Sunday, July 12, 2026

Let’s Treat Criminals Like (Dare I Say It?) Criminals

By James Lileks

Sunday, July 12, 2026

 

The city of Minneapolis has a problem with open-air drug markets. Main cause: permitting open-air drug markets. Now they’re cracking down. In announcing this new effort, the ever-earnest mayor, Jacob Frey, said: “This past month I visited [the] Little Earth [housing project], and I learned that there were four children that had stepped on discarded needles and required HIV prevention treatment.”

 

You would think this would be bad, but you have to balance the “problems” of punctured kids with the harm that might befall the needle-strewer if the authorities were summoned. Said one city councilperson, reacting to the  news of a crackdown: “Today, the City of Minneapolis and Mayor Frey announced a strategy that I consider the city’s War on Drugs. Let me be very clear, this approach will criminalize homelessness, criminalize those struggling with addiction, will worsen people’s life outcomes by giving them a criminal record that follows them for years, and will only expose our undocumented neighbors to deportations.”

 

Criminals getting criminal records? Well, we can’t have that. Deporting illegals who are doing fent in the playground? The Statue of Liberty would drop her torch and bury her head in her hands. Kids stepping on needles is the price we pay for a tolerant and compassionate society, and hey — it’s not like they can’t treat HIV these days. What we must do is address the structural causes for carelessly strewn needles. We must chew gum before we can even think of lacing up our shoes to walk.

 

This sympathy for the anti-social sorts flared up on Twitter/X this week, as one of the perennial debates flared up like a coal seam fire hosed with gas: what to do about miscreants who light up a joint in the subway. The answer, of course, is nothing.

 

If you must do something, ask him politely to cease his anti-social activity. This has the highest potential for a stabby reaction, but who knows? He could say “deucedly bad of me, old man, I’ve let myself down. Oughtn’t have breached the social contract with such flagrant disregard. Thank you for bringing me back within the fold of civilized behavior with the gentlest of verbal nudges.”

 

What you do not do, under any circumstances, is hold the rule-breaker accountable and advocate for consequences. Everyone else in the subway car — service workers heading off to their second job, mothers with children — should put up with the rich, aromatic smell of cigarettes or weed, because asserting some sort of civil norm is cruel to the smoker. You absolutely cannot alert the authorities, because it’s likely The Agents of the Carceral State who show up to assert the power behind the bourgeois “quality of life” statutes will kill someone. According to the pro-miscreant caucus on X, when the cops show up, it goes like this:

 

Cop #1: Buddy, put out the cigarette.

 

Smoker: [Penetrative expletive] you.

 

Cop #2: (sighs, looks at partner) Is it your turn to shoot him? I think it is? I shot the last one. I remember because I was doing the paperwork and ran out of ink.

 

Cop #1: No, I shot the last one. Remember? We caught him putting gum under the seat and I told him it was against the law and he just looked at me funny and I shot him? Remember? The deaf guy?

 

Cop #2: Oh right. (shoots smoker)

 

Happens a dozen times a day. Now imagine when those blood-maddened civil servants have carte blanche to enforce the basic rules of public decorum all the time in the subway. Or even above ground in Minneapolis or San Francisco or Philly, where the open-air drug markets do brisk business. An absolute fascist dystopia. Sure, it would be nice if transit was safe and the streets were clean and the kids could cavort in the playground unpierced, but not if it’s for the wrong reasons.

No comments: