By Jonah Goldberg
Friday, November 13, 2026
I don’t have a long list of favorite memos written by
government bureaucrats, so this might seem like faint praise. But Lin Wells’ memo is my favorite of the genre, and probably would remain
so even if the competition were stiffer.
It’s probably easier for you to just go check it out
yourself, I won’t mind. But here’s how it begins:
If you had been a
security policy-maker in the world’s greatest power in 1900, you would have
been a Brit, looking warily at your age-old enemy, France.
By 1910, you would
be allied with France and your enemy would be Germany.
By 1920, World War
I would have been fought and won, and you’d be engaged in a naval arms race
with your erstwhile allies, the U.S. and Japan.
And so on. In its brevity and concision, it’s really one
of the best things I’ve ever read to illustrate a fundamental point: Things
change.
Intellectuals have a special weakness for not
understanding this. George Orwell makes this point in his essay “Second Thoughts on James Burnham.” (If I had to
compile a list of my favorite essays, the competition would be far more fierce.
But this would definitely be a contender for the top spot.)
Orwell is, I think, a little unfair to Burnham—but only a
little—when he writes: “It will be seen that at each point Burnham is
predicting a continuation of the thing that is happening. Now the tendency to
do this is not simply a bad habit, like inaccuracy or exaggeration, which one
can correct by taking thought. It is a major mental disease, and its roots lie
partly in cowardice and partly in the worship of power, which is not fully
separable from cowardice.”
Further on, he adds: “Power worship blurs political
judgment because it leads, almost unavoidably, to the belief that present
trends will continue.”
If I had the power to snap my fingers and make eggheads
(and politicians, and big donors) instantly understand one thing, it might be
this.
Which brings me, obviously, to Kansas.
OK, maybe not obviously. So let me explain. In the run-up
to the midterms, nearly every serious political commentator and analyst thought
that it was at least unlikely that Adam Hamilton, the Democratic Senate
candidate in Kansas, would win his race. And even those who thought otherwise
believed that, if Hamilton pulled it off, he’d do so narrowly.
Why? Because Kansas had not elected a Democrat to the
Senate since 1932. Kansas, you see, was a reliable “red” state.
There are a lot of reasons to hate the convention of
labeling states or districts “red” or “blue,” starting with the fact that “red”
is the traditional color of the left. Before the 2000 election, there wasn’t
much rhyme or reason to which party got which color. Networks and newspapers
assigned the colors fairly arbitrarily. NBC, which pioneered the color coding,
chose blue for Republicans in 1976 because, in the U.K., the right was blue and
the left was red. “Without giving it a second thought, we said blue for
conservatives, because that’s what the parliamentary system in London is, red
for the more liberal party,” explained Roy Wetzel, who oversaw election
coverage for NBC. “And that settled it. We just did it.” (The Smithsonian has a
good history of all this.)
Over the last quarter century, the red vs. blue thing has
sunk deep into our political consciousness. It’s become almost a form of
political identity-politics color coding. Countless books and journalistic
accounts use it as a shorthand for their analysis of the culture war,
polarization, even speculation about secession or civil war. It’s all perfectly
understandable. Indeed, that’s why it caught on: It helps people understand
politics in a clear and simple way. But that doesn’t mean it’s necessarily helpful.
Which brings me back to Kansas. Kansas was born as a
Republican state in 1861, against the backdrop of the Kansas-Nebraska Act and
the Civil War. Many antislavery New England transplants were among the state’s
key founders and civic leaders. Indeed, Kansas was traditionally Republican in
the same way that many New England states were. As John Judis put it, “After the Civil War, Kansans retained their
allegiance to the Republican Party in much the same way post-bellum white
Mississippians remained Democrats.”
In other words, Kansas’ attachment to the GOP was more historical
than ideological. Most of the Republican politicians from Kansas that
you might remember were not hardcore conservatives. When Bob Dole returned from
World War II and was approached to run for office, he asked, “Well, how many
Republicans are there and how many Democrats?” in Russell County. When informed
there were twice as many Republicans, he said, “Well, I think I’d better be a
Republican.” Dole was a loyal Republican, but he was hardly a Reaganite or
William F. Buckley guy. Neither were Sen. Nancy Kassebaum or Gov. Alf Landon.
That’s not to say that Kansas doesn’t have a rich tradition of moral crusading
and ideological progressivism, but that’s sort of the point: “Republican
progressive” is an oxymoron for people caught in the red vs. blue paradigm. But
it was just a normal label for many Republicans, from Robert La Follette and
Teddy Roosevelt to Nelson Rockefeller and even Richard Nixon.
Prior to Hamilton, the last Democrat sent to the Senate
from Kansas was George McGill in 1932. But that was his reelection. He won a
special election in 1930, thanks in part to a backlash against the Smoot-Hawley
trade bill that, by 1932 (his reelection year), ignited the “Farmers Revolt.”
(Sound familiar?) Race also played a role, because blacks in Kansas and
elsewhere were beginning to shift toward Democrats for reasons we don’t need to
get into here. Of course, 1932 was a good year for Democrats generally, given
the fact that FDR had some serious coattails.
Orwell was right that “Power worship blurs political
judgment because it leads, almost unavoidably, to the belief that present
trends will continue.” What he left out was that the same blurred political
judgment can lead us to the belief that present trends extend backward, too.
We think of the Solid South as red, but the term “the
Solid South” was born as a descriptor of the monolithically Democratic South
before the Civil War, and that meaning largely endured until the 1960s when LBJ
won the presidency in a massive landslide despite losing much of the South to
Barry Goldwater.
What changed? Well, America. By that I mean the culture,
the economy, and just plain old life changed—and the political agendas of the
parties changed with them.
That’s as it should be. And even if you think it
shouldn’t be that way, the simple fact is it is.
The problems come when we conflate partisan
identification with identity: cultural, ideological, or even racial. Some of
the people who thought it unimaginable that Kansas (or Texas, or Mississippi)
could vote blue based their judgment on perfectly sound variables like polling
data, voting trends, cash on hand, party infrastructure, etc. They were still
wrong, but they weren’t crazy or stupid in their wrongness.
Other people based their invincibly confident predictions
on superficial cliches about “red America,” as if red were synonymous not just
with ideological conservatism but with all of the populist, culture-war, MAGA
nostrums and white and Christian identity assumptions that get folded into a
lot of red vs. blue “analysis.”
The postelection spin wars contain a lot of the same
thinking. Kevin Roberts, the president of the Heritage Foundation, attacked
Senate Majority Leader John Thune for daring to suggest that the Republican
Party needed to appeal to independent voters because they make up a third of
the electorate and drove the Democratic tsunami.
Roberts responded:
“Saying, ‘We’ve got to start talking to independent voters,’ here is Swamp talk
for ‘run to the middle.’ Running to the middle is not what got Trump popularly
elected in 2024, but it is what got Republicans crushed in the midterms. Bold
conservatism is what will attract independent voters and win elections.”
The stupidity of this is breathtaking. First of all, no
professional Trump apologist should ever use the phrase “swamp talk” as if they
have the moral authority to talk about “draining the swamp.” More to the point,
Trump himself would have lost without independents, which is why he threw
pro-lifers under the bus in 2024. His
promises to end “forever wars” (eyeroll) and concentrate on deporting “the
worst of the worst” were aimed as much at independents as at the Republican
base.
Why did Trump want to court independents? Because, like
all presidential candidates, he wanted to win.
But Roberts is less concerned with winning elections than
he is with winning an intra-right argument. To do that, Roberts needs to
redefine “bold conservatism” as a cowardly obeisance to Trump, J.D. Vance, and
the donors he’s been captured by. He has so abandoned the conservatism Heritage
once stood for that he can’t even see the absurdity of recasting MAGA identity
politics and his own slavish loyalty to Trump as “bold conservatism.”
Part of the war on Thune is just an effort to shift blame
for the midterms away from Trump and his enablers, like Roberts. But part of it
also stems from this idea that partisan identity is an identity and must remain
one, heedless of policy preferences or intellectual or moral objections. Thune
wants to work with people who disagree with him or the GOP on some issues.
Roberts and his ilk think that doing so is a betrayal of their tribe. Shortly
before the election, Roberts wrote that “The Democratic Party is planning to storm next
week’s midterm elections like the Bastille, fueled by a Jacobin fanaticism
unprecedented in American politics.”
First, there are plenty of precedents in American
politics for the 2026 midterm results. Second, the Jacobins didn’t storm the
Bastille, in part because the Jacobins he’s thinking of didn’t really exist
yet. Third, Roberts’ argument that traditional conservatives should drop their
objections to his brand of NatCon populism and “fuse” with his tribe to defeat
child-mutilating jihadist commies who hate us is hard to reconcile with the ongoing purges of traditional
conservatives at Heritage. Heritage has a “one-voice” policy that requires
everyone at Heritage to follow the party line dictated by Roberts. That’s
Heritage’s prerogative. But Roberts wants to extend that approach to the
entirety of the right as if his brand of bulls–t was a religious doctrine or
ethnicity. The Roberts crowd talks about Republican identity as if it was as
immutable as left-handedness or height. This is a profoundly unhealthy way to
think about politics. It’s also a stupidly self-defeating way to think about
politics because it demands total surrender to fabricated identity. If you
deviate, you risk being branded a heretic or apostate. A lot of voters don’t
want to sign up for that. And you need some of those voters to win elections.
“They hate us” is almost always shorthand for “We hate
them.” And “we hate them” is always reductionist, stripping away all nuance and
independent judgment and behavior. It outsources thinking to crude “us vs.
them” categories—like “red America” and “blue America.”
Now, I should say, I don’t like child mutilators,
communism, or jihadism. I also don’t see any of that in Hamilton—and neither
did Kansas voters. What they saw was a decent pastor of conservative
temperament running against a Trump rubber-stamping senator. Or, more simply,
they saw a Kansan who happened to be a Democrat who was fed up with the
ugliness of Trump’s presidency and Roberts’ fake conservatism. And like a lot
of Americans, they found that refreshing.
I began by noting that things change. They do. But unlike
some on the right, I don’t think that principles change. Your commitment to
principles can change, and so can the commitment of political parties to them.
But the power worship inherent in the idea that red states can never turn blue
(or vice versa) fuels the delusion: the blurred political judgement that you
can take voters for granted and therefore that you can wander from your
principles without paying a price because your power is an immutable entitlement.
Donald Trump took office and governed on that assumption, to the uncritical
applause of Roberts and company. The midterm results were the price for their
arrogance, but there will surely be more to pay in the years ahead.
No comments:
Post a Comment