Tuesday, November 17, 2026

What If Democrats Don’t Succumb to Disarray?

By Noah Rothman

Monday, November 16, 2026

 

The emerging conventional wisdom now holds that while Democrats have a momentous political opportunity on their hands, they will probably mess it up. The Democratic Party will “get in their own way,” succumb to “infighting,” and, when the victory parties subside, revert to a general and familiar state of “disarray.”

 

But what if they don’t?

 

Republicans have not seriously grappled with even the hypothetical prospect of a Democratic Party that not only conceives of itself as the majority party in America but also acts like it.

 

Democrats have been given the chance to rebrand themselves and cast off the stink of the Biden years. What would such a party — one that conceives of itself as a majoritarian political vehicle — look like? Well, it might look a lot like the party that is currently iterating a new version of itself right before our eyes.

 

It would be one that’s “nicer and more optimistic,” as Axios summarized the advocacy of influential Democrats such as former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg and California Governor Gavin Newsom — traits Axios’s reporters also saw evinced in Amy Acton and James Talarico’s successful 2026 campaigns.

 

Caveats and cautionary notes abound, of course.

 

Democrats who assembled last week in Denver for a convention of party insiders warned their co-partisans that they are “on probation,” in Congressman Jason Crow’s words. The 2026 electorate didn’t write Democrats “a blank check,” Senator Ruben Gallego said. “Not one of them gives a damn about political litmus tests or where we fall on some imaginary political spectrum,” Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro agreed.

 

That same admonition now appears regularly in America’s legacy media outlets.

 

A New York Times profile of “politically homeless” voters in the middle of the electorate, some of whom backed Democratic candidates “for the first time in their lives,” will prove useful to the Democrats who hope to curb the activist left’s enthusiasm. Those voters have not “suddenly become Democrats.” Rather, theirs “was more a practical choice” designed to curb Donald Trump’s excesses and signal to Washington their general displeasure with the status quo.

 

Likewise, the Wall Street Journal warned Democrats that voters gave the party an opportunity and nothing more. “Voters are becoming less attached to the parties their parents voted for and are more likely to try out new parties or new political pitches, on the left and right,” its reporters cautioned. “And while they are willing to give insurgent parties or populist figures such as Trump a shot, they will also lose patience quickly if they don’t deliver.”

 

The party’s leaders may take such warnings seriously. Some already are.

 

A majoritarian Democratic Party would, it stands to reason, be a more religious party — or, at least, a less self-consciously secular one. Kansas Senator-elect Adam Hamilton, a Methodist minister and seminarian, appears to see no conflict between his religious affinities and his political commitments. Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear, too, makes no effort to shield his faith from voters’ eyes. It’s a soft-focus religiosity, though, and it’s “working,” in conservative radio host Erick Erickson’s estimation, because it contrasts favorably with cultural aggression he sees on offer from the “antisemitic racists and white victimhood cultists” who populate the internet with content.

 

A Democratic Party that wants to represent most Americans would not eschew the kind of incrementalism encouraged by the Constitution. In the near term, that will entail co-opting Donald Trump, whispering sweet nothings in his ear, and “giving him a few wins” along the way to their ultimate political triumph, as Axios reported. That’s why you see a diverse array of Democrats — from Michigan’s Abdul El-Sayed to Mississippi’s Scott Colom — appealing to the president’s vanity as they attempt to flatter him into submission.

 

Of course, El-Sayed and Colom represent distinct factions within the Democratic Party’s ideologically heterogeneous congressional majorities. When it comes to the party’s governing agenda, there is no consensus. But the party’s leaders have drawn up a path forward that is certain to frustrate progressives.

 

The far left wants to nationalize the health insurance industry. Leadership seeks only to reverse Medicaid cuts and restore Obamacare subsidies.

 

Progressives seek to tax the wealthy, and they seem more enlivened by the expropriation than by what they supposedly want to do with the wealth they would requisition. Hakeem Jeffries wants to expand the Child Tax Credit.

 

Majoritarian Democrats are more than happy to let Donald Trump claim credit for permitting reform if it allows the next president — a Democratic president, preferably — to preside over an infrastructure construction boom. The environmentalists are not — not when they think Democrats are “greenwashing” the “infrastructure for fascism,” anyway.

 

And while the loudest factions on the activist left will not be satisfied by anything other than Donald Trump’s impeachment, conviction, and removal from office, party leaders are talking their base voters out of indulging their passions.

 

The Democratic Party’s skeptics have earned their overwhelming sense of déjà vu. They’ve seen this movie before, and they know how it ends.

 

The Democrats have shoved their activists to the side before, and they’ve seen that enterprise fail. They are right to expect that the socialists in Congress, as well as those in control of so many major American metropolises, will wield the loudest factions within the Democratic firmament like a weapon. They can anticipate that progressives will make the perfect the enemy of the good and alienate would-be partners. They can foresee the conditions that will encourage performance art and discourage good governance.

 

Those are sound predictions. Surely, some political entrepreneurs will emerge to exploit the sense of abandonment felt by the majority party’s most uncompromising and dogmatic supporters. The majority has taken their base voters for granted, they’ll shout. Fat and happy, the majority party has become as out of touch as the elites against whom they once campaigned. They’ve forgotten who their constituents are, gone soft in office, and sold out the little guy only to feather their already cushy nests.

 

When that dynamic reemerges, it may knock establishmentarian Democrats off course. But the opportunity is there. While the 2026 election moved the nation “to the left some,” Yuval Levin wrote, “it actually moves the internal ideological centers of gravity of both parties to the right.” Paradoxically, the breadth of the Democratic Party’s majorities will make it easier for its leaders to sideline the radicals.

 

Perhaps progressives chafe at suddenly finding themselves a minority within a party that now includes many red-state Democrats and centrist voters. Maybe they mount a rearguard action that successfully sidelines the moderates. In that case, voters are likely to give the GOP a second look. But if Republicans believe Democratic disarray is a foregone conclusion and they don’t have to do much to win back the public’s trust, they’re pushing all their chips in on a very big bet.

 

Few appear to have considered the consequences if they lose that bet, perhaps because the consequences would be deep and lasting.

No comments: