of social engineering, it doesn’t exactly depart from progressives’ first principles. But would expanding the CTC make it to the top of the list if so many Democrats weren’t elected on November 3, even as voters across the country simultaneously backed anti-tax ballot initiatives?

 

Saddled with a mandate for progressive change amid an open tax revolt, the Democratic Party has an “impossible agenda,” Vox.com’s Eric Levitz frets. He might be right.

 

Of course, Jeffries can’t afford to forget about affordability. His caucus will argue that restoring cuts to Medicaid and Obamacare subsidies fits that bill. But that hardly covers the waterfront, and this truncated agenda appears to sideline campaign-trail promises to curtail the president’s tariff-issuing and war-making powers. It would have been uncharacteristic for a Democratic majority to hamstring the executive branch in the first place. But since Democrats promised to do so, voters might expect them to deliver.

 

Voters might be similarly perplexed by the Democratic Party’s conclusion that what voters were clamoring for were constitutional limits on their right to engage in political speech within a certain proximity to an election. If a push to “overturn Citizens United” is on the docket, paring back the First Amendment’s protections is a live issue.

 

Banning mid-decade redistricting may encounter its own constitutional obstacles. Even if the “elections clause” covers Congress, such a sweeping imposition on the states would consume more political capital than the Democratic majority seems to have considered. And even if a plurality or, perhaps, a majority of voters support codifying Roe in federal law, that, too, is not a pocketbook issue.

 

In this agenda, we see the influence of progressive activist groups and establishmentarian Democrats, centrists and suburbanite converts, and swing voters who reluctantly gave the opposition party a turn at the helm. Maybe by trying to be all things to all people, Jeffries will make everyone happy. But it doesn’t often turn out that way.

No comments: