By John R. Puri
Sunday, November 15, 2026
Says Pete Hegseth, echoing a quote by Marco Rubio in a
recent speech for the Federalist Society: “Stop quoting laws to MEN WITH
SWORDS.”
These folks may never get around to citing James Madison,
but they can sure quote Roman generals who served dictators. Perhaps Rubio has
the better defense. He quoted
Pompey the Great to inveigh against the International Criminal Court’s claims
of authority over the United States. If the court attempted to enforce its
decrees against U.S. citizens, Rubio said, it would be met with the halting
hand of the U.S. government.
But that would not be an instance of the law falling to
the sword, because, as Rubio mentions one line earlier, the ICC’s supposed
authority over America is no law at all. Since men are born with equal
authority, the spring of just law is consent, and Americans have never
consented to be governed by the ICC through their representatives because our
country has never joined it. If the ICC tried to override state or federal
statute, its false law would give way to true law. The sword,
should it come into play, would merely be the instrument to that true law.
In America, the sword of government or any individual has
no independent authority whatsoever. The very purpose of the American founding
was to ensure that force would always be subject to law, which would itself
flow from natural right and popular consent. That is why one of the Founders’
great innovations was to place the new U.S. armed forces under strict civilian
control.
It is revealing that the sentiment of Rubio’s speech that
Hegseth — the man responsible for those armed forces — chose to pick out and
emphasize in ALL CAPS, without even Rubio’s context, was that laws ought to
yield to swords. Not in this country, they don’t.

No comments:
Post a Comment