By Alex Castellanos
Sunday, November 15, 2026
In Lerner and Loewe’s 1960 musical, Richard Burton as
King Arthur explains the rules of an idyllic land known as Camelot. The
climate, His Royal Highness tells the audience, is commanded by his authority.
“It’s true. It’s true. The Crown has made it clear. The climate must be perfect
all the year. The rain may never fall till after sundown, by eight, the morning
fog must disappear.”
Washington still sings this song every day. Congress
wishes for cheaper health care and so, commands it. When our political
overlords desire faster economic growth, they order it to appear, and staple
thousands of pages of instructions to their mandates. Convinced there is only
upside, Washington cranks out an unrelenting stream of magical, cost-free
legislation. Their endless good intentions, they believe, can produce only
unendingly good results, always reflected in the legislation’s title: the
Affordable Care Act, the Inflation Reduction Act, the American Job Creation
Act. If only it were so.
Washington often tells us to “listen to the scientists.”
Well, okay then. Let’s set politics aside for a moment and look at government’s
impact on our economy as a matter of physics. The equations of fluid dynamics
do not exclusively describe the movement of water. They describe what happens
when anything flows through a constrained channel. Traffic on a highway obeys
these equations. Blood in an artery obeys them. So does an economy, which is a
flow of goods, labor, and capital through channels shaped by law.
And the physics tells us that government’s products,
laws, rules, and mandates come with a cost the political class does not
consider, price, or acknowledge. That price is friction. And it can be
measured as it rubs against all of us.
In the 1840s, a French hydraulic engineer named Henry
Darcy, the same man who gave Dijon its first municipal water system, spent
years measuring how much pressure water lost as it traveled through a pipe. A
German engineer named Julius Weisbach helped him tidy up the math. The result,
the Darcy–Weisbach equation, is still used by every fluid engineer in the
world. It tells you the exact cost a pipe imposes on the water that passes
through it.
Every plumber understands it intuitively, even if he has
never met the equation. Four things inescapably matter.
1. How
long is the pipe? Every extra foot of pipe is another foot of friction.
2. How
wide is the passage? Push the same amount of water through a pipe half as
wide, and the friction rises not twofold, but roughly thirtyfold. The physics
is not kind to constrictions.
3. How
rough are the walls? Clean copper is easy on the water. Old rusted iron
drags on it.
4. How
fast is the water moving? Double the speed, and you do not double the
friction. You quadruple it.
Simplified, the equation reads:
Length x Narrowness x Roughness x Velocity² =
Friction
That word, “multiplied,” is the quiet secret of the
physics, and the reason the American economy is so much more strained than our
leaders notice. Politicians add laws the way a librarian adds books to a shelf,
one by one, and cannot understand why the total feels so heavy. But the physics
does not add laws. It multiplies them. Every rule stretches the pipe, narrows
it, or roughens it, and each variable amplifies the others.
The Four Faces of Government Friction
Increasingly, our lives pass through the pipes of our
government. One only need think about the four variables I mentioned:
·
Length. The Federal Register, the daily
catalog of new federal rules and proposed rules, ran about 10,000 pages in
1950. It hit a record 106,109 pages in 2024. The Code of Federal Regulations
has grown from about 23,000 pages in 1960 to more than 188,000. Every modest
deregulation effort within living memory is a small dip in an otherwise
unbroken line that climbs ever upward to regulatory nirvana. The pipe keeps
getting longer under presidents of both parties.
·
Narrowness. True story: A woman spent 30
years braiding hair in Dallas. When she decided to teach braiding, Texas told
her she would need 2,250 hours of barbering coursework, none of which involved
braiding, and a fully equipped barber college with barber chairs and sinks she
would never use, and more than $20,000 in renovations. A federal court
eventually struck the requirements down. She won. But the argument the physics
compels is not about the woman who fought. It is about the ones who didn’t. In
the 1950s, roughly 5 percent of American jobs required a government license.
Today, the figure is over 20 percent. That is not because our jobs are four
times more dangerous. It is because government narrowed the pipe at its
entrance by a factor of four.
·
Roughness. There is a difference between
a rule that tells you what to do and a rule that tells you to hire a lawyer to
figure out what to do. Fluid engineers call it pipe roughness. Consider the
Inflation Reduction Act’s electric-vehicle credit: Simple enough, it promised a
$7,500 tax credit. Treasury and the IRS buried it under years of shifting rules
on domestic content, critical minerals, and battery components. The rules were
revised many times, and so were the revisions. Manufacturers could not plan a
battery supply chain without a team of attorneys. The list of eligible cars
kept changing. Uncertainty is a subsidy for lawyers. For everyone else, it is a
tax, and it falls hardest on those who cannot afford a compliance department.
Since Dodd–Frank, roughly 3,400 American banks have disappeared,
most of them absorbed by larger banks that could carry the ever-growing
regulatory load of compliance. A law sold as a brake pedal on too-big-to-fail
banks produced more of them.
·
Velocity. Here the physics turns cruel,
because America runs faster than it did a century ago. Our grandfathers built
railroads. Their grandchildren build AI companies that go from a dorm room to a
billion users in a few sunrises. Consider data centers, which consumed less
than 2 percent of American power a decade ago and are projected to consume up
to 12 percent by 2028. Microsoft has signed a 20-year deal to buy power from a
shuttered reactor at Three Mile Island, because reviving an old plant is easier
than getting a new one approved. Officially, American energy policy wants
clean, cheap electricity to power our AI economy. Also officially, American
regulatory policy prevents anyone from providing it. A regulatory pipe that was
tolerable at the walking pace of 1935 is a garrote at the speed of data in
2026.
None of this appears in any statistic politicians
publish. No table shows the jobs never created, the apartments never built, or
the power plants never turned on. But our futures are lessened in their
absence.
Politics Has Its Own Reynolds Threshold
If friction only slowed the flow of our lives, regulation
would be a matter of gradual optimization. Some friction is worth it, some is
not, and reasonable folks could debate the trade-offs, should we find any such
people in Washington’s marbled temples. But physics has a stranger property
that the plumber’s intuition does not capture and that Washington cannot see.
Above a certain threshold, the character of the flow itself changes.
In 1883, a British engineer named Osborne Reynolds built
a long glass tube, filled it with water, and introduced a thin filament of
colored dye. At slow speeds, the dye moved through the tube in a clean,
parallel line. We call this laminar flow. But when Reynolds opened the valve
past a certain point, the dye did not simply move faster. It burst into chaotic
swirls. The flow had turned turbulent. Water still moved through the tube, but
unpredictably, losing far more of its energy to friction.
Remarkably, the transition happened at a specific,
calculable number. Below about 2,300, flow is smooth and orderly. Above about
4,000, it is turbulent. Every fluid engineer since has calculated it for every
pipe he has designed. It is called the Reynolds number, and it tells you where
the character of your flow will change.
An economy under normal government friction is laminar.
Growth softens. Voters grumble; incumbents lose elections; new laws are passed.
That is the ordinary politics of decline, mostly bearable, and it is what most
Americans have lived through since Ronald Reagan left for Rancho del Cielo.
But an economy above its Reynolds number is a different
animal. Rules produce outcomes their authors never contemplated. Gray markets
emerge. Capital flees to other states and countries. Trust in institutions
collapses, not gradually, but all at once. Socialist candidates stun the
Democratic establishment. Populist movements, from both the Bernie Sanders left
and the Donald Trump right, gain command of their parties.
The political class experiences this as a series of
shocks it cannot explain. Voters are irrational, they say. The polls are wrong.
Everyone in Washington asks the same question: What is happening? It is the
transition Reynolds watched in his glass tube. The flow of American life
through government’s pipes has crossed a threshold.
We have seen this before. Britain in the 1970s ran
nationalized industries, marginal tax rates above 90 percent, and inflation
that reached 25 percent. Garbage piled up in the streets during the Winter of
Discontent. The International Monetary Fund had to bail out one of the great
powers of the industrial age. Margaret Thatcher was elected, not because
Britain had suddenly become conservative, but because turbulent flow always
demands a political response.
The Turbulence Comes Home
On November 3, precisely as the fluid churns faster in
the United States, a political movement stepped forward to lengthen, narrow,
and roughen government’s pipes all at once. The election results are in. A
cabal of hungry young socialists established themselves as the future of the
Democratic Party.
Democratic socialism does not touch one friction variable
at a time. It moves all of them. We do not have to imagine what this looks
like. It is governing America’s largest city. In June, Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s
Rent Guidelines Board froze rents on about a million New York apartments. What
we see is the promise of “affordable housing.” What we don’t see is the
developer who moves his mid-rise to Nashville, the pre-war building that never
gets renovated, and the tenant who, a few years from now, can’t find an
apartment at all.
And this is just rent control in New York City. Add
zoning, environmental review, historic preservation, minimum-lot-size
requirements, parking mandates, and years of permitting delay, and we have a
U.S. housing sector that has been shrinking relative to growing demand for half
a century. And we wonder why young families can’t afford a starter home?
New York State lost a net $76.7 billion in taxable income
to other states between 2019 and 2023, before the new mayor had frozen a single
rent. Before Mamdani took office, the city had already lost 5,000 businesses in a single quarter. Now, thanks to
Mayor Mamdani’s good intentions, Wells Fargo is moving its wealth-management
headquarters, and its top wealth executives, to West Palm Beach, closer to the
clients who already left. Physics is preparing a demonstration for New York
City and the Empire State. It’s not one residents there are going to like.
A fluid engineer who reaches the Reynolds threshold does
not think of incremental reform. He removes constrictions. He reroutes the
flow. He replumbs. Below the threshold, a system responds to corrections. Above
it, the intervention required is of a different kind.
Which brings us to a question few of our leaders ask: If
we built our government from scratch today, would it look anything like what we
have? No one would design a Federal Register that adds a hundred thousand pages
a year. No one would build a government that cannot count its own agencies.
Another true fact: Depending on which official list you consult, the number of
federal agencies runs from about 60 to more than 430. We have a government that
cannot count its own pipes, much less measure their impact.
Every piece of the pipe has a defender, a lobbyist, and a
story. The people who are subject to the friction in the pipes have none of
those things. What the physics demands is the willingness to eliminate whole
functions of the federal government rather than prune them, and to return to
the states and the free market the powers that should never have been given to
Washington.
None of this is radical. It’s how we scale the
intervention to the challenge.
The stakes are clear: Turbulent flow always demands a
response. Britain got Thatcher. Argentina got Milei. But Russia got Lenin, Cuba
got Castro, and Venezuela got Chávez. Every nation past its Reynolds threshold
eventually produces its political answer. Some replumb the pipes. Others
lengthen them and weld the valves shut. In the United States, our choice is
urgent: Either we simplify the plumbing and get our lives and our economy
flowing again, or we suffer the political version of a heart attack, delivered
by socialists who propose Medicare for All for every political ailment. Their
revolutionary agendas will soon dominate the U.S. Senate and the House.
The audience smiled at King Arthur because they knew what
he did not. Weather does not bend to royal proclamations. Neither does
government friction. Every rule that government passes narrows the pipe of
American life, roughens its walls, and lengthens the journey. The price is paid
in businesses that never start, homes that are never built, and turbulence when
the Reynolds number climbs too high.
The 2026 elections are over. The turbulence has arrived.
Can we still build a government whose laws respect the physics it cannot
repeal? Yes, we can. We need a good plumber, not a king, but we do not have
much time.
No comments:
Post a Comment