Sunday, February 7, 2021

What Killed Humor?

By Joseph Epstein

Thursday, February 04, 2021

 

If you know of any working comedians, or television sitcoms, or comic writers you think genuinely amusing, please don’t hesitate to let me know about them, for I have in recent years been suffering a fairly serious humor deficiency. I cannot remember the last time I smiled even faintly at a New Yorker cartoon. I cannot get through most current stand-up comedy routines. Seinfeld was the last sitcom I enjoyed. Something has happened to the GNH, or Gross National Humor, which for a long while now has been plunging steadily downward.

 

Perhaps the “gross” in GNH is a mistake, for much of what’s passed for humor over the past few decades has not wanted for grossness. In the standard choreography of progress — one step forward, two steps back — the removal of censorship has put a serious dent in comedy. In an earlier day, when jokes about masturbation, fellatio, and menstruation were not allowed on public stages, comedians were forced to be more inventive and relied on social observation, irony, timing, language artfully deployed — all qualities that comedy shared with good writing. With so many comedians now working blue, no longer, and distinctly not for the better, is this so.

 

Not that a touch of grossness, artfully applied, isn’t funny, or even sometimes appropriate. On November 29, 1963, I was in the audience at a New York movie theater for a performance by Lenny Bruce. Bruce had to work in the movie theater because he had lost his New York cabaret license over an obscenity-law violation. November 29, 1963, of course, was one week after the assassination of John F. Kennedy. Without introduction or musical fanfare, Bruce walked out from behind the curtain, paused briefly, and, in a conversational voice, said: “ ‘Oswald,’ it’s a f***in’ rabbit’s name. And who doesn’t know a putz like Jack Ruby.” He then went on to register the shock of a now long-forgotten comedian, Vaughn Meader, whose chief stock-in-trade was a Kennedy impersonation and who, Bruce claimed, when told of the death of the president, said: “But I’ve had 50,000 T-shirts printed!” Bruce then shifted smoothly into a skit about a Jewish nightclub owner offering one of his Puerto Rican busboys $50 to have sex with Sophie Tucker, the singer then appearing at his club and who in the skit is assumed to be an insatiable nymphomaniac. The punch line, delivered in a strong Spanish accent, was: “I don’t care what you say, Mr. Rosenberg, I’m not going to schtup her!”

 

More comedians seemed to be at work in that day. But, then, there were more places for them to display their talents. Television no longer offers what were once known as variety shows, the most popular of which at the time was The Ed Sullivan Show, which ran from 1948 to 1971 and introduced innumerable stand-up comics, among them Richard Pryor, Joan Rivers, Flip Wilson, Alan King, Phyllis Diller, Jackie Mason, Rodney Dangerfield, George Carlin, and others. So big was comedy that some comedians had their own shows — Bob Hope, Milton Berle, Jackie Gleason, Carol Burnett, Steve Allen, and Dean Martin and Jerry Lewis — on which still other comedians appeared. Your Show of Shows, starring Sid Caesar and Imogene Coca, was so popular and so amusing that people stayed home on Saturday nights to watch it. Johnny Carson was known for introducing new young comedians on his late-night talk show and having older established comedians — Jonathan Winters, Don Rickles, Shecky Greene, Dangerfield — as fairly frequent guests.

 

The range of comedy was in itself fairly impressive. Rickles did insult humor, Winters went off on wild imaginative flights, Burnett did pleasing physical humor, Mason did heavily Jewish material, and Wilson riffed on black culture, while both Rivers and Diller worked the veins of female vanity, sensibility, and resentment, and Steven Wright played off the comedy of literalism (“Went into a restaurant whose menu said ‘Breakfast Anytime,’ so I ordered French toast in the Renaissance”). The Dick Van Dyke Show and, later, The Mary Tyler Moore Show were what today would be called “must-see TV.” I’m not sure anyone noticed at the time, but it was a golden age of comedy.

 

An entire branch of comedy, now quite gone, was that done by (mostly) men known as “impressionists.” They did imitations of famous movie stars and occasionally of politicians. Two of the better known among them were Frank Gorshin and Rich Little. Gorshin’s caricatural impressions of Kirk Douglas and Burt Lancaster made it impossible for me ever again to watch the movies of either of these actors without inwardly giggling. The standard repertoire of the impressionists included imitations of James Cagney, Edward G. Robinson, Bette Davis, John Wayne, and others. So far as I know, no impressionists are at work today. Of whom, after all, could they do impressions? Brad Pitt, Gwyneth Paltrow, Adam Schiff, Leonardo DiCaprio? Personalities, whether in movies or public life, no longer exist who seem worth imitating.

 

In the private realm, there is joke-telling, the act of friends telling friends jokes they have heard. When I hear what I take to be a good joke, I am eager to pass it on. In Jokes and Their Relation to the Unconscious, Freud was quite wrong in thinking that jokes are inherently acts of unconscious aggression, but he wasn’t wrong when he called jokes “good news,” by which he meant that the creation of a joke meant someone was thinking.

 

Joke-telling may be generational, ending perhaps with my own generation (I was born in 1937), and heavily favored by certain Jews, or, as I think of them, Jokey Jakeys. I happen myself to be such a Jokey Jakey. On the first day of the one creative-writing course I taught, I asked the students to tell a joke. My reason for asking was that a joke is a mini short story. Not many of my students knew any jokes. The only one I remember from that class was about a mushroom coming home in tears to tell his mother he wasn’t invited to a party of the vegetables. His mother, attempting to comfort him, asked whether he had told the other vegetables he was “a fungi.”

 

Here are three jokes I have told recently:

 

(1) Malcolm Brown, age 98, at his annual physical, tells his physician he thinks he is slowing down sexually. His physician, astonished that a man of 98 would have any sex life at all, asks him when he first noticed this. “Last night,” Brown replies, “and then again this morning.” When his physician notes how remarkable this is, Brown answers, “If you think I’m remarkable, you should know that my father, at age 126, is planning to get married next week.” When the physician asks, “Why would a man who’s 126 want to get married?,” Brown replies, “What do you mean ‘want to’?”

 

(2) The police call on Mrs. O’Leary to tell her the sad news that her husband Paddy has fallen into a vat of dark beer at the local brewery and drowned. “I hope his death was at least a quick one,” Mrs. O’Leary, in tears, says. “I’m afraid it wasn’t,” the policeman replies. “How do you know?” Mrs. O’Leary asks. “Because,” the policeman replies, “he was seen three times leaving the vat to urinate.”

 

(3) Goldenberg, in his strong greenhorn accent, says to his friend Glickman: “I just bought a new hearing aid. Wonderful! Look, you can’t even see it in my ear. State of the art, state of the art! Cost $5,000. Magnificent! Untoppable! Like I say, state of the art.” Glickman asks, “What kind is it?” Goldenberg looks down at his wrist and says, “A quarter to three.”

 

***

 

None of these jokes is in especially good taste, but then I’m not sure that humor has much to do with good taste. Yet all three jokes, in the current political atmosphere, might be disqualified, their teller written off as crudely insensitive. The first is after all an example of what is called “ageism,” and what about the poor young woman that Brown’s aged father has made pregnant? The second plays on the old stereotype of Irish drinking and can be ruled out of bounds on the grounds of ethnic prejudice. The third, because of the name “Goldenberg” and the reference to his accent, just might be considered anti-Semitic while also mocking the disability of deafness. A more virtuous person, surely, would do well not to tell any of these jokes.

 

Make that “would do well not to tell any of these jokes during the current reign of political correctness.” In fact, under this reign he would do well to steer clear of any humor whatsoever. Whole categories of jokes must be forgone. All the old mother-in-law jokes would now be scored off as obviously sexist. Lenny Bruce’s joke about the Puerto Rican busboy and Sophie Tucker would be considered racist. All ethnic jokes are strictly verboten. Just about every other category of joke would be awarded one or another of the current day’s non-union labels: misogynist, elitist, or just generally offensive.

 

A shame that George Carlin, who died in 2008, isn’t alive to take on, through his attacking humor, the grave humorlessness of political correctness. Carlin it was who said that “there’s a different group in this country to get pissed off at you for everything you’re not supposed to say.” Political correctness, with its comfortable home in our universities, would make a lovely comedic target for any comedian with the courage to engage it. Doubtless it is an indication of PC’s threatening power that no comedian yet has. Comedians steer clear of it. Jerry Seinfeld, the most apolitical of comedians, no longer plays campuses because he feels that nearly every bit he does is likely to trigger anger in a university audience.

 

What passes for humor instead, or has for the past four years, are the late-night talk-show hosts — Stephen Colbert, Jimmy Kimmel, Seth Meyers, et alia — taking potshots at the ignorance and general repulsiveness of Donald Trump. Talk about an easy target. Because it is so easy, none of these men is especially funny, unless one has an advanced case of TDS, or Trump Derangement Syndrome, and so feels one’s disgust reinforced by their relentless mockery. One wonders what these men, these half-wits — “half” in that their wit is likely to appeal to only half the country — will do now that Trump has departed the presidency.

 

Politics can be death to humor, at least if the comedian takes a political side. Even so beloved a comedian as Bob Hope lost a good share of his audience when he came out in favor of Richard Nixon’s position on continuing to prosecute the Vietnam War. During the 2008 election, Sarah Silverman lost some fans when she did a bit encouraging children and grandchildren to threaten not to visit their elderly relatives in Florida if they didn’t vote for Barack Obama against John McCain. Too much of the current version of Saturday Night Live is political, and as for the cable channel Comedy Central, I watch it so seldom that I think of it as Comedy Peripheral.

 

Mort Sahl did political humor, and for all I know — he’s 93 and occasionally working — may still be doing it. But his political humor was without rancor. He found politicians generally, without distinction of party, worth mocking. I ran into Sahl one night in 1956 on Rush Street in Chicago, when he was playing the now long-gone nightclub Mr. Kelly’s. I told him that in Arkansas, the segregationist governor Orval Faubus was planning to run against J. William Fulbright for the U.S. Senate and wondered, if he won, would students henceforth study abroad on a Faubus? Sahl was mildly amused and, in the spirit of an eye for an eye, a joke for a joke, told me that a pre-presidential-election-campaign meeting between President Eisenhower and Adlai Stevenson had had to be canceled because they couldn’t find a translator.

 

Which brings me back to the old television variety shows, on which I first saw Mort Sahl. An episode of The Ed Sullivan Show might include an opera singer, an animal act, acrobats or jugglers, one or two comedians, and a popular singer. These were shows — The Garry Moore Show, The Perry Como Show, The Carol Burnett Show, and others — that three generations of the same family could amiably watch together. The reason is that the United States in those years had a more unified culture than it has now, or at least the dominant culture was not itself under attack.

 

This unified culture began to break up when a separate youth culture arose in the 1960s. Later, the black-power movement, forgoing integration, formed another, separate strand of American culture. The 1970s saw what is now known as the second wave of feminism, and this was closely followed by the gay-liberation movement. America was still one country, but now a country made up of several different strands of culture, and many within them feeling deprived, depressed, and mad as hell. None was in a mood for joking. Humor was out, anger in.

 

Is humor likely to make a comeback in that exasperatingly indeterminable stretch of time known as “the foreseeable future”? “Wouldn’t it be pretty to think so?” as Hemingway’s hero Jake Barnes says in The Sun Also Rises. But humor may have to await a less divided country, whose arrival no one can predict. Which is a shame. For a country without humor, one that cannot laugh at itself, one in which ample segments of the population go about ticked pretty near the max, doesn’t, let’s face it, figure to be much fun.

Saturday, February 6, 2021

Emmanuel Macron Envies America

By Cameron Hilditch

Saturday, February 06, 2021

 

Of all the peoples of the Earth, perhaps only Americans and Russians spend more time thinking about the soul of their nation than the French do. There’s a preoccupation with the national character in France — a kind of incessant introspection, obsessed with diagnosing the metaphysical maladies of the country — that’s especially pronounced. General de Gaulle summed up the attitude of the French to their motherland when he said that “France cannot be France without greatness.” When this greatness is manifestly absent, a crisis of confidence habitually flares up in the French body politic.

 

The global race to vaccinate the public against COVID-19 has triggered just such a crisis. As I detailed this past week, the European Union’s handling of vaccine procurement and distribution has been criminally bad. The Europeans are desperately in need of new vaccine patents after the EU bungled its contract with AstraZeneca.

 

France’s failure to develop its own vaccine has bruised the characteristic national pride of her elites. The country has an illustrious history of vaccination, stretching back to the great Louis Pasteur, who invented vaccines for rabies and anthrax. The storied Pasteur Institute was later at the cutting edge of treatment for HIV.

 

However, the Pasteur Institute abandoned its main COVID-19 vaccine project last week, and another French pharmaceutical company, Sanofi, also threw its hands up in defeat. This has triggered the typical soul-searching among French politicians.

 

The center-right Les Républicains parliamentary group tweeted:

 

In a race against the clock, the Pasteur Institute throws in the towel on its main vaccine project, while Sanofi announces a delay until the end of the year, because of a lack of efficiency, after so many grand announcements. This scientific decline is a slap in the face.

 

Meanwhile, in an interview with a French radio station, François Bayrou, a prominent ally of President Emmanuel Macron, described France’s dearth of vaccine innovation as “a sign of the decline of the country and this decline is unacceptable.” Interestingly, the embarrassment that French statesmen have shown on their country’s behalf in recent days has often expressed itself in the form of envy for American innovation and dynamism. Bayrou, for instance, lamented the “brain drain” of France’s best and brightest to the United States as a national humiliation. He was referring in this instance to Stéphane Bancel, the Frenchman in charge of the American biotech firm Moderna, whose vaccine is already being administered widely in both Europe and the U.S. “It is not acceptable that our best researchers, the most brilliant of our researchers, are sucked up by the American system,” Bayrou concluded.

 

No one, however, has voiced more frustration with European shortcomings or shown more unabashed envy for American innovation than the French president himself. During a meeting with a group of reporters last Friday, Macron said that he was “very admiring” of the “extremely innovative model” the Trump administration had put in place in the form of “Operation Warp Speed,” and expressed frustration that “Europe had a slower strategy.”

 

Being a Frenchman however, he could not let his analysis rest at the level of sheer technical achievement. He also mused upon the virtues of the American spirit. “I also think it’s a question of state of mind,” he told reporters. “How do we do good science as quickly as possible? The Americans did this very well, much better than us.” Macron put this down to the “less risk-averse” American way of life, which has allowed the United States to shorten clinical trials and fast-track the vaccine-authorization process. “What’s great,” Macron said, “is that we can benefit from what the Americans did, when they compressed the phase two and three of clinical trials, they allowed all of humanity to progress. It’s great.”

 

Three conclusions should be drawn from France’s failures and from the subsequent reflections of her statesmen upon them.

 

Firstly, it would be insane for the United States to pursue a policy of immigration restrictionism. It may be a great source of sorrow for Mr. Bayrou that France’s “best researchers, the most brilliant of our researchers, are sucked up by the American system,” but it is fantastic for America. The best and brightest of planet Earth have been pressing their faces up against the windows of American life for centuries, yearning to be let in through the front door. Turning them away in a fit of nativist pique to appease the restrictionist sentiments of some voters would be a supreme act of national self-harm. Indeed, the work of Stéphane Bancel is case-in-point of what makes America great.

 

Secondly, European statesmen, especially Macron, ought to be careful about their pursuit of “strategic autonomy” — the burgeoning desire among European elites to further centralize European power through the institutions of the EU. The stated purpose of this centralization is to make Europe less dependent on the United States in areas such as health care and industry, and, more importantly, to eventually allow the EU to project military power in its own interests, independent of the United States. Macron reportedly underscored these themes in a recent call with President Biden.

 

The French president should not labor under the illusion that Europeans will always be able “to benefit from what the Americans did” while pursuing strategic outcomes that do not align with the interests of the United States. The coronavirus pandemic has shown that when Europe is up the proverbial creek without a paddle, it still likes having Uncle Sam on speed dial as a last resort. Throwing the cell phone overboard to pursue “strategic autonomy” might not work out so well the next time the Old World hits rough waters.

 

Lastly, the failure of the French vaccine drive and Macron’s lament should remind us that rumors of America’s death, to amend a phrase of Mark Twain’s, have been greatly exaggerated. Prophecies of American decline are made, more often than not, by Americans themselves who are too close to the United States to see it against the backdrop of the wider world. But the view of America from across the Atlantic is quite different. It’s hard to see a city shining on a hill from within its own walls. It’s better seen from a far-off ridge, from which its shimmering light is thrown into relief by the darkness surrounding it: darkness that Macron, France, and all of Europe are well acquainted with.

The New York Times’s Internal Mob Takes Down Another of Its Own

By Charles C. W. Cooke

Saturday, February 06, 2021

 

Earlier this week, I wrote at length about the growing tide of illiberalism in the United States. This morning, I was forwarded an email sent out by the management team at the New York Times that illustrates precisely what I was talking about. For sake of clarity, I will quote the whole thing, starting with the preface:

 

———- Forwarded message ———

From: NYT Mail <*@nytimes.com>

Date: Fri, Feb 5, 2021 at 4:31 PM

Subject: A Note From Dean and Joe

To: All Company Employees <*@nytimes.com>

 

Colleagues,

 

We are writing to let you know that Donald McNeil Jr. will be leaving the company. Donald joined The Times in 1976 and has done much good reporting over four decades. But we feel that this is the right next step.

 

We do not tolerate racist language regardless of intent. We are committed to building a news report and company that reflect our core values of integrity and respect, and will work with urgency to create clearer guidelines and enforcement about conduct in the workplace, including red-line issues on racist language.

 

Every person in leadership at The Times is dedicated to building a culture where each of our colleagues feels supported and respected. It’s vital that we get this right. To those of you who have reached out to us with your honest and sometimes painful feelings about this incident, we thank you.

 

Donald has offered a statement to his colleagues, which is below.

 

— Dean and Joe

 

Based solely upon the information included here, one might think it plausible that McNeil had been let go for a good reason. There is nothing wrong per se with organizations trying to create a work culture in which their employees feel “supported and respected,” and it is not impossible to imagine circumstances in which “racist language” would impede that goal. To read McNeil’s “statement to his colleagues,” however, is to be immediately disabused of that suspicion:

 

To the staff of The Times:

 

On a 2019 New York Times trip to Peru for high school students, I was asked at dinner by a student whether I thought a classmate of hers should have been suspended for a video she had made as a 12-year-old in which she used a racial slur.

 

To understand what was in the video, I asked if she had called someone else the slur or whether she was rapping or quoting a book title. In asking the question, I used the slur itself.

 

I should not have done that. Originally, I thought the context in which I used this ugly word could be defended.

 

I now realize that it cannot. It is deeply offensive and hurtful. The fact that I even thought I could defend it itself showed extraordinarily bad judgement. For that I apologize.

 

To the students on the trip, I also extend my sincerest apology. But my apology needs to be broader than that.

 

My lapse of judgment has hurt my colleagues in Science, the hundreds of people who trusted me to work with them closely during this pandemic, the team at “The Daily” that turned to me during this frightening year, and the whole institution, which put its confidence in me and expected better.

 

So for offending my colleagues — and for anything I’ve done to hurt The Times, which is an institution I love and whose mission I believe in and try to serve — I am sorry. I let you all down.

 

Donald G. McNeil Jr.

 

Andrew Sullivan suggests that this reads like “a confession procured by the Khmer Rouge,” which is correct but understates the case. In order to extract its “confessions,” the Khmer Rouge used grotesque instruments of torture and hung the ever-present threat of the killing fields over those they were trying to control. The New York Times, by contrast, has . . . what? In Cambodia, the fact that the apologies were extracted under duress made the willingness of the targeted to acquiesce understandable, and, by extension, made it less likely that anyone watching would believe that the tortured really meant what they said. And in Manhattan . . . ? At one level, I am disinclined to blame the victim here. At another, though, I am absolutely appalled by McNeil’s failure to stand up for the truth, and for himself. At some level, at least, he must know that he is dealing with witch-hunting lunatics who, having entered themselves into a never-ending frenzy of self-righteousness, have lost their capacity to reason. At some level, he must know that there is a profound difference between using a racial epithet in the course of a discussion about that racial epithet’s use, and using a racial epithet to diminish or to wound someone. At some level, he must know that it is not only acceptable to ask in what context a word was used, but that if one wishes to comprehend what happened during a given incident, it is imperative. Or, put another way: At some level, the 67-year-old Donald G. McNeil Jr. must know that he has done absolutely nothing wrong.

 

And yet he won’t say it. Instead, he writes, “Originally, I thought the context in which I used this ugly word could be defended. I now realize that it cannot.” But of course it can. We are human beings, not robots trained to search indifferently for malicious words. To assert “We do not tolerate racist language regardless of intent” is, in practice, to assert that “we” are automatons without judgement. There is an enormous difference between a History professor’s discussing Jim Crow abuses and the repeating of those abuses themselves, just as there is an enormous difference between the casual use of derogatory terms and the text of Huckleberry Finn. What “Dean and Joe” are telling the world is that they, and those who are egging them on, are morons. What McNeil is telling us by caving to them is that he is prepared to be led by morons. McNeil suggests that “the fact that I even thought I could defend it itself showed extraordinarily bad judgement.” But the only “poor judgement” here is his own — for indulging this guff. I love my colleagues at National Review dearly, but I can tell you this much: If, tomorrow, they started insisting that 2+2 was 5, I would not consider that a vote had been taken and that I was consequently in need of reeducation. I would tell them to go to hell.

 

Alas, instead of doing just that, McNeil chose to take the complaints at face value and, in so doing, made everything worse — not only for himself, but for the next person who is targeted by this madness. Surely, it can not have gone amiss on him that he was being canceled after using a word for asking why someone else was canceled after using a word? And on spins the vortex.

 

McNeil suggests that his:

 

lapse of judgment has hurt my colleagues in Science, the hundreds of people who trusted me to work with them closely during this pandemic, the team at “The Daily” that turned to me during this frightening year, and the whole institution, which put its confidence in me and expected better.

 

In reality, of course, McNeil’s innocent question has “hurt” nobody. But, even if it had, what about the rest of us, who still have our senses about us? What of his readers? He mentions the Times as “an institution I love and whose mission I believe in and try to serve.” Well, what of that mission? Is this now it: to sacrifice sexagenarian journalists for trying to understand the world around them?

 

I have seen a few people trying to explain why McNeil decided to fall so abashedly on his sword, rather than to fight. Among them are that doing so was a condition of his severance package; that doing so was a play for future work elsewhere; and that, having worked for the Times for so long, he had in effect been institutionalized into considering it the final arbiter of truth. It is possible that one of these is correct, but, if it is, it says nothing good about the New York Times and its ilk. If McNeil was, indeed, bullied into this pose under threat of losing a pension or a redundancy package, then what is the point of the Times‘s famous union? If he felt that self-abasement would prove to be the price of readmission, then journalism as we have known it is dead. And if he considers the New York Times to be the final word on truth . . . well, then he shouldn’t be writing for the Science section.

 

“Dean and Joe” submit that their newspaper exhibits the “core values of integrity and respect.” I would submit that, over the last couple of years, their newspaper has demonstrated that it has no values whatsoever. Its staff is febrile and brittle, its editor is fearful and impotent, and its loyalties, insofar as they exist at all, lie with the latest fads and nothing else besides. Once, we feared that the barbarians would arrive the gates. Little did we know that our preeminent institutions would welcome them in, add them to their Slack channels, and give them free rein to hunt down the inquisitive, the heretical, and the free.

Democrats Will Regret Their Move against Marjorie Taylor Greene

National Review Online

Saturday, February 06, 2021

 

At least Marjorie Taylor Greene won’t have to spend time sitting at the end of the dais during long committee hearings.

 

House Democrats voted to boot her from her committee assignments in an act that they will surely come to regret, perhaps as soon as January 2023.

 

If the majority can keep members of the opposition party off of committees based on incendiary comments, it’s not clear why the GOP ever let, say, Maxine Waters serve on any committees when it had control of the chamber, or why it ever will again.

 

Kicking off Greene will come to be remembered as another inflection point in the steady unraveling of institutional norms on Capitol Hill.

 

That said, we believe that Republicans should have taken matters into their own hands and denied Greene her committee assignments to draw a line against malicious lunacy in their own ranks.

 

That Democrats had a gun to his head with their threat to have a floor vote on Greene’s committee assignments probably made it more politically difficult for Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy to act on his own. He did seek a deal with the Democrats to take her off the House Committee on Education and Labor and the Budget Committee and instead relegate her to the Small Business Committee.

 

When Democrats didn’t bite, McCarthy again condemned her past comments and wrung an expression of regret from her in an internal GOP meeting earlier in the week that she repeated on the House floor on Thursday. Her statement didn’t ring with sincerity, but it was better than nothing, even if she was immediately holding a combative press conference where she said, “I’m fine with being kicked off committees because it’d be a waste of my time.”

 

We have, no doubt, not heard the last of her.

Catchphrase Diplomacy Is Back

By Jimmy Quinn

Friday, February 05, 2021

 

For days, the White House teased Joe Biden’s first major foreign-policy address as a noteworthy event. Jake Sullivan, the national-security adviser, even made an appearance at the briefing room podium to talk it up on Thursday: “He wants to send a clear message that our national-security strategy will lead with diplomacy” and re-establish American strength on the global stage.

 

His boss delivered on that preview during his speech at the State Department later that afternoon. “America is back,” declared Biden, just as he did in his November remarks introducing his foreign-policy appointees. And he said it again for emphasis: “America is back. Diplomacy is back at the center of our foreign policy.” He’d said the same thing an hour earlier when he spoke to U.S. foreign-service officers.

 

No one promised that the speech would be particularly interesting. The 46th president’s first foreign-policy speech amounted to a hash of warmed-over talking points about standing with U.S. allies and the need to revitalize American democracy and strength at home.

 

Biden did make some news, announcing his decision to end U.S. support of Saudi-led offensive operations in Yemen and to appoint a special envoy to deal with the conflict. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin, the president said, will begin a review of the U.S. global force posture. And underscoring the extent to which this foreign-policy vision is about projecting a values-based diplomacy, Biden also announced a directive to focus U.S. efforts on the promotion of LGBTQ rights. To his credit, he also announced his intent to review and reverse particularly wrongheaded Trump-era policies, such as the Germany troop drawdown and the evisceration of America’s refugee resettlement efforts.

 

Working with U.S. allies is important, but the overriding vision that Biden presented about renewing national strength failed on two crucial counts.

 

His talk about alliances presupposed a wholly decimated U.S. global posture, rather than the mixed bag left by the previous president, whose early diplomatic missteps were eventually eclipsed by fourth-quarter foreign-policy successes. Donald Trump’s disinterested management of the policy process empowered high-octane foreign-policy advisers — who, among other things, built alliances to counter the Chinese Communist Party, isolate Iran, and forge diplomatic breakthroughs in the Middle East.

 

Although Trump alienated certain European allies — whose behavior doesn’t seem likely to change significantly with a friendlier U.S. administration in power — his administration revitalized the Indo-Pacific’s Quad alliance and built the Clean Network initiative to counter China. It left behind stronger coalitions to go after ISIS, and worked closely with Israel and the Gulf countries. (For all of Biden’s talk about alliances, he neglected to mention the U.S. alliance with Israel.) The new team can’t rely on such an obvious caricature of the previous administration forever.

 

Biden’s broader foreign-policy vision also falls flat because it fixates on meeting transnational challenges, such as climate change and global public health, while crowding out talk of confronting America’s authoritarian adversaries.

 

It’s not that the president didn’t talk about confronting Russia and China, but where he did, he emphasized cooperation on shared interests just a bit too much: “By leading with diplomacy, we must also mean engaging our adversaries and our competitors diplomatically, where it’s in our interest.”

 

As Biden went on to explain, this meant signing on to a five-year extension of an arms limitation treaty with Moscow in the early days of his administration while also continuing to call out Russian misbehavior, such as the attempted assassination of Alexei Navalny and his recent imprisonment. But the agreement on arms control failed to produce an outcome more in line with U.S. interests. And Biden pledged that, despite the Chinese Communist Party’s “advancing authoritarianism” and threat to human rights, intellectual property, and global governance, “we are ready to work with Beijing, when it’s in America’s interest to do so,” echoing comments made last week by Secretary of State Antony Blinken.

 

But “reclaiming our credibility and moral authority, much of which has been lost,” as Biden put it, requires a clear-eyed approach to confronting the CCP’s unique threat to human rights and global democracy. Biden set out to demonstrate a commitment to these values by emphasizing that the U.S. is working with its partners on a response to the coup in Myanmar, and by calling on the country’s military junta to relinquish power. But for all his discussion of values, he neglected to mention the human-rights elephant in the room: the recent disturbing BBC report on the systematic rape and torture of Uyghurs that goes on in Xinjiang’s concentration camps.

 

What interests can America possibly share with the Chinese regime? Biden himself has previously accused it of gross human-rights abuses, even genocide. The abject cravenness of the Chinese party-state should be the primary thing that the U.S. president highlights in a foreign-policy address, not the potential for cooperation.

 

Biden saw fit to spend more time featuring a set of vague paeans to press freedom, science, and fighting systemic racism. “America cannot afford to be absent any longer on the world stage,” he concluded. But for all the tumult of the Trump years, America was never actually absent. What has in fact returned is the misplaced priorities of the center-left foreign-policy establishment.

Friday, February 5, 2021

Our Illiberal Moment

By Charles C. W. Cooke

Thursday, February 04, 2021

 

Voltaire’s apocryphal maxim “I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it” is in the process of being turned squarely on its head. Today, a more suitable rendering might read: “I disapprove of what you say, you are exiled, goodbye.”

 

To be adequately maintained, classical liberalism demands three key virtues. Humility, so that each of society’s competing factions might comprehend that it will not always hold power. Tolerance, so that the habitual reaction to a difference of opinion is the shrug rather than the bayonet. And forbearance, so that the immediate rush of victory can be subordinated to longer-term ambition. Little by little, we are losing all three and, as they go, forgetting the good practices that have built, sustained, and improved our remarkable society for generations.

 

Thus far, these losses have been primarily limited to our culture. For now, the Supreme Court continues to stand athwart, especially in defense of free speech. But, with culture sitting upstream of the law, and with the institutions that are supposed to be the most committed to liberalism rapidly becoming the institutions that are the least committed to liberalism, we cannot expect that this will remain true forever. The New York Times is, of course, within its legal and institutional rights to issue craven apologies for the crime of having irritated its readers’ sensibilities, just as the paper’s staff is within its rights to pretend that a given column has meaningfully put them in “danger.” But it matters when it happens. Behavior breeds behavior, and every time the employees of Politico revolt because Ben Shapiro edited Playbook for a day, or the crew at New York magazine decides that it “can’t even” with Andrew Sullivan, or the team at The Atlantic insists that the appearance of Kevin Williamson’s byline represents a mortal threat, or CNN’s Oliver Darcy proposes that the competitors to the cable network for which he works should be shut down, our hard-won customs are damaged a little more. Read a piece about a contretemps at a major American press outlet and you will invariably learn of a split between the “old guard,” which is committed to free speech and pluralism, and the “woke young,” which is not. That old guard was a young guard once, though. And, one day, the woke young will be the woke old.

 

Our political antennae are trained to look for individuals with too much power, which, given the history of the 20th century, is no bad thing. And yet our current predicament is the product of a somewhat different phenomenon: the inward-facing mob. Why did the New York Times become an unbearable workplace for someone as moderate and open-minded as Bari Weiss? Because its staff, complaining and haranguing and egging each other on in Slack, put pressure on their bosses and all but took over the joint. Why did Twitter choose to delete President Trump’s account, and Amazon Web Services choose to delete Parler? Because the lower-downs pushed and pushed and pushed until the companies did “the right thing.” Why are due process and open debate recast as “apologism” on college campuses when the defendant or the speaker is disliked? Because administrators who should know better fear that their offices will be filled with protesters or that they themselves will be targeted. Much of the criticism of our new American illiberalism focuses in on the ideologies that inform it. Not enough of that criticism, however, is engaged in analyzing the motive. It is undoubtedly the case that a good number of Americans have swallowed whole the idea that classical liberalism is a smokescreen for all sorts of insidious isms. But an even bigger number, one suspects, are simply using the weapons they’ve been handed. One need not be an incisive student of history to understand that when a man is told that he can silence his critics by merely claiming to feel “unsafe,” he will quickly claim to feel unsafe.

 

As for those of us who have no interest in silencing anyone? Well, we face the age-old liberal problem of being obliged to advance our arguments in defense of someone — or something — that is unpopular. When, in 1978, the American Civil Liberties Union defended the right of Holocaust-denying neo-Nazis to march through a Chicago suburb with a sizeable Jewish population, its leadership was asked why it was spending its time and resources in the service of such a repugnant endeavor. But this, of course, was the wrong question, predicated on the wrong assumption. In practice, the ACLU was not defending, endorsing, or empowering neo-Nazism but conserving an imperative principle: that even the least favored of all figures within American society are entitled to their rights. That the ACLU considered the neo-Nazis to be revolting was not beside the point so much as it was the point. Yes, few Americans would have wept had the neo-Nazis been denied their permit — or, even, had they been arrested. But, at various points, the same was true of other reviled minorities, including those who happened to be correct — among them, abolitionists and civil-rights advocates. As the ACLU had learned over the years, one cannot pick and choose whom to defend based on one’s personal moral preferences without setting legal and cultural precedents that one will eventually come to regret.

 

***

 

Today, this notion is under threat. Consider, by way of example, the manner in which self-described liberals habitually talked during Robert Mueller’s interminable investigation into the Trump campaign. The mere fact that Trump had been accused of colluding with the Russian government was sufficient warrant for many to assume guilt; reports that the president or his associates might plead the Fifth Amendment were met with the insistence that “only criminals” would do such a thing; complaints about the FBI’s bad habit of finding process crimes to prosecute when it cannot find anything concrete were met with eye rolls; and warnings about the danger of, say, perjury traps were dismissed as distractions (“One easy way to avoid the ‘perjury trap,’ ” tweeted the New York Times’ Nick Kristof, stupidly: “Don’t lie.”) Even the denouement was grotesque. At the press conference announcing his findings, Mueller invented an entirely new standard of guilt, and nobody batted an eye. “If we had had confidence that the president had clearly not committed a crime,” Mueller explained, “we would have said so.”

 

Oh, is that how it works in America?

 

Because the targets of the investigation were Donald Trump and his entourage, all of the Left’s traditional skepticism toward such shenanigans disappeared instantly, while those who demanded that it be restored were denounced as naïfs or stooges or “anti-anti-Trumpers” or whatever other description happened to be doing the rounds at MSNBC that day. But the skeptics, as usual, were right. Donald Trump is a well-connected septuagenarian billionaire and was, at the time of the investigation, the president of the United States. Which is another way of saying that Donald Trump was about as well placed to weather the storm as it was possible for an American to be. Do you know who isn’t so well placed? Almost everyone else, that’s who. There is a reason we all know that scene from A Man for All Seasons, in which Sir Thomas More berates William Roper for his willingness to bend the rules (“And when the last law was down — and the Devil turned round on you — where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat?”), and that reason is that it is timelessly true. We may fancy ourselves to be more advanced than the Tudors, but we still cannot cut down the rules that protect the Devil without cutting down the rules that protect the saints.

 

A similar mania obtained during the Brett Kavanaugh saga, certain parts of which would have been considered a little too on-the-nose by the denizens of Salem. Within hours of the accusations having been brought by Christine Blasey Ford, many figures within the Democratic Party and the press had begun referring to Ford as a “victim” or a “survivor” — designations that, by definition, can be bestowed only after an evidence-based tribunal has demonstrated culpability. From there, they never let up, even after it had become obvious that no such evidence would be forthcoming — and, indeed, after key witnesses had confirmed that they had no memory of what had been alleged. Among the ploys attempted by Kavanaugh’s opponents were that he should be disqualified purely because he had been accused; that his anger and upset at having been described as, among other things, a gang-rapist was evidence of both his guilt and his unsuitability for the bench; and that because other men who attended similar elite schools have behaved badly, he should simply be presumed to have done whatever terrible things the worst actors in the press and the legal profession could dream up. For a few weeks in late 2018, it seemed as if America’s commitment to liberalism was being tested and that America was failing that test spectacularly. Had Senator Susan Collins not come out swinging, it would have.

 

Still, I suppose we can’t say we weren’t warned. In 2014, Ezra Klein laid out the progressive position on campus sexual-assault cases, arguing in Vox that while critics might “worry that colleges will fill with cases in which campus boards convict young men . . . of sexual assault for genuinely ambiguous situations,” such a development would in fact be “necessary for the law’s success.” Or, put another way, Klein proposed that women as a category were at risk, so we should knowingly sacrifice some men — a repugnant approach that represented a flat disavowal of the principle that individuals should be judged on their merits. Alas, Klein’s submission was not an outlier. As has been made clear by his relentless attempts to strip due process from college students, Joe Biden, the current president of the United States, agrees with Klein completely — and, if anything, wishes to take his foolishness further. In 2016, during a speech in Pittsburgh, Biden contended that no woman who accused a man of sexual assault should ever have to answer questions such as “Were you drinking?” or “What did you say?” or to have her claims examined in any way that implied they might be untrue. “No one,” Biden continued, “particularly a court of law, has a right to ask any of those questions.” Thus we can see the progression: from academia, into the newspapers, back into the colleges, and then into the law.

 

***

 

To adopt Biden’s approach would be, in effect, to abandon all the fancy “evidence” stuff that we’ve insisted on for a few centuries and go back to weighing witches. I exaggerate, yes, but only a little, for if due process is to be cast as the opposite of justice, and if the details of a given case are to matter less than the characteristics of those involved, then why bother with the formalities? Perhaps the most frustrating part of our illiberal turn has been how closely it resembles the other illiberal turns from which we seem to believe that we have learned. It should be clear by now that principles such as free speech, due process, and equality under the law cannot survive contact with political favoritism. And yet political favoritism continues to be offered up as if it were a panacea. The architects of Proposition 16 may have believed that they were being frightfully modern when they tried to empower the government of California to treat citizens differently depending on their race, sex, or ethnicity, but in practice they were just dragging us back into an ancient mire. Max Boot may think he is advancing truth and light when he calls for his least favorite cable channels to be silenced by the state, but in truth he’s just a good old-fashioned censor, uttering those good old-fashioned words “but this is important.” Joe Biden and Ezra Klein may suppose they are helping to prevent further indignity when they demand that tribunals make prejudgments, but in reality they are condemning a whole class of Americans to suffer based on an immutable characteristic. And those kids who stand up and chant so that Charles Murray can’t give an address? They may think they’re fighting fascism, but they’re not: They’re emulating it. As liberalism was unable to coexist with Jim Crow, so it is unable to coexist with the progressive hierarchy of victims. We are either equal, or we’re not. We either extend charity to all, or we extend it to none. Now, as ever, liberal is as liberal does.

 

A few weeks after Brett Kavanaugh was approved by the Senate, The Atlantic’s Jemele Hill reported back from an event she had attended at “an auditorium with 100 black men in the city of Baltimore.” She had expected, she said, “to hear frustration that the sexual-assault allegations against him had failed to derail his Supreme Court nomination,” but instead she “encountered sympathy.” In fact, to “applause, and an array of head nods,” one man had even stood up and asked, “What happened to due process?” This had shocked Hill, who proceeded to explain that the black men in question were wrong to feel sympathy for Kavanaugh because, as a white man, he enjoyed privileges that they never would. But it was the black men in Baltimore who were right, not Hill, for they grasped that one cannot selectively abuse our liberal order without damaging it for everyone. Hill is undoubtedly correct to observe that Kavanaugh is privileged and powerful, but, as in the case of President Trump, she fails to grasp that that is precisely why it was so important that we set a good example. If what happened to Kavanaugh were to become the norm, figures such as he might well be able to ride it out. But everyone else? Not so much. Sometime soon, the hideous standards that were crafted and reinforced by those attempting to bring down Kavanaugh will be used against someone with no power, money, name recognition, or institutional backing. Perhaps then Hill will understand?

 

***

 

Conservatives should remember this, lest they become so angered by the trend that they give in to the same temptation to which Hill succumbed and end up burning themselves with their own fire. In many quarters, including this magazine, conservatism continues to play its role as the primary protector of America’s liberal order. And yet in other parts of the Right, including in the Trump White House, we have seen the rise of a host of self-consciously illiberal figures who have decided that because the system does not always yield their preferred results, the system must be junked. These people are wrong. To guarantee America’s future for everyone, we do not need a dictatorship but a robust federal system that is capable of accommodating profound differences in moral judgment and a culture that respects dissenters irrespective of where they sit on the political spectrum. I certainly understand the frustration that the post-liberals of the Right feel. But I do not understand their strategy. We cannot restore the principles of free speech, religious liberty, and genuine pluralism by aping the behavior of their enemies.

 

And if we try, we will lose. The Left’s descent into authoritarianism has been appalling to watch, but at least it has been explicable. Once, progressivism was the counterculture and needed liberalism to advance itself. Now that progressivism is the dominant culture, it has no such need. What, though, is the Right’s excuse? Suppose, for the sake of argument, that for a brief moment the government were empowered to crack down on profanity or pornography or “drag-queen story hour” or whatever is concerning illiberal conservatives today. Then what, when the pendulum swings in the opposite direction? Are we seriously supposed to believe that there is a political market for 13th-century integralism in America?

 

I’ll answer that one: There is not — thank goodness. Instead, our best friends are still our better angels, and our best bet is still the open order we have spent years assiduously protecting. History is littered with examples of men who, when pressing their case in the public square, have thought solely about the interests of their land, tribe, religion, or self; but it is sprinkled only lightly with men who, in making their arguments, have taken care to respect the enduring principles that have served to break the old cycles of strife, faction, and war. In the United States today, we seem increasingly drawn to the tribalistic over the principled. If we act now, we’ll have time to put out the pyre. But make no mistake: The flames are rising.

Don’t Quit on the GOP

By Rich Lowry

Friday, February 05, 2021

 

After losing a national election, it’s natural that a political party goes through a period of soul-searching and internal turmoil.

 

The Republican Party, though, has taken it to another level.

 

President Donald Trump brought most of the GOP along for the ride during his conspiracy-fueled attempt to overturn the election.

 

His loyalists have been scouring the landscape searching for Republicans to censure or primary for insufficient loyalty to him.

 

The most famous Republican House freshman mused not too long ago about a space laser starting the 2018 California wildfires.

 

And Trump has maintained his hold on the party seemingly effortlessly.

 

This dismaying chapter has led to declarations that the party is doomed or calls to split it up.

 

A former chair of the Washington State GOP wrote in an op-ed in the Seattle Times urging, as the headline put it, “Let’s form a new Republican Party.” This prompted a Chris Cillizza item at CNN headlined: “Should Republicans disband the GOP?”

 

There’s been a spate of articles by erstwhile Republicans announcing they are done with the party.

 

Jonathan Last wrote a piece in The New Republic titled: “The Republican Party is dead. It is the Trump cult now.” Washington Post columnist Kathleen Parker declared: “The party isn’t doomed; it’s dead.”

 

This seems a mite premature about a party that represents roughly half the country and is on the cusp of a majority in the House, tied 50-50 in the Senate, and in control of the governorships in 27 states and both the governorship and state legislature in 22 of those.

 

If we are going to consider this geographically diverse collection of officeholders — whose careers in many instances pre-date Trump and will outlast him — a mere personality cult, the word “cult” has lost its meaning.

 

The fortunes of our political parties ebb and flow, and their iterations change over time, but they are deeply embedded institutions of our public life.

 

As Dan McLaughlin, my colleague at National Review, points out, the Republican Party has, since its inception, been a fusion of a classical liberal wing with a more populist, elemental conservatism.

 

What’s different about Trump is that he represents the ascendance of the populist wing after it had long been in a subordinate position in the party. Even he, though, retained key traditional policy priorities of the GOP, from tax cuts and judges to religious liberty and abortion.

 

That said, the party does need to get beyond Trump, who is a three-time loser now — in the 2018 midterms, in his 2020 reelection campaign, and in the Georgia special elections. In electoral terms, “all the winning” stopped circa November 2016.

 

If it feels now as though the post-Trump GOP will never arrive, American politics moves quickly. Richard Nixon resigned in 1974, leaving the GOP in utter disarray — and yet Reagan won a landslide six years later. The Tea Party sprang to life from nowhere in 2009 and had disappeared by 2016, subsumed into the Trump phenomenon.

 

There will inevitably be an overwhelming controversy in the Biden administration or a crisis that moves us beyond the politics of the Trump presidency and the immediate aftermath.

 

New issues will emerge, and there are plenty of talented, ambitious Republican politicians who think they are better suited to win a presidential election and serve as president than Donald Trump 2.0. The incentives are for them to slipstream behind Trump for now, but that won’t always be true.

 

The temptation to splinter from the GOP might be alluring to elements of both the populists and the Republican traditionalists, but this is a dead end.

 

The Republican Party is the only plausible electoral vehicle for any sort of right-of-center politics in America. It is worth fighting over, and it will be.

 

That struggle is sure to be toxic and unpredictable — except for the fact that at the end of the day the Grand Old Party will still be standing.