Friday, November 20, 2026

Vance’s Political Losses Are Rubio’s Gains

By Noah Rothman

Thursday, November 19, 2026

 

Those who invested in JD Vance’s political stock — perhaps even literally — may be looking to offload their holdings. The vice president’s brand is not what it once was, and he largely has his own wanting judgment to thank for that.

 

Like all vice presidents, Vance’s fortunes are inseparable from his boss’s. So, it was a foolish choice to implicitly lay the blame for the GOP’s disastrous midterm performance at Donald Trump’s feet, claiming that the president had “lost” a war that he was still prosecuting. Accordingly, Trump is reportedly withdrawing his previous support for Vance’s succession — an imprimatur the vice president’s allies believe he needs if he is to win the 2028 primary.

 

Those same allies have spent the weeks since the election flooding the zone with stories indicating that the vice president is rethinking his plans. In their telling, however, Vance is a victim of circumstance. He is a young man with a young family, they say. A presidential run would put his children through hell. And the political environment in 2028 is not likely to be conducive to a Republican victory. The GOP presidential nomination may be a poisoned chalice for whoever takes it. Better to wait, regroup, and take another run at the White House in 2032. Perhaps he can be drafted into a race for his old Ohio Senate seat! Whatever he decides, his boosters insist, Vance has options.

 

Yet, even as Vanceworld conditions the environment for the vice president’s retreat from politics, the chatter around Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s presidential prospects is growing. What’s more, Rubio himself no longer seems to mind.

 

With Republicans “trying to coax him off the sidelines,” CNN reported, “There have been increasing signs that he’s weighing a run.” Yes, their enthusiasm is attributable to “fresh doubts” about Vance — particularly the vice president’s apparent determination to engineer a schism within the MAGA movement. “Some Rubio supporters noted more fallout over Vance’s postmortem could be coming, anticipating a potential confrontation with Trump,” the report continued. But their openness to a presidential run by Rubio is also fueled by his own increased interest in another campaign for the White House:

 

The 55-year-old has grown vaguer in private as well about his post-State Department plans, two sources familiar with those conversations told CNN. It’s a marked departure from earlier in Trump’s presidency, when Rubio insisted to allies that he had no intentions to run and instead wanted to pursue a lucrative private-sector job, according to two sources familiar with those previous remarks.

 

Rubio faces plenty of obstacles, any one of which might dissuade him from seeking the presidency. He has his eye on Cuba, and “his supporters in the Cuban community will expect to see progress on that front,” CNN noted. The Iran war is just one of the “president’s most pressing political challenges” that Rubio would prefer reach a reasonably satisfying resolution before he even considers a presidential campaign. Some of Rubio’s supporters believe he would only pull the trigger if Trump “effectively cleared the field” for him. That isn’t likely.

 

Nevertheless, interest in a Rubio bid is peaking — perhaps too early — as Republicans are increasingly concluding, with all requisite evidence, that the levers on which Vance would have to pull to win the presidency are no longer functioning. In 2024, Trump and Vance both expertly exploited an American political milieu uniquely favorable to their respective styles.

 

Much has changed. Provoking for provocation’s sake no longer has the cachet it once did. The New York Times’ reporting on the ouster or self-imposed exile of MAGA staples from Congress — outgoing or former members like Nancy Mace, Marjorie Taylor Greene, and Lauren Boebert — illustrates that phenomenon.

 

The big-name podcasters on whom Vance would rely to reach the low-propensity voters who buttressed Trump’s winning coalitions are shying away from politics. The politicians who sought office in 2026 have returned the favor. This year, they kept their distance from the alternative broadcasters who held the political world on a string just two short years ago.

 

“I’m not MAGA,” Elon Musk told the Times this week, admitting his nine-figure investment in the GOP’s candidates this year felt “pretty foolish” in retrospect. Burnt by his experience with DOGE and as a high-dollar donor, the world’s richest man may be out. Perhaps he will take his Silicon Valley allies — those who aren’t scrambling to curry favor with ascendent Democrats, at least — with him.

 

Vance has defined his constituency so narrowly that all this represents an existential threat to his political fortunes. Rubio is not similarly constrained. “People just have a sense that he’s more mature,” Newt Gingrich told CNN. “he’s a broader personality and that he would reach out to a much wider constituency.”

 

Which is to say that Vance’s problem isn’t his family, the president, or the foreboding mix of political circumstances that will conspire against the GOP in 2028. The problem is JD Vance. The secretary of state may stumble, too. But he’s been a far better steward of his own political trademark. And if the party still decides, well, it sounds like it’s already decided.

No comments: