Wednesday, February 10, 2021

Economic Nationalism 2.0

By Kevin D. Williamson
Thursday, February 04, 2021

Republicans embraced some un­likely things in the Trump years — from bonkers conspiracy theories to the music from Cats, which alternated with the Village People’s “Macho Man” at Donald Trump’s campaign events — but the most consequential of these strange new passions is: central planning. Republicans thus ensorcelled should be somewhat relieved by the election of Joe Biden, whose ambitions regarding economic nationalism are identical to those of Trump in almost every aspect save the rhetorical.

Trump was fascinated by China as an economic bogeyman, and so is Biden. Trump aspired to a situation of defense autarky, under which normal market operations are policed in the name of national security, and so does Biden. Trump believed that aggressive reinforcement of trade barriers was the key to cultivating blue-collar employment in the United States, and so does Biden. Trump supported purely protectionist measures such as the Jones Act, which gives U.S.-flagged ships a monopoly on service between U.S. ports, against the advice of advisers such as Larry Kudlow, and Biden can’t get enough Jones Act: On top of “Buy American!” he demands, “Ship American!” Etc.

As President Biden moves to put more of the U.S. economy under direct Washington-based political regimentation, Republicans cannot pretend this came out of nowhere. Central planning of trade, manufacturing, transportation, energy, and other critical sectors of the economy is now a matter of broad bi­partisan consensus, comprising figures as notionally diverse as Tucker Carlson and Elizabeth Warren. When Senator Warren talks about “economic patriotism,” Tucker Carlson says she reminds him of “Donald Trump at his best.”

We are (mostly) all Nehruvians now, eager to see Washington patrol the commanding heights of the economy.

This will, of course, end badly.

It has begun badly, because the bed­rock assumptions of economic nationalism are at odds with the facts, prominent among them the fact that U.S. manufacturing, far from being “hollowed out” by trade, has continuously expanded since the end of World War II, with the United States seeing an increase in manufacturing output of almost 600 percent between 1950 and 2010, as the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago runs the numbers — even accounting for the steep recession following the financial crisis of 2008–09. U.S. manufacturing output is considerably higher today than it was when China joined the World Trade Organi­zation or when NAFTA was ratified, according to Fed data. What troubles the economic nationalists is not the decline of U.S. manufacturing but the success of U.S. manufacturing: As U.S.-based manufacturing has grown more technologically and logistically sophisticated, it has grown much more efficient, too: What used to take 1,000 factory workers to produce now takes about 167, according to the Fed. Manufacturing’s share of the workforce has declined dramatically, but this no more represents a hollowing out of U.S. manufacturing than the radical decline in the farm workforce represented the decline of U.S. agriculture.

This at least complicates, and in many cases eviscerates, the populist political narrative of U.S. vulnerability in regard to manufacturing. The labor calculus has changed, but the United States is no more vulnerable when it comes to steel and aluminum for military purposes than it is when it comes to wheat and corn: As Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis documented in a report to the Treasury Department, steel and aluminum consumed by the national de­fense apparatus amounts to about 3 percent of U.S. output of each metal, and even in the case of more specialized products such as high-purity aluminum, defense consumption is less than 10 percent of domestic output. And the choice between U.S. providers and Chinese providers is a matter more of rhetoric than of reality: More than 80 percent of Canadian aluminum is exported to the United States, while about 40 percent of U.S. steel exports are Canada-bound. That is not a vulnerability — that is a well-integrated international market enabling cooperation between two advanced countries with broadly overlapping economic and political interests.

Far from exposing a weakness in U.S manufacturing, the coronavirus epidemic has showcased its great strengths — innovation, flexibility, adaptability. When in the early days of the epidemic there were shortages of products such as hand sanitizer, and more consequential shortages of face masks and other personal-protective equipment, U.S. manufacturers responded very quickly — that bottle of Tito’s hand sanitizer is bound to become a collector’s item — and in fact moved so quickly that, as of this writing, there is a glut of PPE in the U.S. market and Demo­cratic lawmakers are pressuring the Biden administration to order big federal purchases to soak up the excess capacity in their districts.

Because the facts don’t support the case, Biden has resorted to making stuff up, as he has done throughout his political career. E.g., Biden complains that under the Trump administration, “federal government contracts awarded directly to foreign companies went up 30 percent,” a claim that is pure four-Pinocchio horse­pucky in the estimate of the Washington Post. Military contracts of all kinds went up during the Trump years, during which overall federal spending in­creased by one-fifth, but the share of DOD contracts (most federal construction contracts are Pentagon contracts) awarded to companies overseas actually declined, albeit only slightly. If you look at the countries with companies receiving a great deal of DOD contract money, you will not be surprised: They are Japan, Germany, South Korea, the United Arab Emirates, Afghanistan, and other places where there are big U.S. bases and operations. When you need to install 50 new toilets in Ramstein, you don’t fly the plumbers in from Milwaukee.

In reality, U.S. defense contracting already is subject to an absurdly protectionist regulatory regime — you can’t feed an American soldier in Herat Province a can of tuna unless that tuna was caught by a U.S. ship and processed in a U.S. facility. To the extent that U.S. military procurement does involve overseas countries, these transactions are governed by the reciprocal military-procurement pacts the United States has negotiated with two dozen other countries, as well as by “security of supply” agreements that allow the DOD to secure priority delivery on contracts with the overseas companies covered by them. These agreements are part of those big, complex bilateral and multinational trade pacts that populists love to hate.


“Economic nationalism” isn’t about national defense — it is about job-farming.

Manufacturing protectionism is a way to make factory jobs into political-patronage jobs — patronage jobs that don’t have to show up on the government’s budget, because these clients (and that is what they are) are not directly on the federal payroll. Looking after hometown jobs and local financial interests, which are the dominant interests here, is in very few circumstances the most efficient, reliable, or direct way to secure our national defense and often runs counter to U.S. national-security interests. And these protectionist policies are bad for U.S. manufacturing and the rest of the economy, too, creating market distortions that favor a handful of politically connected firms and industries at the expense of everybody else. That’s the plain truth about Marco Rubio’s “national security” case for sugar protectionism: Some very nice rich people in Florida get richer and everybody else pays more for their groceries.

Biden’s economic nationalism, like Trump’s, would essentially take the worst thinking behind the General Motors bailout and make it national industrial policy. For the politician, jobs are not a means to some end — Cadillacs, bales of cotton, iPhones — but an end in and of themselves. If Joe Biden could figure out a way to have GM hire 1 million Americans to make nothing, but to make it at $98,000 a year plus benefits, that would be, in his view, a smashing success. If you view people as a liability, as mouths to be fed — which economic nationalism does and must — then giving Bob a make-work job producing nothing of economic value is a fine policy, assuming somebody can pay for it, because it solves the Bob problem. Workers in firms benefiting from Biden-style protectionism don’t make nothing — they make things in a way that is less efficient than the way they would have been made without market-distorting nationalist policies. And that makes Americans, at large, poorer, because they have to pay artificially high prices for their own goods and services and pay artificially high prices for government procurement through their taxes.

If this were a question of, say, contracting with a Colombia-based firm to make guidance systems for nuclear missiles, then there would be a legitimate national-security concern. But such exceptions should be the exception, and they should be narrowly tailored and rigorously managed. We are not talking about that. For the most part, we are talking about cans of tuna and rolls of insulation, roofing materials and computer printers, and the special treatment accorded office furniture made by the captive labor of Federal Prison Industries.

Economic nationalism is corporate welfare in patriotic drag. It was a bad idea for the Trump administration, and the Biden administration may yet discover a way to make it worse.

Biden’s Weak Case for Returning to the U.N. Human Rights Council

National Review Online
Tuesday, February 09, 2021

The administration’s announcement forfeits an important diplomatic bargaining chip.

Secretary of State Antony Blinken announced Monday morning that President Biden has directed the State Department to reengage with the U.N. Human Rights Council. This decision prioritizes the administration’s PR strategy over concrete diplomatic results.

The case for “reengagement” with the council is based on a misrepresentation of Trump-era U.S. diplomacy in Geneva, and it perpetuates the deeply damaging narrative that says however flawed the Human Rights Council may be, it’s not worth rocking the boat to demand change.

The Trump administration withdrew from the council in June 2018, citing structural problems that bias it against Israel and the continued participation of serial human-rights violators. While it has occasionally done valuable work on Syria, North Korea, and a few other human-rights hotspots, the council is too often hijacked by its many authoritarian members. “Such a council, in fact, damages the cause of human rights,” said erstwhile U.N. ambassador Nikki Haley when announcing our departure.

Proving her right, last year, Russia, China, and Cuba all won their elections for council seats, and the body passed five resolutions critical of Israel and none criticizing its newest human-rights-abusing members. Their hold over the council is so deeply entrenched that some of the U.N. special-rapporteur positions that it created have only ratified deeply damaging authoritarian talking points.

The Biden administration isn’t completely oblivious to the problems that plague what Blinken called this “flawed body, in need of reform”; rather, it says that reengaging is the best way to prevent authoritarian regimes from using it to their advantage. But Biden officials are still wearing rose-tinted glasses, convinced that their sloganeering about human rights and multilateral engagement will be enough to bring about positive improvement.

Blinken notes that America will “engage with the Council as an observer,” as if this were a significant change in policy. But it’s not. Not only is there no such thing as observer status, but the previous administration also effectively continued to participate in council-related activities in such a capacity even after it had terminated its membership. It played a role in the “universal periodic review” of the human-rights records of countries throughout 2019 and 2020, and it organized events around Geneva about human-rights abuses in Venezuela and China’s Uyghur concentration camps.

In fact, until the U.S. officially seeks a seat on the council, the only true change is that Biden is ordering American diplomats to participate in some council meetings. Overall, though, the Biden administration is only loudly declaring that it will do what the previous team more quietly did — a message reassuring to European diplomats and human-rights NGOs.

Which leads to another fallacy espoused by the Biden administration’s narrative — European diplomats and NGO staffers, rather than the 2018 withdrawal, have posed one of the most persistent obstacles to meaningful reform of the council.

When the Trump administration took office in 2017, a formal reform process was already slated to begin in 2021, but officials refused to accept four more years of the status quo. And thus the administration — hoping that it could succeed where the Obama administration failed — began an aggressive campaign to change the council spanning some 200 meetings with diplomats and human-rights advocates throughout 2017 and the start of 2018. Diplomats first sought fundamental changes to the council’s anti-Israel agenda and its lax membership criteria, but when it became clear that these were politically unfeasible, they expressed their willingness to accept less-ambitious measures that would have changed its day-to-day operations.

Still, at every turn, U.S. diplomats were blocked. The European delegations killed a modest package that would have streamlined the council’s agenda and diluted debate about its numerous anti-Israel resolutions. The NGOs fought off a reform proposal that would have transformed their annual Human Rights Council candidates’ forum into an event run directly by the U.N. (The groups objected, of course, out of a selfish desire to continue holding these events themselves.)

In case there’s any doubt about the weak link when it comes to standing up to human-rights abusers at the Human Rights Council: Before Washington had even decided to leave the body, the Chinese delegation won adoption of a resolution endorsing “mutually-beneficial cooperation” and other Chinese Communist Party–approved language on human rights in March 2018. Only the U.S. voted against the measure. The European countries, fearful of antagonizing Beijing, abstained.

But after Washington left, the other democracies learned to fend for themselves, and when China proposed a resolution with similar language last year, most of them voted against it.

The Biden team should have tried to leverage the new clear-sightedness of these U.S. allies to first seek reform of the council before announcing its reengagement. The U.S. delegation could have quietly worked with the other democracies ahead of the council’s March session — which will kick off the 2021 reform process — conditioning its return on their support for reforms.

Instead, the new administration went for the splashier option that advanced its “Diplomacy is Back” narrative, likely gaining nothing of substance.

Tom Friedman’s Warped Love Affair with Communist China

By David Harsanyi
Tuesday, February 09, 2021 

In 2009, New York Times columnist Tom Friedman wrote these words:

One-party autocracy certainly has its drawbacks. But when it is led by a reasonably enlightened group of people, as China is today, it can also have great advantages. That one party can just impose the politically difficult but critically important policies needed to move a society forward in the 21st century.

Now, certainly, a rejection of basic human rights and dignity isn’t ideal, but has Tom told you about the solar panels?

Like many left-wingers fixated on the “climate crisis,” Friedman suffers from an acute case of authoritarian envy. Friedman’s focus of adoration is Xi Jinping and the People’s Republic of China, the world’s largest one-party state tyranny. On Chris Cuomo’s CNN show this week, the Pulitzer Prize–winner “was thinking, like, what are they doing in China today?”

Friedman imagines that 1.3 billion Chinese are contemplating serious environmental matters rather than wasting their time with a “knucklehead” like CNN fixation Marjorie Taylor Greene:

“They were probably thinking about some bad stuff with the Uyghurs and all of that, oh, for sure, but I guarantee you they weren’t wasting their time on this nonsense.”

I doubt the Chinese are “thinking about” the Uyghurs, since there’s no critical press allowed in China. But yes, Americans should be thankful that they don’t have to think about the sadistic state-sanctioned torture of women with electric batons, or the gang rape of 20-year-olds in front of hundreds of detainees, or genocide — at least, not in America.

Friedman once famously fantasized about America being “China for a day” so that “we could actually, you know, authorize the right solutions.” This isn’t just the rationalization used by every tyrant in history, but it’s also puerile. China isn’t interested in Friedman’s “right solutions.” Instead, it is building 250 new coal-powered plants right now — enough to power all of Germany.

Still, if, in your hierarchy of values, green public transportation sits above basic liberties, you end up saying things such as:

You know, Chris, do you know that it takes four hours and 18 minutes to take the bullet train from Beijing to Shanghai? And it takes 21 hours to take the train from New York to Chicago. And they’re both about the same distance.

Yeah, well, it takes fewer than three hours to take a plane from New York to Chicago, and we don’t even have to open concentration camps in order to pay for it.

New York Times Defends Star Journalist Who Doxxed Free Beacon Reporter on Twitter

By Ryan Mills
Tuesday, February 09, 2021 

The New York Times is defending one of its most controversial star journalists after she doxxed a reporter from a conservative news site who reached out to her for comment about one of her past Twitter posts using the n-word.

Late last week, Washington Free Beacon reporter Aaron Sibarium reached out to Nikole Hannah-Jones, an investigative journalist for the Times, asking her about a 2016 tweet in which she said there is a “linguistic difference” between the n-word that ends in “a” and the n-word that ends in “er.” Hannah-Jones spelled out both racial slurs in the 2016 tweet.

In response to Sibarium, she posted his inquiry on Twitter, including a screenshot with his phone number – a practice known as doxxing. On Monday she deleted the tweet after she received backlash, and also appears to have scrubbed her entire Twitter history.

Eileen Murphy, a senior vice president of communications for the Times, wrote in an email to National Review that “The inclusion of the phone number was inadvertent and when it was brought to Nikole’s attention, she deleted it.”

However, a Twitter exchange on Saturday – two days before she deleted the tweet – indicates that Hannah-Jones was aware even then that she’d posted Sibarium’s phone number. In the exchange, Uché Blackstock, a Yahoo News medical contributor, replied to Hannah-Jones, “Lol, and he included his phone number and thought you would actually call him,” to which Hannah-Jones replied only “Girl.”

According to the Times’ social media guidelines, “newsroom employees should avoid posting anything on social media that damages our reputation for neutrality and fairness.” According to the guidelines, Times employees are to “always treat others with respect on social media” and avoid making “offensive comments or do anything else that undercuts The Times’s journalistic reputation.” Employees who tweet an error or something inappropriate and wish to delete the tweet are directed to “be sure to quickly acknowledge the deletion in a subsequent tweet.”

Washington Free Beacon Editor in Chief Eliana Johnson told National Review in an email that “The behavior and the Times’s disingenuous response speak for themselves.” Sibarium similarly responded that Hannah-Jones’s “behavior speaks for itself.”

Sibarium reached out to Hannah-Jones while he was reporting on Times staffers’ responses to the recent ouster of star science writer Donald McNeil Jr., who acknowledged using the n-word on a 2019 New York Times trip to Peru for high school students. In a statement to his colleagues, McNeil wrote that he was asked at dinner by a student if he thought one of her classmates should have been suspended for using the racial slur in a video she made as a 12-year-old. While conversing with the student, McNeil used the n-word himself, he wrote.

“I should not have done that,” he wrote. “Originally, I thought the context in which I used this ugly word could be defended. I now realize that it cannot.”

Sibarium was reporting about a heated debate posted to a Facebook group for current and former Times staffers. Some staffers argued that McNeil’s dismissal was appropriate, while others said McNeil deserved “the benefit of the doubt,” and questioned why the newspaper’s union didn’t do more to defend him.

Dean Baquet, the Times’s executive editor, told staff in an email that, “We do not tolerate racist language regardless of intent.” However, the paper printed the n-word just last week in a profile of a Princeton classics professor, according to the Free Beacon.

Sibarium reached out to Hannah-Jones to ask if she believed that intent made a difference in regard to her tweet. Hannah-Jones won the Pulitzer Prize for Commentary for The 1619 Project, which aimed to reframe the nation’s history based on the consequences of slavery. Some historians have criticized the project for being factually flawed.

Tuesday, February 9, 2021

Operation: Pancake

Kevin D. Williamson

Tuesday, February 09, 2021

Politicians and journalists are inferior to dachshunds in many important ways, beginning with the fact that a dachshund will never lie to you. Politicians and journalists, unhappily, are a different story.

 

I recommend to you this Twitter thread from Thom Lambert, a Missouri law professor, about his former colleague, Senator Josh Hawley. Senator Hawley, who is looking to take over the conspiracy-kook caucus from Donald Trump before Marjorie Taylor Greene can get full control of it, is none too careful with the truth. Senator Hawley, in fact, “is lying,” Professor Lambert writes. “I hate to say that of a friend, but it’s true. He’s saying things he knows are false.”

 

The specific issue here is Senator Hawley’s false claim of a conspiracy by stock-trading platforms to protect hedge funds in the GameStop matter. But it could have been anything — and it could have been all too many politicians. Senator Hawley’s lies, Professor Lambert writes, are part of his “campaign to rail against the sort of coastal elites that, like him, went to schools such as Stanford and Yale and now, like him, have amassed power. This campaign, he hopes, will endear him to regular folks.” Perhaps Ted Cruz of Princeton and Harvard Law could give him some tips on how “regular folks” do things.

 

Professor Lambert’s basic criticism is all true enough, and the professor might have stopped there. But there’s more:

 

It’s an “end justifies the means” thing. The problem is that the end doesn’t justify the means, at least not for Christians. Jesus clearly taught that his followers are to be certain sorts of people, not to achieve certain ends. And a smart person who misleads others to gain power isn’t who we’re to be.

 

Which brings me to [First Things magazine]. The name “First Things” refers to a C.S. Lewis essay emphasizing the importance of keeping matters in their proper place, of not overvaluing (admittedly good) things that are of secondary importance to other things. Doing so, Lewis warned, may ironically destroy the value of the second thing that was improperly elevated above the first thing.

 

As Lewis elsewhere put it, “Put first things first and we get second things thrown in: put second things first and we lose both first and second things.”

 

For the Christian politician, electoral success and advancement is a second thing. Christian virtue—truthfulness, kindness, humility, peacemaking—must come first. “Seek ye first the kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things shall be added unto you.”

 

This new breed of Christian nationalist may retort, “Yeah, that’s a recipe for continued electoral defeat and ultimately anti-Christian policies.” To which Jesus responds, “What doth it profit a man to gain the whole world and yet lose his soul?”

 

[First Things] used to understand this. Its founder, Richard John Neuhaus, famously said that “culture is the root of politics and religion is the root of culture.” Get that? Religion (Christian virtue) is the first thing. Culture, and ultimately politics, follow.

 

The sort of “muscular” Christian who views political success as paramount for protecting religion, and thus as an objective to be achieved however necessary, puts second things first. As Lewis warned, we’re likely to lose both first things (virtue) and second (elections).

 

Some Trump-aligned Republicans have turned Cicero’s advice — Esse quam videri, “Be, rather than seem” — on its head. It’s an old con-artist strategy, a variation on the theme of “Fake it ’til you make it.” Elizabeth Holmes of Theranos, the defunct medical-technology company, seems to have believed that she could lie a successful company into existence: The lies would attract capital and influential friends, and these would enable her to actually build the company she pretended to have built. She wasn’t entirely wrong: The money came, and so did influential advocates and board members, including the late George Schultz. Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign was the Theranos of presidential runs, attracting money and influential friends — friends who would, out of shame at being conned or perverted loyalty, fight on the lie even when they knew it was a lie, knowing that the promises that were being made were based on nothing. Trump is a strong believer in his own ability to lie facts into existence: He describes the New York Times as “the failing New York Times” not because it is failing — far from it — but because he believes that creating the perception of failure at the New York Times may create the reality of failure, too.

 

Trumpists have been doing the same thing with National Review for years, albeit weirdly incompetently: Most of them seem to think that Bill Kristol is the founder/editor of NR (he ran the late lamented Weekly Standard), and they often advise your obedient correspondent to spend some time “outside of the Beltway.” The Beltway is a loop road in Washington, D.C. National Review is based in New York City. I live in Texas. (I think there must be a few NR writers who do in fact live inside the Beltway, but I can’t think of any offhand.) The Federalist reported that House Republicans were ready to oust Representative Liz Cheney from leadership and that she was trying to prevent such a vote. Federalist publisher Ben Domenech sneered: “If National Review wants to die on the 197-10 hill with douchebro Adam Kinzinger, be my guest.” But Representative Cheney did not lose in a 197–10 vote. She did not, in fact, lose at all, but won easily — and, in spite of the entirely fictious claims published in The Federalist and circulated by the likes of Representative Matt Gaetz and Steve Bannon, Representative Cheney was agitating for having a vote, rather than against it. Matt Gaetz would like to have Representative Cheney’s leadership position, and The Federalist would rather be something other than third-rate, and they believe that they can advance their interests by convincing others that their rivals are losers.

 

This sort of thing happens in matters great and small. Lou Dobbs has just entered a sudden retirement, and Fox News corporately and several of its current and suddenly former hosts are facing the potential of paying a very large settlement to Smartmatic, a company Dobbs and other Fox News conspiracy kooks plainly and unquestionably libeled, repeatedly. “Libel” generally is understood in U.S. law as statements that are (1) false (2) defamatory and (3) published with actual malice or reckless disregard for the truth. Reckless disregard for the truth may as well have been Fox News’s corporate motto during the Trump years. Fox News claims that Dobb’s cancellation was part of a series of long-planned changes at the network — which is transparent corporate bullsh** on top of Dobbs’s transparent bullsh**. I used to appear on Dobbs’s show regularly, and he never has been anything but gracious to me, personally, but there’s no pretending that this bullsh** isn’t bullsh**. These lawsuits will, I hope, provide a welcome reminder that bullsh** can be expensive. It should be.

 

As I said, great and small. I still hear pretty frequently about a supposed episode in which I went on Morning Joe and delivered an unhinged rant about executing women who have abortions. It never happened (I’ve been on the show a few times, and abortion never has come up) but NARAL claimed it happened, and some people want to believe such things. Great and small: There is a puzzling legend among certain social-media-centered progressives that I am in the habit of wearing capes. I have no idea where this comes from and assume that it is the usual middle-school taunt so readily resorted to by our intellectually sophisticated friends on the left. But it has been repeated far and wide, most recently by Elizabeth Bruenig of the New York Times. This is, for the Bruenigs, a kind of bizarre family tradition: Elizabeth’s husband, Matt Bruenig, himself an occasional New York Times contributor, once manufactured a quote that had me defending the racist antics of Donald Sterling, of whom I had never heard and about whom I’d never written a word. This wasn’t something “taken out of context” or misconstrued — it was simply made up, a pure fabrication. Why? Because he can. That’s not the sort of thing that keeps a writer out of the pages of the New York Times. Nobody who matters very much cares.

 

These are little things, but, of course, it does matter that people who write for the New York Times make things up and publish them. Taylor Lorenz of the Times recently smeared the venture capitalist Marc Andreessen, accusing him of having used the word “retard” as a pejorative in a conversation. This never happened. Andreessen never said any such thing in the conversation in question, and the only use of the word “retard” was from Felicia Horowitz, in the context of describing a group of stock-market enthusiasts who call themselves the “retard revolution,” ironically embracing the term of abuse Wall Street types have thrown at nobody investors on the Internet. How can you have a conversation about a group of people who call themselves x without mentioning x? This is what commands the attention of the New York Times.

 

Lies don’t matter, but the truth can get you fired.

 

Lorenz knows what she is doing: The Times recently fired a reporter for speaking aloud a racial slur in a conversation about a controversy involving the use of the same racial slur by a child. Lorenz perceives Andreessen to be a cultural and political enemy, because he has an independent streak, and so she sought to subject him to the form of ritual humiliation that currently masquerades as journalism at the New York Times and elsewhere, and perhaps try to ruin him financially. (Good luck with that.) It is a cult of conformism, and it is purely vindictive.

 

It matters that New York Times writers publish lies. It also matters why they publish lies. It matters that First Things publishes lies. It even matters, a little bit, that The Federalist publishes lies, if only because some people might be under the misapprehension that it has something to do with the real Federalist. As a matter of intellectual honesty, there’s no difference between what Elizabeth Bruenig does and what Donald Trump does: It is the same dishonest strategy pursued to the same end.

The Humiliating Art of the Woke Apology

By Rich Lowry

Monday, February 08, 2021

 

When people look back at our current era of woke intolerance, perhaps the most disturbing artifact will be reporter Donald McNeil’s apology upon his ouster from the New York Times.

 

The reason for his abject self-abasement is a bit of a mystery. He didn’t grovel to save his job — he was getting fired regardless. Perhaps he felt he needed to make a fulsome apology with an eye to future job prospects, or maybe he believed every word.

 

Regardless, this sort of self-accusation is not normal . . . except for in totalitarian states and in contemporary America.

 

The McNeil note to Times staff follows the pattern of other such apologies over the last year. We are a long way from the rote “I’m sorry if I offended anyone” apologies of yore, and a long way from “I wish in retrospect I had put that differently” apologies that might make sense, if warranted.

 

A routine feature of over-the-top apologies is the vast gap between the alleged offense and the depths of the confessions of wrongdoing. The tone and content of many contemporary apologies might be appropriate if, say, Aaron Burr were expressing regret for shooting Alexander Hamilton, or if Andrew Jackson were coming to terms with the enormity of the Trail of Tears.

 

Instead, we are talking about peccadilloes or non-offenses like McNeil’s using an offensive racial term in a conversation with students after one of them asked whether he thought it was right for a classmate to be punished for using the term as a twelve-year-old.

 

There is definitely an art to humiliating woke apologies, common patterns that appear across these attempts to appease the gods of taking offense.

 

Extreme Self-Accusation

 

The apologizer must make the rubble bounce regarding his or her own failures. In one of the multiple apologies for taking a swipe at Chrissy Teigen’s recipe business (and at Marie Kondo), food writer Alison Roman said that she was “stupid, careless, and insensitive.”

 

In an astonishingly far-reaching apology for the offense of having written in support of college football, Ohio State University professor Matthew Mayhew wrote, “I was wrong. And even worse, I was uninformed, ignorant and harm inducing.”

 

Moreover, according to Mayhew: “To consider the possible hurt I have played a role in, the scores of others whose pain I didn’t fully see, aches inside me — a feeling different and deeper than the tears and emotions I’ve experienced being caught in an ignorant racist moment.”

 

A Sweeping Statement of Harm

 

It’s never a handful of people who are offended but entire institutions and categories of people, evidently always rocked to their cores.

 

Donald McNeil, whose work on the coronavirus has gained renown during the pandemic, made it sound as though science coverage at the Times, and perhaps the paper itself, would be hard-pressed to recover from his innocent use of the n-word:

 

“My lapse of judgment has hurt my colleagues in Science, the hundreds of people who trusted me to work with them closely during this pandemic, the team at ‘The Daily’ that turned to me during this frightening year, and the whole institution, which put its confidence in me and expected better.

 

“So for offending my colleagues — and for anything I’ve done to hurt The Times, which is an institution I love and whose mission I believe in and try to serve — I am sorry. I let you all down.”

 

New Orleans Saints quarterback Drew Brees criticized kneeling last year, then quickly buckled under the resulting criticism. “I would like to apologize to my friends, teammates, the City of New Orleans, the black community, NFL community and anyone I hurt with my comments yesterday,” he said, leaving no one out. “In speaking with some of you, it breaks my heart to know the pain I have caused.”

 

The Poetry Foundation made a fairly typical statement of support for racial justice after the killing of George Floyd and then, when critics wrote a letter of condemnation for the supposed offenses embedded in the statement, the Foundation apologized — to pretty much everyone imaginable.

 

“To our community of contributors, subscribers, partners, and visitors which includes,” it noted, “but is not limited to, Black, Latinx, Indigenous, Middle Eastern, Asian, trans, non-binary, and queer people, undocumented and other immigrants, people with disabilities, and those struggling financially: we apologize for our silence in the face of crisis amid the call to dismantle institutional racism.”

 

The Berklee College of Music in Boston said after letting the police use its restrooms following George Floyd protests, “We understand that many members of our community feel betrayed. We are deeply sorry for the impact this had on our community and for perpetuating feelings of oppression, silencing, and marginalization. We will make a more concerted effort to consider the effects of our actions.”

 

The OSU professor Mayhew wrote, “I hate the fact that I have hurt my colleagues at Ohio State and the field of higher education, especially Black scholars whose careers have been spent studying Black lives. I am sorry for ignoring your scholarship. I hate that I have let down my Black friends and friends of color, whom I love.”

 

All of this, remember, for an article praising college football.

 

A Dawning Awareness of the Level of Offense

 

These apologies are little morality tales, where the offender realizes the error of not realizing how offensive he was.

 

“Originally,” McNeil wrote, “I thought the context in which I used this ugly word could be defended. I now realize that it cannot. It is deeply offensive and hurtful.”

 

The reporter added, “The fact that I even thought I could defend it itself showed extraordinarily bad judgement. For that I apologize.”

 

Brees realized that his comments “lacked awareness and any type of compassion or empathy. Instead, those words have become divisive and hurtful and have misled people into believing that somehow I am an enemy.”

 

Roman said she needed to learn the difference between being unfiltered and honest and uneducated and flippant: “I’m deeply sorry that my learning came at Chrissy and Marie’s expense.”

 

A Confession (Of Course) of Privilege

 

If there’s any upside to the original offense, according to these apologies, it’s the offenders realizing how shot through with “privilege” they are.

 

The Poetry Foundation said, “We acknowledge that we are predominantly white, and occupy other privileged identities.”

 

Roman confessed, “I’m a white woman who has and will continue to benefit from white privilege and I recognize that makes what I said even more inexcusable and hurtful. The fact that it didn’t occur to me that I had singled out two Asian women is one hundred percent a function of my privilege (being blind to racial insensitivities is a discriminatory luxury).”

 

Gratitude for Being Tutored by the More Enlightened

 

All the learning cited in these apologies wouldn’t have occurred without the instruction of the truly woke, who are accordingly due the greatest appreciation.

 

In an apology upon leaving the company for an article he wrote in 1987 opposing women in combat, then-Boeing executive Niel Golightly said the article was “painful because it is wrong. Painful because it is offensive to women. Painful because it reminds me of the sharp and embarrassing education the uninformed and unformed ‘me’ of that time received as soon as the piece appeared.”

 

The Poetry Foundation thanked those who slammed it: “We wish to express our deep gratitude and reverence to the authors of the community letter, to every person who signed in support, and to those who have spoken up in the past. Through our acceptance of institutional silence to questions and concerns raised, we have let you down.”

 

Roman professed herself “grateful to those who have already begun having difficult, important conversations with me in private.”

 

And, naturally, Mayhew thanked most fulsomely those who convinced him of his hidden racism: “I am immeasurably grateful to the grace extended by [several fellow academics] and for their willingness to work with me on these issues. I know they are taking a risk by partnering with me on this pathway. I know that they are carrying a burden by even taking any time with me. I want to thank them.”

 

***

 

There is one factor that undergirds every aspect of these apologies — it is fear, fear of the cultural power of the accusers, of their ability to ruin careers, reputations, and lives. These kinds of confessions aren’t wrung from the accused under threat of torture or exile. But they are in some real sense coerced, which is why they ring so false and are so alarming in a free society.

Are the Classics Racist?

By Rich Lowry

Tuesday, February 09, 2021

 

It was only a matter of time before Cicero got canceled.

 

The New York Times the other day profiled Princeton classicist Dan-el Padilla Peralta, who wants to destroy the study of classics as a blow for racial justice.

 

The critique of classics as stultifying and privileged isn’t new, but in the woke era this attack is more potent than ever and has a better chance of demolishing a foundation of Western education.

 

At a time when Abraham Lincoln doesn’t pass muster in the progressive precincts of America, poor benighted Homer, whose chief subject was toxic masculinity, probably doesn’t stand a chance.

 

In its report, the Times writes that the critics believe that the study of classics “has been instrumental to the invention of ‘whiteness’ and its continued domination.” Or as Padilla himself puts it, “Systemic racism is foundational to those institutions that incubate classics and classics as a field itself.”

 

It is rare to find other instances of scholars so consumed with hatred for their own disciplines that they literally want to destroy them from within. Presumably if an ultra-progressive astrophysicist concludes that his field is desperately out of touch with social-justice concerns, he simply goes and does something else for a living rather than agitating to have students stop learning about space.

 

One would think Padilla’s own amazing personal journey would, in itself, make the case for the wonders of the classics. He came here as a child from the Dominican Republic, lived in a homeless shelter in New York City, discovered a book on Ancient Greece and Rome — and with help from a mentor, got into a prep school and went on to get degrees from Princeton, Oxford, and Stanford.

 

For him, evidently, the classics weren’t very exclusionary, and indeed there’s no reason that they should be.

 

The rigors of Greek and Latin, the timeless questions raised by Plato and Aristotle, the literary value of some of the most compelling poems, plays, and tracts ever written, the insights of early historians Herodotus and Thucydides, the oratory of Pericles and Cicero, the awe-inspiring beauty of the architecture, sculpture, and pottery — all of this is available to anyone of any race, ethnicity, or creed.

 

To look at all these marvels and see only “whiteness” speaks to a reductive obsession with race that is destructive, self-defeating, and, in the end, profoundly depressing.

 

The Times complains that, paraphrasing critics, “Enlightenment thinkers created a hierarchy with Greece and Rome, coded as white, on top, and everything else below.”

 

There’s quite a simple reason, though, that Greece and Rome have been subjects of study and fascination for so long — their cultural, political, and legal contributions are so vast and enduring.

 

The Greeks gave us the example — flawed and incomplete to be sure — of democracy, and the Roman stamp is still discernible on our legal system and institutions.

 

Western thought and literature have proceeded throughout their history in dialogue with the classics, constantly interacting with the arguments, themes, and characters of those long-ago forebears.

 

This isn’t true of other ancient societies.

 

Of course, the Greeks and Romans were blinkered, exclusionary, repressive, and violent, but who wasn’t? Where in the ancient world did slavery not exist? What society afforded women equal status with men? Where did any ruler respect the dignity of all people?

 

A key difference between the Greeks and Romans and the rest was that their writers critiqued and lampooned their own societies. This willingness to engage in self-criticism became one of the hallmarks, and strengths, of Western culture.

 

The critics give the Greeks and the Romans the same treatment as the American project, ignoring what was exceptional about them for a monomaniacal focus on their failings, even if the failings were commonplace everywhere else.

 

They want to impoverish American college students and ultimately the Western mind in an act of ideological destruction. This is galling enough; it’s even worse that they call it progress.