By Mike Nelson
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
The 2028 Republican field seems much more open than it
did just a few weeks ago when allies of J.D. Vance were shouting down any
suggestion that the vice president’s path to nomination was anything less than
certain. Vance’s full-throated advocacy for some of the worst candidates and
messages of the 2026 midterms, his morning-after
attempt to distance himself from the foreign policy of the administration
of which he is a member, and the president clearly sidelining him on Iran are
all pretty good reasons why rumors he may decide to sit out the next election
are starting to circulate.
It would be poor form for those eyeing a 2028 run to say
so officially this early, but anyone entertaining the idea is starting to
jockey for position and command the attention of the various factions of the
conservative coalition he or she would need to build.
Following up his high-profile speech last month in Athens, Secretary of
State Marco Rubio gave the keynote address to the Federalist Society convention on
Friday evening, the kind of speech that might be intended to generate such
buzz.
Rubio’s speech covered a wide range of topics pertinent
to his current foreign policy portfolio that might demonstrate the kind of
leadership and vision the conservative movement would look for in a
presidential candidate. Among these was the administration’s decision to
sanction the International Criminal Court earlier this year. The decision and
general objection to the ICC are born out of the idea that multinational
organizations to which the United States is not a party cannot exert power,
influence, or authority that would deny American sovereignty.
This opposition to the ICC’s authority has been a
standard, to varying degrees, across multiple presidencies, with George W. Bush
formally withdrawing from the Rome Statute in 2002 and signing legislation
compelling the United States to secure the release of any American
servicemembers should they be prosecuted by the ICC. Even Bill Clinton, who
signed the Rome Statute two years prior, stated at the signing that the ICC should have no bearing
over U.S. citizens unless the United States ratified the agreement as a treaty,
a measure the United States never took nor that any president, Republican or
Democrat, ever pursued. Further, Rubio said in his speech, the ICC’s actions
indicate not an impartial adjudication of international law, but rather an
imbalanced scale that seeks outcomes, plays favorites, and fails to recognize
the international order created, protected, and maintained by the United States.
To make his point, Rubio quoted Roman general and
politician Gnaeus Pompey Magnus. If the ICC were to attempt to enforce its
decrees, Rubio said, “Our answer will probably be the same as the Roman
general, Pompey, when he said to those who were trying to invoke their cities’
charters against his legions. He said, ‘Stop quoting laws to men with swords.’”
This quote is where Rubio’s point goes a little—okay, a
lot—off track. What appeared to be Rubio’s point was that the United States
will not subordinate its sovereignty to the faux authority of a make-believe
court with make-believe laws, and will defend that sovereignty accordingly.
Perhaps he meant to imply, correctly, that international law and order exist to
the extent they do because of American force, and perhaps the international
community should be grateful for, rather than contemptuous of, the historical
examples of justified use of American force—a worthy statement. Perhaps Rubio
would have done himself more of a favor by sticking with his own rhetorical
formulations rather than leaning on a quote that is actually counter to the
larger point he was making, anathema to the very founding ideals, and for which
he seemed to lack the historical context.
Pompey did indeed say those words to the citizens of the
Sicilian city of Messana—Roman citizens—while acting in the service of Lucius
Cornelius Sulla. Sulla had consolidated power as a dictator and was engaged in
a campaign of purges, executions, and proscription of those he deemed political
rivals, some of whom had fled to Sicily. When Messana challenged Pompey’s
authority to conduct a tribunal, based on established Roman law, he responded
with his now-famous quote. In other words, it’s roughly akin to police arriving
at a citizen’s door, demanding to search the place, and countering requests for
a warrant by pointing out they have guns.
It’s also worth noting that, beyond acting on behalf of
anti-republican forces, Pompey helped set in motion the events that ended the Roman Republic permanently
and, ultimately, was beheaded bywhen other men with swords compelled an
outcome.
In other words, while claiming to advocate for
sovereignty and the rights of citizens and democracies, Rubio specifically
invoked an example of dictatorial coercion and the threat of tyrannical
violence by a government against its citizens—who had appealed to the
legitimate and established laws of their own country.
Rubio seemed to be blending and confusing two
antithetical concepts, the first being a realistic understanding that all the
high-minded ideals in the world may not matter if they cannot be protected from
those who would counter or destroy them. History is full of examples supporting
that idea. Consider that, a year prior to adopting a Declaration of
Independence—itself a list of high-minded ideals and appeals to natural law—the
Continental Congress first raised an army that would be needed to make that independence
a reality. There could be no imposition of justice at Nuremberg had the Allied
forces not first invaded Germany and defeated the Third Reich. But the second
concept, the one Pompey represented in his ominous threat to Massana, counters
the first precisely: the idea that strength alone justifies outcome. The
Founders, prior to declaring independence, made several appeals to the British
government: Was the patriot cause less just without an army? Would Nazi evil
have been justified if it had not been countered? This is the same kind of
“might makes right” rationalization embodied by Stalin’s famous quip when he
dismissed the pope’s influence by asking how many divisions he commanded, or
the same lesson taken from those who read the Melian dialogue—summarized by its most famous quote that
“the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must”—as a license
to exercise unbridled power without restraint rather than a warning against it.
Using the quote is a bit of an unforced error from Rubio,
who normally stands out as an island of competence and thoughtfulness in a vast
sea of perpetual rake-stepping Cabinet secretaries. The quote itself might have
gone largely unnoticed if not picked up and amplified by one of Rubio’s many
less capable peers. Never missing an opportunity to generate content, Defense
Secretary Pete Hegseth boosted
a State Department social media post about the speech with “Stop quoting laws
to MEN WITH SWORDS” added for emphasis. Hegseth’s post seems to have gotten
much more attention than Rubio’s original utterance—a few seconds of an
hourlong speech—and drowned out any other substance from the text.
It’s not the first time Hegseth has latched onto a quote
he thinks sounds cool without concern for applicability, appropriateness, or
even accuracy. He famously held a prayer service at the Pentagon, wherein he
said a “prayer” he cited was based on Ezekiel 25:17. It, in fact, was not based
on Scripture but was derived from dialogue from Pulp Fiction that
claimed to have been based on the biblical passage, but was more of an homage
to a Sonny Chiba martial arts movie. Perhaps it’s fitting that Hegseth had
paraphrased Jules, Samuel L. Jackson’s character in the Tarantino classic,
because, in a moment of the kind of introspection of which Hegseth seems
incapable, Jules says of the phrase,“I just thought that was cold-blooded sh**
to say to a motherf***er before I popped a cap in his a**.” Hegseth indeed
loves the slogans that sound like some “cold-blooded” stuff to say, but never
takes the time to think about what they mean.
There are those who defend Rubio and Hegseth’s use of the
quote, suggesting it should be taken at face value, divorced from the context of who said it, why
Pompey said it, or what happened to him as the logical conclusion of the very
vision of force he had espoused. But when taken at face value, it is a clear
endorsement of force as virtue untethered from morality. These defenders will
further cry that it is solely an endorsement of American defense of our values
and sovereignty against feckless bureaucrats across the oceans. If that’s the
case, then perhaps we should expect Cabinet secretaries who can articulate
that—as Rubio did right up until the quote—without muddying the waters by
citing speakers or ideas unworthy of inclusion.
For Rubio, including the quote was a mistake if he wishes
to demonstrate the kind of thoughtful leadership that unifies American ideals
at home and strong foreign policy abroad, that acts on a consistent worldview
rather than on impulse, and that maintains the world order America created. For
Hegseth, his amplification is another example of compulsive dedication to image
over substance, at best a childish fixation on slogans he thinks sound cool and
at worst further reason to believe that Hegseth views violence, force, and
power as virtues unto themselves even when divorced from a moral cause
unleashing them, virtuous conduct guiding them, or achievable goals they seek
to accomplish.
Because after all, America needs both laws and men with
swords. But history is full of various factions of men with swords who rose to
primacy, some virtuous, but many more base, craven, evil, and dedicated to
conquest and self-interest. What makes America unique is not having men with
swords. It’s having men with swords dedicated to preserving the laws.
No comments:
Post a Comment