Sunday, November 15, 2026

The Diminishing Returns of MAGA’s Rebellion

By Raleigh Adams

Saturday, November 14, 2026

 

The Trump administration’s pre-midterm enthusiasm for AI-generated pop-culture memes produced an unlikely political hero: Anakin Skywalker. A gifted young man, repeatedly frustrated by an arrogant institutional hierarchy, finally takes matters into his own hands. Of course, MAGA would see itself in the future Sith Lord and assume its voters would, too.

 

One rather important detail about Anakin, though: He didn’t overthrow the Empire. He helped build it, then helped run it — insofar as Force-based violence counts as governing.

 

Apparently, though, the fate of this Empire is still someone else’s fault.

 

Curtis Yarvin, meanwhile, thinks Republicans haven’t been rebellious enough. Writing recently in The Spectator, the far-right political blogger argued that Republicans need to recover their rebellious spirit to mobilize disaffected nonvoters. I appreciate the punk sentiment. It just pains me to admit that Yarvin has a point. Trump was elected to challenge an entrenched political establishment, not merely to preside over it. As Yarvin puts it, “The Trump administration was elected to break the frame.” Instead, “it chose to operate inside the frame.”

 

Yarvin also acknowledges that Trump’s revolutionary promises have become increasingly disconnected from political reality. No argument there. “There was no path from reality to fantasy,” he writes. The administration can declare victory as often as it likes, but voters still have to live with the results.

 

There is a reason the rebel act worked for Trump in 2016. He was challenging not only Democrats but a Republican establishment whose own voters had grown tired of its promises. Even in 2024, Trump could plausibly campaign as the candidate of change against an incumbent Democratic administration. But the political circumstances are different now. The White House is his, for the second time. So is the Republican Party he once ran against. Trump could once point to Washington’s failures as evidence that the people running it needed to be replaced. What he can no longer do is pretend that replacing them is an accomplishment in itself.

 

Ten years is an awfully long time for a rebellious phase. At some point, arrested development stops being charming.

 

Yarvin’s prescription is not simply more provocative messaging. He wants better political organization, a disciplined narrative, and decisive institutional action. But his preferred source of political momentum is revealing: “Not the vegetarian momentum of governing well, but the carnivorous momentum of destroying the enemy.”

 

Governing well is not the vegetarian alternative to political victory, Curtis. It is what victory is supposed to make possible. If defeating the enemy becomes the measure of success, there will always be another enemy to defeat, another institution to blame, another rebellion to wage, and precious little reason to account for what the last victory accomplished — or didn’t.

 

After a decade of MAGA insurgency and one and a half Trump presidencies, everyone but Yarvin may begin to wonder how much longer another rebel yell can keep paying dividends. The movement has hardly suffered from a shortage of enemies, revolutionary imagery, or declarations that the establishment is finally on the ropes. Yet everyday Americans are still dissatisfied with the cost of living and increasingly want an end to the war in Iran

 

The problems that brought a movement to power do not disappear simply because its preferred enemies have been defeated.

 

MAGA’s rebel identity may still energize its most committed supporters. But there is a difference between mobilizing voters against the people in charge and persuading them that you deserve to remain there. An insurgency can make a compelling case for why its opponents should lose power. Eventually, it must make an equally compelling case for what it has done with its own.

 

MAGA doesn’t need to learn how to be the rebellion. It needs to learn when to stop playing one.

No comments: