By Tom Nichols
Tuesday, August 19, 2025
Donald Trump loves to speak extemporaneously, and
usually, he makes very little sense. (Sharks? The Unabomber?
What?) Trying to turn his ramblings into a coherent message is like trying, as
an old European saying goes, to turn fish soup back into an aquarium. But he is
the president of the United States and holds the codes to some 2,000 nuclear
weapons. When he speaks, his statements are both policy and a peek into the
worldview currently governing the planet’s sole superpower.
This morning, the commander in chief made clear that he
does not understand the largest war in Europe, what started it, or why it
continues. Worse, insofar as he does understand anything about Russia’s
attempted conquest of Ukraine, he seems to have internalized old pro-Moscow
talking points that even the Kremlin doesn’t bother with anymore.
The setting,
as it so often is when Trump piles into a car with his thoughts and then goes
full Thelma & Louise off a rhetorical cliff, was Fox &
Friends. The Fox hosts, although predictably fawning, did their best to
keep the president from the ledge, but when Trump pushes the accelerator,
everyone goes along for the ride.
The subject, ostensibly, was Trump’s supposed diplomatic
triumph at yesterday’s White House meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr
Zelensky and seven European leaders. The Fox hosts, of course, congratulated
Trump—for what, no one could say—but that is part of the drill. A Trump
interview on conservative media is something like a liturgy, with its
predictable chants, its call-and-response moments, and its paternosters. Trump
ran through the usual items: The war was Joe Biden’s fault; the “Russia, Russia,
Russia hoax”; the war never would have happened if Trump had been president.
Unto ages of ages, amen.
But when the hosts asked specifically about making peace,
the president of America sounded a lot like the president of Russia.
The war, Trump said, started because of Crimea and NATO.
Considering his commitment to being a “peace president,” Trump was oddly eager
to castigate his predecessors for being weak: Crimea, he said, was handed over
to Russian President Vladimir Putin by Barack Obama “without a shot fired.”
(Should Obama have fired some? No one asked.) Crimea, you see, is a beautiful
piece of real estate, surrounded by water—I have been to Crimea, and I can
confirm the president’s evaluation here—and “Barack Hussein Obama gave it
away.” Putin, he said, got a “great deal” from Obama, and took it “like candy
from a baby.”
Trump did not explain how this putative land swindle led
to Putin trying to seize all of Ukraine. But no matter; he quickly shifted to
NATO, echoing the arguments of early Kremlin apologists and credulous Western intellectuals that Ukraine existed only as a “buffer” with the West, and that
Putin was acting to forestall Ukraine joining NATO. Russia was right, Trump
said, not to want the Western “enemy” on their border.
This might be the first time an American president has
used Russia’s language to describe NATO as an enemy. Perhaps Trump was simply
trying to see the other side’s point of view. He then added, however, that the
war was sparked not only by NATO membership—which was not on the table anytime
soon—but also by Ukrainian demands to return Crimea, which Trump felt were
“very insulting” to Russia.
Trump is a bit behind on his pro-Kremlin talking points.
The Russians themselves long ago largely abandoned any such blather about NATO
and Crimea. Putin claimed early on that Ukraine was infested with Nazis—in the case of Zelensky,
apparently Jewish Nazis—and that even if it weren’t for NATO and Nazis,
Ukraine is organically part of Russia and belongs under Kremlin rule. For three years, Putin has been slaughtering Ukrainian
civilians to make the point that his Slavic brothers and sisters need to either
accept that they are part of Russia, or die.
Trump then stumbled through a discussion of security
guarantees, wandering off topic repeatedly while the hosts tried to shepherd
him back to the safety of their questions. And then the president of the United
States showed the entire world why the past few days of international diplomacy
perhaps haven’t been going so well, and why a delegation of European leaders had to parachute into Washington to stop
him from doing something reckless.
“Look,” Trump said, “everybody can play cute, and this
and that, but Ukraine is gonna get their life back, they’re gonna stop having
people killed all over the place, and they’re gonna get a lot of land.”
Notice how the president described people getting killed
as if mass death is just a natural disaster that no one has any control over.
(Later, he added that he was in a hurry to get to a peace deal because
thousands were dying each week—again, as if people were perishing from
regularly scheduled earthquakes instead of Russian bombs.) His comment about
Ukraine getting lots of land also betrays his default acceptance of Moscow’s
imperial demands: The land Trump is describing already belongs to Ukraine, and
any deal that does not return all of it is a net loss. The American president,
however, is speaking as if Kyiv should be grateful for the scraps of territory
that Trump and Putin will grudgingly allow to fall from their table.
And then the discussion got worse. “Russia,” Trump
ruminated, “is a powerful military nation.” (Well, yes.) “You know, whether
people like it or not, it’s a powerful nation. It’s a much bigger nation,”
Trump said. “It’s not a war that should have been started.” (Again, a perfectly
reasonable statement.) “You don’t do that. You don’t take on a nation that’s 10
times your size.”
Wait, what? Who doesn’t take on a bigger nation?
Who does Trump think began this war?
Trump’s answers to the uneasy Fox courtiers summarized
his belief that Ukraine, not Russia, was the aggressor, merely by refusing to
roll over and hand its land and people to the Kremlin. The president seems to
have embraced Putin’s sly use of the term root
causes (an expression Putin used again in
Anchorage). When the Russian dictator says “root causes,” he means Ukraine’s
continued existence as an independent nation, which Russia now views as the
fundamental justification for its barbarism.
Trump then bumbled into several other verbal brambles,
but none of them mattered as much as this revealing moment. Zelensky and
Ukraine are the problem, and the rest is just an ongoing tragedy that the
Ukrainians can end by being “flexible” and by putting their president in a room
with the man conducting atrocities against them.
In the end, Trump even suggested that cutting through the
knot of war in Ukraine could be the ticket to salvation. “If I can get to
heaven,” he said, “this will be one of the reasons,” because he will be
recognized, presumably, as one of the great peacemakers. As for Putin, Trump
knows they can work together: “There’s a warmth there,” he said of his
relationship with an indicted war criminal. Blessed, perhaps, are the
warmongers.
No comments:
Post a Comment