Commentary Magazine
Monday, November 16, 2026
There’s been a lot of talk in recent years about the
“horseshoe theory”—the notion that people and ideas on the political extremes
end up being pulled toward each other almost magnetically, thereby threatening
to leave the non-extreme center little more than an isolated chasm. If we look
through history, Jew-hatred has been among the most reliable examples of this
phenomenon, as erstwhile ideological rivals always seem to find a way to set
aside their differences when they see the Jews as a common problem.
What happens when those forces move from the fringes to
the mainstream? The results of the 2026 congressional midterms are
unfortunately offering us a possible answer to a question we wish we didn’t
have to ask.
From the moment the polls closed, the Jewish state and
its supporters became targets, simultaneously demonized by the winning side and
scapegoated by the losers. This is a new political moment, and U.S.-Israel
relations and Zionism itself are facing a new kind of peril.
Indeed, there is a real possibility that the only
bipartisan consensus during the final two years of the Trump presidency will be
an agreement in principle that Israel asks too much, gets too much, delivers
nothing, and deserves to be punished.
The Democratic Party has been traveling down this road
for more than a decade. Ordinarily such a journey would be met with
countermeasures by the opposing party’s vanguard, but Jews always represent a
special case whose antagonists play by special rules. The force that believes
itself to be the vanguard of the right is mirroring, matching, and in some
cases exceeding the hostility of the left toward Israel and the Jews.
Democrats like Senators-elect Abdul El-Sayed and Troy
Jackson along with Representatives-elect Darializa Avila Chevalier, Claire
Valdez, Adam Hamawy, Melat Kiros, and Chris Rabb helped provide their party
with sizable majorities in both houses of Congress—which will give Democrats an
opportunity actually to enact anti-Israel legislation they could only have
dreamt of just months ago. At the same time, Vice President JD Vance’s
prospective presidential candidacy appears to be built on a foundation of scapegoating
the Jewish state and its American supporters.
Vance “felt negative going into Tuesday,” he wrote
in a post-election statement released 16 hours after the polls closed. An
unnamed pollster had told him that “Trump 2024 voters were angry and planning
to vote for Democrats.” The only way to get these right-leaning voters back to
the GOP was with a four-point plan:
1) End the war
2) Focus on cost of
living/inflation
3) Put America First
4) Change our relationship to
Israel
Three of those four are either direct or oblique
references to Israel.
It is not the first time Vance has signaled his intention
to travel this byway. In June, the vice president lashed
out at critics of the diplomatic outreach he conducted with Iran that led
to the “memorandum of understanding,” which brought the yet-to-be-won war to a
screeching halt. He directly pointed a finger at the Israeli government:
“I guess my message to them would be twofold. Number one,
Donald J. Trump is the only head of state in the entire world who is
sympathetic to the nation of Israel at this moment in time. And he happens to
be the head of state of the world’s superpower. If I was in the cabinet of the
Israeli government, I might not be attacking the only powerful ally that I have
anywhere left in the entire world.”
Number two, Vance added, was a reminder to Israelis that
“over the last three months, two-thirds of the defensive weapons that have
protected your homeland have been built by American hands and paid for by
American tax dollars.”
The following month, Vance complained
to podcast king Joe Rogan that Israel and a former administration staffer were
behind “a literal foreign influence campaign being funded to tank the very deal
[with Iran] that I was pursuing.” His message to them: “Go to hell.” What Vance
said was patently untrue. There was a paid-influencer campaign, but its
intent was to improve Israel’s image abroad, not to attack the Iran talks or
anything about the administration’s statements, actions, or policy.
While Vance is preparing the ground for 2028,
progressives will be in position to legislate the end of key parts of the
U.S.-Israel relationship. They’ve been laying the groundwork. In November 2024,
Senator Bernie Sanders put forth several “resolutions of disapproval” of arms
sales to Israel. None had the support of more than 19 Democratic senators. Two
years later, one of Sanders’s arms-restriction bills received the support of 27
Democrats.
In April, the embargo garnered the support
of 40 Democratic senators, including leading 2028 candidates such as Georgia’s
Jon Ossoff. Come January, there will be as many as 56 Democrats in the Senate,
significantly raising the odds that these bills will get a full floor vote and
pass. (Though they would likely be vetoed by President Trump.)
This was made all the more significant by Trump’s
surprise announcement
on November 3 that he had reached a deal with Israel to end U.S. military aid
after this year instead of in 2028, when the current memorandum of
understanding is set to expire. Trump might have been trying to take a campaign
issue away from the anti-Israel progressive base, but he likely just moved the
ball further down the field for the anti-Zionists.
If military aid to Israel—which consists of grants that
Israel must spend on U.S. manufacturers, thus actually serving as a domestic
price support for the American weapons industry—is ending, Democrats in
Congress are likely to simply move on to the next step in the process of
undoing U.S.-Israel relations. As incoming Representative Chevalier, an acolyte
of New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani, said:
“Ending military aid is not enough. We need to end U.S. taxpayer funding for
Israel’s war crimes, a full arms embargo, and the Palestinian right of return.”
Many on the left share that goal. El-Sayed and Alexandria
Ocasio-Cortez, the New York congresswoman and likely 2028 presidential
candidate, are among those who have voiced
opposition even to purely defensive, life-saving tools like Iron Dome
missile defense. Out-and-out progressives will surely back a full U.S.
government arms embargo and attempt to outlaw private defense-contractor sales
to Israel as well. In the past few years, Democrats have put forth bills,
resolutions, and amendments to label
Israel a genocidaire, to undo
planned U.S.-Israel military and technology cooperation, to restore
funding to UNRWA (the UN Gaza agency found to be riddled with Hamas members and
sympathizers and that shared facilities with the terrorist group during the
war), and to require
U.S. government investigations into law enforcement in Judea and Samaria. Any
and all of these could get a fresh hearing after the new Congress is sworn in.
Unfortunately, the more politically conventional
Democratic leadership has put up almost no resistance to its anti-Zionist left
flank. That might be because they haven’t had to: Without control of Congress,
Democrats couldn’t enact any of this legislation. Now they can.
The Senate majority leader will be Chuck Schumer, a human
doormat when it comes to left-wing anti-Semites. Presumably Schumer would
rather not organize a legislative attempt to treat Israel as a rogue state—but
if he has a plan to prevent that, he hasn’t shared it. Instead, he has
facilitated the elections of El-Sayed, Jackson, and others who have made their
intentions plain.
In the House of Representatives, incoming Speaker Hakeem
Jeffries is in a similar position. Jeffries has already voiced support
for some Israel-critical legislation. He is a co-sponsor of the West Bank
Violence Prevention Act, which would establish a sanctions regime for alleged
Israeli misbehavior in Judea and Samaria. The bill could apply not only to
hilltop hooligans but to Israeli government officials and institutions (banks,
for example) deemed enablers of the misbehavior.
It would open the door to the U.S. treating Israel the
way the U.S. treats Iran. El-Sayed himself has suggested
viewing both countries as threats to America.
Moreover, Jeffries’s bill would fail to sate the
anti-Zionists in his coalition. It will only whet their appetites. They’ll
pocket Jeffries’s sanctions bill and move right along to the next item on their
agenda.
All of this would be prelude to a hypothetical Democratic
president’s chance to finish off in 2028 whatever was beyond Congress’s
purview, or to sign into law any such legislation that Trump vetoes.
If the next president is Vance, these Democrats in
Congress will find surprising common ground with a politician they otherwise
revile. Vance appears to have been methodically establishing the arguments he
will use to reverse the case he made only two years ago for Israel’s status as
an American ally. In May 2024, two months before he was announced as Trump’s
running mate, Vance gave a major foreign policy address to the
isolationist Quincy Institute. There, before an audience of Israel skeptics,
Vance explained why he supported Israel but not Ukraine.
“I certainly admire the Ukrainians who are fighting
against Russia, but I do not think that it is in America’s interest to continue
to fund an effectively never-ending war in Ukraine,” Vance said. In contrast,
allying closely with Israel can “actually give us missile-defense parity.
That’s a very important national security objective of the United States of
America, and that’s something we’re working with one of the most innovative
economies in the world to accomplish.”
The basic question, Vance said, is this: “Do we want
clients who depend on us, who can’t do anything without us? Or do we want real
allies who can actually advance their interests on their own with America
playing a leadership role?”
Vance’s post-midterms statement was a point-by-point
refutation of this case for Israel. The war with Iran has apparently
demonstrated, to Vance, that Israel can’t and won’t always fight alone. This
drains American resources and flies in the face of an “America First” strategy.
Therefore, we must “change our relationship to Israel.”
Yet this raises a question: Throughout his career, Vance
has been willing to adapt his principles to match whatever has popular support
on the right. Polls show
a majority of Republican voters still believe that Trump’s level of support for
Israel is right where it should be. Why would Vance stake out a position on the
other side?
The answer is that Vance chooses policy stances not by
their popularity but by their usefulness to his own career advancement. The two
are not always the same. Vance envisions a race for the 2028 Republican
presidential nomination in which supporters of the U.S.-Israel alliance will
already be backing a different candidate. His ambition therefore would
naturally lead him to jettison his grudging, utilitarian support for our
alliance with Israel. To win the nomination, however, he’ll have to convince
enough Republicans to follow suit.
How might he seek to do this? Not only by blaming Israel
for decisions his administration made, but by taking a page out of anti-Israel
Democrats’ playbook and exacerbating the existing divides within American
Jewry.
Vance’s wing of conservatism is populated by NatCons—the
National Conservatives. As Naya Lekht writes elsewhere in this issue, the
NatCons advocate a form of blood-and-soil nationalism for the American right.
They recently held a conference in Jerusalem where several speakers exhorted
Israelis to tell U.S. Jews to stop complaining about anti-Semitism. The
message: American Jews are ruining it for Israel. This is a right-wing version
of the Democrats’ ongoing campaign to convince American Jews that Israelis
are to blame for all their woes.
Thus are American Jews presented with the following
demand: They need to renounce the parts of Judaism that extremist political
demagogues find distasteful and disassociate themselves from the Jews
who won’t follow suit.
“Judaism and the Jewish people are not the same as Israel
and AIPAC. They’re not the same,” El-Sayed said
in August. He’d said
the same thing three weeks earlier on Meet the Press: “I love and revere
Judaism and the Jewish people…. But they are not the same as AIPAC and Israel.”
AIPAC, of course, isn’t Israel. It is an
organization of Americans who support the U.S.-Israel alliance.
El-Sayed’s comments are a reminder that Israel’s enemies see American Jews as a
direct threat to their agenda. It’s a sentiment shared by numerous
progressives, who will now have the wind at their backs—and an unlikely
cheerleader in JD Vance who hopes to replicate their success.
This is more than a horseshoe. It’s a pincer attack, and
attacks must be foiled or the attackers will simply continue to advance. Many
American Jews—the majority in Michigan who voted for el-Sayed, for example—have
decided they are not going to fight, or are going to accept some illusory deal
whereby they will be left alone if they go along to get along. The Jews
throughout history who try to buy off those with deadly intent against them
either end up no longer being Jews or learning too late the cost of their
appeasement.
The rest of us, unable to retreat into illusion, are
going to have to fight the pincer attack for them—not because these
contemptible Jews deserve to be fought for, but because it is the battle for
our children and grandchildren, who do.