By John Fund
Sunday, November 15, 2026
The blue wave washed over a slew of state legislative
chambers and six new governorships. Next year, a majority of Americans will
live in a state with a Democratic governing trifecta. One of the biggest
dangers of Democrats’ new political clout is that they will now push to
override the Electoral College and effectively force the country into a
nationwide presidential popular voting system as early as 2028.
Their vehicle is called the National Popular Vote
Interstate Compact, an agreement among states to award their electoral votes to
the winner of the national popular vote, no matter which candidate carries each
state. The compact was born after former President George W. Bush’s narrow
Electoral College victory in 2000, and it was turbocharged following Donald
Trump’s 2016 win despite his losing the popular vote. The District of Columbia
and 18 states have joined, accounting for 222 electoral votes.
The compact takes effect only if its members’ electoral
votes total 270: the number needed to win the White House. This year’s midterm
elections gave Democrats a governing trifecta in Pennsylvania, Michigan,
Arizona, Wisconsin, and Nevada. If all five join, the compact would cross the
270-vote threshold.
“National popular vote will be something that we’ll
prioritize early in the session,” says Kelda Roys, a Democratic lawmaker in Wisconsin who
points out that Virginia joined the compact as soon as Democrats won full
control of the state government there in 2025.
But approval is not a sure thing. Some Democrats oppose
the compact out of concern that it would dilute their state’s influence in
presidential campaigns. Michigan refused to pass it when it was previously
governed by a Democratic trifecta, from 2023 to 2024. And in 2019, Nevada’s
Democratic governor vetoed the measure.
Moreover, should the compact cross the 270-vote
threshold, there will likely be a slew of legal challenges. “The argument would
be that it’s unconstitutional because it changes a fundamental structural part
of the Constitution without going through the constitutional amendment
process,” Hans Von Spakovsky, a former member of the Federal Election
Commission, told me. “I think the Supreme Court would say you can’t do that.”
There are also practical objections. The change would
likely incentivize election fraud, as political machines focused on heavily
populated urban areas would be encouraged to turn out votes for their preferred
nominee. “A national popular vote would reward with influence, and thus
incentivize, any state that encourages the maximum number of votes, whether
it’s by legalizing non-citizen voting or stuffing ballot boxes,” writes Inez Feltscher Stepman in National Review. “It would
set off a registration arms race and punish, with less influence over national
elections, any state that tried to put in place anti-fraud protections.” As an
inevitable result, postelection litigation and disputed vote counts would
become the norm in any close contest.
Chris Stirewalt, the politics editor of NewsNation, warns that a national popular vote would “breed more
populism and more angry-mob politics.” Indeed, “If you haven’t enjoyed Trumpism
and the idea of $5,000 bonus checks, you would most certainly not enjoy the
America of a national popular vote.”
There is a reason that our Founding Fathers made it so
difficult to change the Constitution. They wanted to ensure that any amendment
to it would represent a real consensus of opinion in Congress as well as the
states. By sneakily circumventing that vision through the scheme of a national
popular vote compact, partisans are only exacerbating the tensions that
increasingly dominate our politics.
No comments:
Post a Comment