By Noah Rothman
Friday, November 13, 2026
As is so often the case, Vahaken Mouradian is on the case. His disquisition on the
French novelist Michel Houellebecq’s torment at the hands of censorial French
authorities is as enlightening as it is righteous in its revulsion.
Blessedly, Mouradian and National Review are not
alone in taking France to task over its harassment of the prolific author. The New York Post is on it. So, too, are the Daily Wire and the Washington Examiner. Unherd contributor Simon Heffer published a stirring condemnation of the
ordeal to which Houellebecq has been consigned.
What’s more, the American right isn’t mounting this
crusade entirely on its own. “An assault on free speech is unfolding in
France,” Thomas Chatterton Williams wrote for The Atlantic.
But beyond Williams’s call to action, it’s hard to find a treatment of
Houellebecq’s case on the left or center-left that offers anything close to a
moral judgment.
The author of several acclaimed works, including Submission
— a tale in which France voluntarily gives itself over to an Islamist social
covenant and a soft, Westernized version of Sharia law — now finds himself in a
purgatorial agony that might have been ripped from the pages of his own novels.
Houellebecq was indicted this week on the charge of
“complicity in incitement to discrimination, hatred or violence” against a
minority group based on “their origin or their belonging or not belonging to a
particular ethnicity, nation, race or religion” — a crime in the French
Republic. His offense stems from remarks he made in November 2022, in which he
speculated that violence committed by France’s unassimilated Muslim minority
may beget acts of retributive violence.
“When entire territories come under Islamist control, I
think acts of resistance will take place,” he told an interviewer. “There will
be attacks and shootings in mosques, in cafés frequented by Muslims, in short,
Bataclans in reverse,” Houellebecq continued, referencing the Islamist massacre
of 130 people in Paris in 2015.
What inspired French authorities to pursue Houellebecq’s
supposed offense so aggressively all these years later? According to Williams,
the French state sputtered to life in response to the October 23 mass shooting in a Muslim-dominated suburb of
Paris by a gunman who allegedly targeted minorities and was likely inspired by
Nazi ideology.
The French civic organizations that indicted
Houellebecq’s complicity in this event imagine he incited it, not that he had
predicted it. And no one seems to have given much thought to the fact that this
horrific and racist shooting event was preceded by weeks of violence of the very sort that Houellebecq warned were coming. In the
absence of a robust state response, he forecast, such violence would inspire
the radicalized and unbalanced to engage in violence themselves.
There’s no indication that Houellebecq welcomed racist
violence. Prophecy is not permission. Nevertheless, French authorities have
repeatedly singled out the author for harassment over controversial claims
about “the changing ethnic and religious composition of the European
population” and its effects on the European civic compact. “A prophet of doom
does not wish for disaster,” Houellebecq’s lawyers wrote, “quite the contrary.”
As a philosophical matter, that is inarguable, even if
France’s prosecutors disagree. Nevertheless, Houellebecq’s torment seems to
have eluded the American left. As Vahaken observed, the vanguard of left-wing
activists who are forever on the hunt for even the appearance of literary
censorship from the right — both in America and internationally — are silent.
We are endlessly privy to tendentious accusations that
the American right is “banning books” — a phenomenon you can fight yourself by
picking up a copy of those forbidden titles that grace the “banned book”
section of your local left-wing bookstore. The right is supposedly “suppressing books” with sexually explicit themes in
elementary school libraries (by making them available only upon request). The
Defense Department under Pete Hegseth set out in early 2025 to “review” titles with what the Pentagon deemed
DEI-related themes — a reactionary and overbroad fervor that captured great
works of literature as much as shlock.
The American left is forever conflating the right’s
distaste for certain literature with unconstitutional efforts to prevent others
from accessing them. And yet, their passion, undiscerning though it may be, is
the sort that a free society cultivates. At times, their principled aversion to
even the suggestion that their ideas are being suppressed leads to a variety of
unlovely excesses. At others, it is a useful corrective when the right forgets
its own civic commitments in its efforts to push back against left-wing
cultural belligerence. That tension is desirable.
But the broader American left seems not to have noticed
Houellebecq’s persecution by the French state. That is what censorship looks
like — not the brute force version, but the creation of conditions that lead
otherwise free thinkers to keep their thoughts to themselves.
“Officially, there is no censorship in the Soviet Union,”
wrote Mikhail Sergeevich Volensky, a former member of the USSR’s
Academy of Sciences, after defecting to West Germany in the 1970s. “A Soviet
citizen knows what he can write and what he cannot,” he added. “It would be
foolish to write something on a topic which is regarded as unimportant or,
worse still, touchy.”
Even if Houellebecq emerges from his trial a free man,
his mistreatment by the French state may still have its intended consequences.
The author is to be condemned to the prison of his own mind, intimidated into
what he would recognize better than anyone else as a species of the very Submission
he saw coming. The American left’s sensors are finely attuned to those perverse
inducements when the right is meting them out. But when it’s the exemplars of
the vast European state muscling heterodox intellectuals into browbeaten
silence, and all on behalf of an obviously unnaturalized and anti-Western
minority, their self-righteousness disappears.
The ugly discrepancy isn’t invisible to all on the left.
“It is easy to pick on America and its extravagance, while we celebrate our
supposed immunity from backward culture wars,” the Maastricht Diplomat’s
Simone Capuozzo wrote last year in a perfunctory appeal to
Europe’s vestigial sense of cultural superiority. “The truth is that attacks on
printed media have started to re-emerge across Europe, and putting the full
blame on American conservatives would deflect blame from homegrown rather than
imported movements.”
France, Chatterton Williams warns, “is creating
conditions in which only outright extremists will dare say what many privately
believe to be true.” He’s right. It’s not just Michel Houellebecq but every
law-abiding Frenchman with a proper sense of self-preservation who will resign
themselves to incarceration within a mental gulag. That is the censor’s last
and final victory. And, in France, the censors are winning.
No comments:
Post a Comment