Friday, November 20, 2026

Trump, Xi, and Putin: The Three Caudillos

By Kevin D. Williamson

Friday, November 20, 2026

 

When Donald Trump entered American politics in a more serious way in 2015-16 (he had sought the Reform Party nomination in 2000), he made a good deal out of being an “outsider” who was “not a politician.” Donald Trump has never been an outsider, of course—he was born an insider by dint of his father’s position in the New York City business milieu—and, like every other real estate developer and would-be casino magnate, no matter how miserable a failure, he had long been a kind of politician. But however we characterize Trump’s career before 2016, a decade plus later, he can no longer say that he is not a politician.

 

He is a bad politician.

 

Trump is entering the Emmanuel Macron stage of his political career: Finding domestic politics too dispiriting and too depressing, the hope of fiscal improvement and entitlement reform too forlorn, he is looking for other things to do. Macron has long focused on the world stage—foreign policy, European affairs, international gatherings of different kinds, etc. Macron is the epitome of Davos Man. France is, to French consternation, only a minor player in world affairs these days, while the United States is the most important player—dangerous, chaotic, undisciplined, unreliable, corrupt, misgoverned, violent, and fickle, to be sure, but still the biggest kid on the block. It is easy to imagine why Trump might want to have a meaningless summit with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin—the big brother and the kid brother of the latest axis of evil—if only to escape the torture of watching James Talarico make fun of him on Saturday Night Live.

 

Trump showed up at Shenzhen with no agenda and, in that sense, he got what he went there for: nothing. Xi and Putin had agendas, and they, too, got what they went there for.

 

Xi got to demonstrate his implicit convening power, hosting the summit as an act of graciousness toward Trump, who had pressed for a meeting in the wake of his humiliation in the midterm elections. For the cost of a few dinners and a stroll up the tarmac, Xi was able to project, almost convincingly, the image of that which he aspires to be but is not yet: the boss of a country that is the equal of the United States. Putin got to remind the world that it is no use trying to make a pariah of him when he has the president of the United States of America hanging from his jockstrap.

 

Putin seems to enjoy making a fool of Trump, and so he had Russian forces launch another brutal fusillade on the women and children of Ukraine as he and the Chinese caudillo and the American caudillo celebrated a four-point “declaration toward peace,” all four points of which serve Putin’s interests: The empty talk about nuclear weapons does not restrain him, expanding the production of fossil fuels enriches him and his war machine, browbeating the International Criminal Court and the United Nations leaves the world for him to bustle in, and the insistence that “respect for immunities of State officials are of paramount importance” is a nice thing for a murderous gangster—or three of them—to have in the ol’ back pocket.

 

A few years ago, I had a memorable lunch with a cardinal who was an adviser to Pope Francis. When another member of the party asked why the pope seemed like such a commie on economic questions, the cardinal—a man who obviously liked and admired the pope—laughed and said that the simple answer was that the holy father didn’t know the first thing about the subject, had never read a serious book touching such matters, and resolutely refused to keep up with his briefs on the subject. People who like and admire Donald Trump—and, inexplicably enough, there are such people—sometimes say the same thing about the president in private, though the public statements are—or were—about 4-D chess and all that nonsensical fantasy horsepucky. One cannot help noticing that the number of abjectly self-abasing Trump apologists is being trimmed. As Jay Nordlinger put it in his low-pH mode: “I have noticed something in the aftermath of the midterm elections. More people—many more people—have always been anti-Trump than I was formerly able to perceive. … In coming years, there may be as many people who were always anti-Trump as there were members of the French resistance.”

 

The Shenzhen summit made some people think of Yalta. But Franklin Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin were serious men—FDR may have been seriously wrong, Stalin seriously evil, and Churchill seriously drunk half the time, but serious. Trump, on the other hand, remains what he always has been: a jumped-up game-show host entirely out of his depth.

 

The amateur is the ideal type of Olympic competitor—the amateur is not the ideal type of politician.

No comments: