Sunday, January 31, 2021

Biden’s Got a Berlin Problem Brewing

By Dalibor Rohac & Ivana Stradner

Sunday, January 31, 2021

 

Those who expect President Joe Biden to singlehandedly fix the transatlantic relationship are in for a disappointment. Although the new administration in Washington takes a far more sympathetic view of Europe than its predecessor did, it is not clear that the sentiment will be reciprocated — especially in Berlin.

 

Following nearly two decades of Angela Merkel’s leadership, Armin Laschet, premier of Germany’s most populous state, Nordrhein-Westfalen, was elected on January 16 as the new leader of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU). Barring large swings in polls before the parliamentary election in September, Laschet is on track to become Germany’s next chancellor.

 

That is bad news for efforts to repair the U.S.–EU relationship. The presence of Laschet at the helm of Europe’s largest economy would give a boost for those in Europe who are reluctant to take their obligations within NATO seriously and would risk tethering the EU closer to both China and Russia.

 

Much as Biden and Laschet are likely to see eye-to-eye on climate change and other “multilateral” issues, the presumptive German chancellor is a man of little patience with those who see the promotion of democratic values as integral to foreign policy. As such, he is likely to frustrate U.S.-led efforts to hold Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping, and other dictators accountable for their domestic and international practices.

 

For one, Laschet has a long record of pandering to Putin, or “Putin-Verstehen” as the German neologism goes. Unlike Merkel and other European figures, Laschet hesitated to condemn the recent arrest of Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny. More broadly, he believes that “while drawing attention to violations of human rights or developments in democracy that we regard as undesirable, we should refrain from itemizing what is going on in Russia and passing didactic judgment on each individual item.” The reason? “We need Russia for many issues in the world” — not least climate change since a Paris Accord without Russia would be only “worth half as much.”

 

It gets worse. When the Russian strongman annexed Crimea in 2014, Laschet’s main concern was with fashionable “anti-Putin populism” emerging in the West. A year later, he disputed the evidence of Russia’s election meddling and disinformation campaigns in Germany. In 2018, Laschet questioned Russian involvement in the Novichok attack on Sergei Skripal and his daughter in the U.K. Amid a chorus of U.S. and European critics of the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline, Laschet reiterated his support for the project earlier this month.

 

There was much to criticize about President Obama’s half-hearted response to the humanitarian catastrophe in Syria, which happened at the hands of the country’s brutal dictator, Bashar al-Assad. Yet curiously, in Laschet’s view, the U.S. administration’s main sin lay in its effort to “weaken Assad,” a supposed bulwark against ISIS-sponsored terrorism. Never mind that it was Assad’s atrocities, backed by Russia and Iran, that set in motion the largest refugee wave that Europe had seen since the end of the Second World War.

 

Unsurprisingly, Laschet opposed a ban on Huawei championed by other voices within the CDU, most notably Norbert Röttgen, the chairman of the Bundestag’s foreign-affairs committee and Laschets’s competitor for the party’s leadership. In Laschet’s view, “German business lives from international exports, also those to China.”

 

Laschet would not be the first German chancellor with questionable foreign-policy views. Gerhard Schröder, who served between 1998–2005, was subject to a barrage of well-deserved criticism after transitioning from the German chancellorship to high-ranking board positions in Russian energy companies. Merkel’s own geopolitical record is a mixed bag. On the one hand, she deserves credit for ensuring a united European front in maintaining the post–2014 sanctions regime against Russia. On the other, she has stood firmly with German business against Europe’s broader strategic interests, whether in the case of the controversial Nord Stream 2 pipeline or, more recently, on the EU–China investment treaty.

 

All of this bodes well for Russia and China, who seek to drive a wedge between the United States and Europe and undermine Western influence in the Balkans, post-Soviet countries, or in the Middle East.

 

While Laschet’s business-like approach to geopolitics has a long tradition in German foreign-policy thinking, the single-minded pursuit of profitable economic opportunities at the expense of broader strategic interests and values is a luxury belonging firmly to an era in which others — namely the United States — could be relied on to keep Europe safe and secure.

 

But Germans and Europeans should not fool themselves. Notwithstanding Joe Biden’s promise of a return to normalcy and to American leadership in the world, the benign old days are not coming back. And in the world that will likely greet a future chancellor Laschet, his seemingly level-headed economic pragmatism risks being proven hopelessly naïve and short-sighted.

Saturday, January 30, 2021

China’s Terrifying Return to Maoism

By Doug Bandow

Saturday, January 30, 2021

 

One of the few issues on which Democrats and Republicans agree is that the People’s Republic of China (PRC) has turned back toward Maoism. Xi Jinping’s regime is committed to eradicating the merest possibility that someone might have an independent thought.

 

The economy remains a socialist-market hybrid, while the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has made little effort to limit personal autonomy except where politics intrudes. However, just a hint of ideological disobedience now brings down the full weight of a vast domestic-security regime that spends more money than the People’s Liberation Army.

 

There are no easy policy answers for Washington. Repression is an essential part of today’s Chinese political system. It’s how current officials, starting at the top with Xi Jinping, retain their power, perquisites, wealth, status, and everything else that sets them apart from normal people. If there is an existential interest for the Chinese state, it is maintaining repression. The regime isn’t going to yield, irrespective of sanction, since its elites prefer power to anything else.

 

Violations of human rights are the norm in the PRC. In practice, civil liberties, free speech, and political freedom simply don’t exist there. China has essentially returned to the era of Mao Zedong, one of the CCP’s founders, who emerged atop the party after unceasingly brutal power struggles that shaped the party’s evolution.

 

The rungs on the CCP ladder were slippery indeed, as many once-dominant figures missed a step, plunging into the political netherworld below. Even Mao’s rise was sometimes interrupted. But he mixed determination, skill, and ruthlessness and ultimately outshone his rivals. He famously announced the creation of the People’s Republic of China in Tiananmen Square on October 1, 1949, and was responsible for virtually every brutal step taken by the CCP in its early years.

 

Mao’s most famous murderous episodes were the misnamed Great Leap Forward and the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution. It is impossible to know how many people died owing to his misrule — estimates range out to 100 million, but 35 to 65 million is probably closer to the truth. The terror felt even by his close colleagues, many of whom were exiled, imprisoned, or killed during the Cultural Revolution, did not end until his death in 1976.

 

Associates cowed by the Great Helmsman, as he was known, quickly moved against his widow and other radical associates, and summoned Deng Xiaoping back from exile to the capital. As Deng rose to preeminence, he freed an economy that once took socialism seriously. Equally important but less noted at the time, the CCP loosened controls over personal life. People gained power over their own lives.

 

There also was strong support for political liberalization, including from CCP General Secretary Zhao Ziyang. However, he opposed the bloody 1989 crackdown on demonstrators in Tiananmen Square and ended up under house arrest for the rest of his life. China’s hope for democratic reform faded, but otherwise the Chinese people remained far freer than before. The system, though authoritarian, was loose. So long as one did not challenge Communist rule, a certain amount of debate was allowed. There were independent journalists who reported primarily on provincial misdeeds and human-rights lawyers who fought repression in court. Foreign academic exchanges were common. Nongovernmental organizations could carefully critique government policies.

 

All of this began to change a decade ago and repression accelerated under Xi Jinping, chosen as party General Secretary in 2012. He focused on strengthening personal and party authority, and then on expanding state control over virtually every aspect of Chinese political life. Intellectual freedom has essentially disappeared.

 

The United Kingdom’s Conservative Party recently addressed this state of affairs in its Human Rights Commission (HRC) report on the full-scale, wide-ranging assault against individual liberty in almost all of its aspects. Explained the U.K. HRC: “The Chinese Communist Party regime has intensified an assault on all human rights throughout China — not only the atrocity crimes perpetrated against the Uyghurs and Tibetans, and the dismantling of Hong Kong’s promised freedoms, but violations [of] all human rights affecting every group and individual throughout the country.”

 

The breadth of the assault detailed by the report is extraordinary:

 

·         Fear of Muslim Uyghurs has led to the incarceration of a million or more people, mostly Uyghurs but some other nationalities too, in reeducation camps. Whether the term genocide rightly applies — the regime is essentially killing a culture, not a people — the hardship suffered is immense.

 

·         “Repression in Tibet has intensified” as well. Occupied in 1950 by the PRC, Beijing has sought to restrict the practice of Buddhism, crush separatist sentiments, and control the Buddhist hierarchy. That means “arrests of Tibetan activists, monks and nuns, and severe restrictions on freedom of expression, freedom of religion or belief and other human rights.”

 

·         Hong Kong’s travails have been in the news over the last couple of years. After slowly expanding Beijing’s authority in the former British colony in recent years, the PRC last year imposed a brutal national-security law “containing severe restrictions on basic freedoms” on the roughly 7.5 million Hong Kongers. The result was to dismantle in surprisingly short order “Hong Kong’s promised freedoms, human rights, the rule of law and autonomy.” Censorship is fast descending upon what formally remains an autonomous special administrative region.

 

·         “Torture is endemic, widespread, systematic and conducted with impunity.” Brutal imprisonment is common around the world but has extra impact when practiced in the world’s most populous state.

 

·         “Forced televised confessions are now commonplace.” They are procured through threats of harsher punishment and maltreatment of relatives. The practice has been used to discredit Westerners who are ultimately released.

 

·         “The Chinese Communist Party regime’s silencing of ‘whistleblowers,’ especially doctors and citizen journalists, at the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in serious human rights violations and the spread of the virus.”

 

·         “Freedom of religion or belief in China is under the most severe crackdown since the Cultural Revolution.” Only a few years ago, in many provinces, churches were left alone if they avoided politics; in Beijing I snapped a picture of a car with a Christian “fish” on its bumper. Today, ministers are arrested, churches are closed or destroyed, members are barred from bringing their children and forced to display communist agitprop, and the CCP even wants to rewrite Scripture. Islam, Buddhism, and Daoism are also under sustained attack.

 

·         The CCP is above the law. The regime emphasizes rule by law and rejects rule of law as in the West.

 

·         “Arbitrary arrests and disappearances are commonplace.” During the early stages of the coronavirus spread, citizen journalists reporting on the pandemic were detained or even quarantined.

 

·         “The China Tribunal concluded ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’ that forced organ harvesting from prisoners of conscience is perpetrated in China and amounts to a crime against humanity.”

 

·         Forced labor is widely used, and not just in Xinjiang. At least 83 Western brands may include such products in their supply chains.

 

·         “The Chinese Communist Party regime is building an all-encompassing surveillance state, and Chinese technology companies such as Huawei are at the heart of this operation.”

 

The report offers individual chapters filled with excruciating details on these and other examples of the CCP’s broad offensive against independent thought and action. Nothing on this list is new, though many of the problems are worsening. Moreover, the list is not exhaustive. For instance, Beijing has essentially destroyed the human-rights bar, once made up disproportionately of Christian attorneys. Most have been dispersed, disbarred, and/or imprisoned.

 

Independent NGOs such as the Unirule Institute have been shut down. Unirule was established in 1993. It advocated market-oriented economic reform, publishing articles full of Ph.D.-speak and holding conferences filled with academics and policy nerds, like me, while carefully avoiding the red line of challenging CCP rule. When I met with the staff in July 2019, their office had been closed, their executive director had been prohibited from traveling to America, their books had been banned from publication, and they were a month away from having their business license pulled. Such was the fear of the great and powerful Xi Jinping of any ideas about freedom being discussed by anyone anywhere in China.

 

Even noncontroversial academic cooperation is carefully scrutinized, and speaking invitations must be approved by Beijing. I discovered this when I showed up in Shanghai two years ago to speak at a maritime conference, only to be told that the organizers had neglected the final step, which had not been previously required. I spent the weekend playing tourist rather than discussing American policy toward the Indo-Pacific.

 

The so-called social-credit system monitors behavior and punishes those who do not faithfully follow regime dictates, including political dissenters. Beijing has sought to export this system. The PRC’s pressure has been growing on Taiwan, which China wants to turn into another subservient territory like Hong Kong.

 

For those interested in addressing the Chinese challenge, there is both good and bad news. The latter is simple: There is very little that the U.S. and West can do to force the PRC to change its internal policies. Maintaining control is an existential interest of the CCP, which will resolutely resist outside interference.

 

Specific targeted measures — barring suppliers from using forced labor, for instance, and insisting upon reciprocal press access — can achieve some positive results. Sanctioning specific Chinese officials delivers emotional satisfaction but doesn’t change policy. For instance, Hong Kong’s chief executive Carrie Lam, a CCP puppet, has had trouble finding a bank after Washington threatened financial penalties against any institution doing business with her. But the destruction of Hong Kong liberties continues apace.

 

On the positive side, China is a vulnerable not-yet superpower. Its weaknesses are manifold: hidden but pronounced political division, profusion of inefficient state enterprises, growing political interference with the economy, a rapidly aging population with a decided and destabilizing male imbalance, massive income gaps between coastal/trading centers and interior provinces, minimal soft power, absence of friends and allies, growing third-world resentment of Chinese commercial practices, and a vulnerable geographic position. It remains important not to underestimate the PRC’s potential. However, it would be foolish to bet against America and other free societies.

 

Most important may be the simple fact that what is will not ever be. That is, today’s rapid race to totalitarianism is a product of one man, Xi Jinping. At age 67, and with many enemies, he will not rule forever. And when he is gone, “Xi Jinping thought” might disappear as rapidly as Maoism dissipated after the Great Helmsman’s death. The Chinese couldn’t wait to dump overboard the reality of the mad Red Emperor’s rule even while preserving his image as the nation’s founder. Xi serves no similar foundational national role, and therefore could be almost instantly consigned to obscurity.

 

The U.S. and West should play the long game by focusing on expanding access to information in the PRC and appealing to rising generations. This is one reason it is important, despite security concerns, to keep American high schools and universities open to Chinese students. Young Chinese like their personal freedoms but are nationalistic. They aren’t interested in being told what to do or think, especially by the U.S. government. (I feel the same way!) Frankly, the ostentatiously maladroit and sanctimonious Mike Pompeo was no asset in this fight.

 

The PRC poses the greatest current international challenge to U.S. policy. It is vital to get America’s response right. The nature of the U.S.–China relationship will affect the rest of the world for years and potentially decades to come. The last previous great-power transitions — the rise of Germany and the Soviet Union — had catastrophic consequences. A prolonged violent struggle between America and the PRC could, in an unimaginable worst case, be even more costly.

 

Finding the right strategy is not just important for America. It also is important for the Chinese people.  Before the pandemic, I visited China regularly. Set aside today’s totalitarian challenge for a moment: It is an extraordinary civilization and fascinating country. Once the PRC is free, it will be an even better place. Ultimately, only the Chinese people can transform the system that controls them and limits their future.

Biden’s Blue-State Clawback

By Matthew Continetti

Saturday, January 30, 2021

 

No one can accuse President Biden of easing into office. His first days have been a blizzard of executive orders, presidential memorandums, and official proclamations. He says he wants to overturn the worst policies of the previous administration, and to restore a sense of national unity and institutional integrity. What gets lost in the details of all these initiatives is Biden’s partisan goal.

 

It’s not just that the new president wants to resume the trajectory America was on when Barack Obama left office in 2017. He also wants to claw back the gains red states made over blue states during the last four years. He wants to shift federal resources to Democratic constituencies, and to save the blue states from the true cost of their misguided policies. And if red America has to pay a price in lost jobs and tax revenue, well, that’s too bad.

 

Leave aside, for the purposes of this discussion, the relative merits of Biden’s executive actions. (I disagree with almost all of them.) Focus instead on their distributional effects, not on individuals but on sectors of the economy, on regions of the country, and on the donor bases of the two parties. The image that comes to mind is of swarms of dollars changing course mid flight: a mass migration of subsidies, spending, and incentives from the GOP coalition to the Democratic one.

 

Start with energy. Biden killed the Keystone XL pipeline at a cost of 1,000 jobs and diplomatic goodwill with Canada. He banned fracking on federal lands and paused oil and gas lease sales in the Arctic National Wildlife Reserve. According to a White House fact sheet, he told federal agencies to “accelerate clean energy and transmission projects.” He is sure to bestow federal largesse on the sons of Solyndra.

 

The alternative energy sector overwhelmingly favors Democrats. Its political investments have paid off. The old-style extractive industries, mainly based in GOP strongholds, will suffer. In some cases they are targeted for extinction. The knock-on effects are serious. “Wyoming state superintendent Jillian Balow notes that her state depends on some $150 million a year in oil and gas federal royalties to fund K-12 schools,” says the Wall Street Journal editorial board.

 

Other Biden measures resumed the flow of government aid to the special interests behind his campaign. The second Catholic president has jumpstarted federal funding of Planned Parenthood almost two years after President Trump cut off the nation’s largest abortion provider. Biden also reversed President Trump’s ban on money for “sanctuary cities” that choose not to enforce federal immigration law. That decision will help boost the budgets of progressive municipalities eager to pass off the costs of illegal immigration. Biden’s codification of the Supreme Court’s Bostock decision, which made gender identity protected under civil rights law, and his lifting of the ban on trans soldiers is sure to please a class of donors essential to Democratic Party finances.

 

Biden’s proposed American Rescue Plan best captures the new administration’s intermingling of public policy and greasy-pole gamesmanship. Take, for example, the $130 billion that Biden wants to spend on K–12 schools. That number is on top of the $67 billion Congress already has committed to reopening elementary and secondary schools.

 

The additional cash is a handout to the teachers’ unions, who have opposed a return to in-person instruction at every opportunity, and who are among Biden’s closest allies. Biden has adopted the unions’ rhetoric, saying that schools cannot open until they have been renovated. He’s wrong, of course — measures such as masks, hygiene, and social distancing are enough to stop the spread, especially among the elementary schoolers who need in-person classes the most and whose transmission rates are low. But science doesn’t matter. The unions must get paid.

 

One year after COVID-19 appeared in America, it is more than evident that arbitrary, statewide lockdowns are a disaster for small businesses, which happen to be a key part of the Republican coalition. The states that have done the most to reopen have best weathered the economic storm. And these same states tend to be low-tax, low-minimum-wage, and have a business-friendly regulatory environment, as well as a warmer climate. The Wall Street Journal reports that the South is leading America’s recovery. But, in the heavily Democratic northeast, “The recovery of jobs has lagged behind.”

 

What does Biden want? His solution is to make Florida and Texas more like New York and California. My colleague at the American Enterprise Institute, Paul H. Kupiec, calculates that the nationwide $15 minimum wage contained in the American Rescue Plan would “shift business formation, growth, and employment from red states to blue, as the higher minimum wage erodes red states’ labor cost advantage in many job categories.” What’s best for Cuomo, however, is not what’s best for the country.

 

A steep minimum-wage hike in the middle of an economic crisis that disproportionately affects small business is the exact opposite of what you want to do to spur full employment. But it does make sense if you are using the crisis to gain leverage for unions and government over free labor and the private sector.

 

Blue America began to claw back red America’s earnings last week. And the next four years (at least) will see the Biden coalition press its advantage.

 

Ah, normalcy.

Andrew Cuomo’s Shame

National Review Online

Friday, January 29, 2021

 

‘We were ambushed like no other state,” New York governor Andrew Cuomo contended to MSNBC’s Nicolle Wallace on January 26. “Again, it was from federal incompetence. They thought the virus was in China, it left China, it had left China, it had gone to Europe and it came here for three months before they ever knew. Incompetent government kills people.”

 

Two days later Letitia James, the state’s attorney general, who is a liberal Democrat like Cuomo and who enjoyed Cuomo’s backing when she sought her current office, released a cautiously worded yet infuriating 76-page report suggesting that Cuomo’s incompetence cost lives.

 

Extrapolating from a survey of about 10 percent of state nursing homes, James estimated that the actual number of COVID deaths related to such facilities was about 50 percent higher than the official figure, which was about 8,700. Within hours, the state Department of Health scrambled to add to its nursing-home total 3,800 souls who had died in hospitals after becoming infected in nursing homes, bringing the official number up to 12,473.

 

As New York City mayor Bill de Blasio put it with uncharacteristic eloquence, “These are our loved ones we lost, you know, it’s someone’s grandma, someone’s mother or father, aunts or uncles, this is families missing someone dear to them.”

 

The coronavirus has represented a once-in-a-hundred-years public-health crisis that has not discriminated between red and blue states. Everyone should have some humility about criticizing anyone in authority during the pandemic, when many decisions were made with imperfect information and when most choices had agonizing trade-offs. Yet Cuomo’s Department of Health’s March 25 order directing nursing homes to accept incoming residents known to have the coronavirus, an order he did not rescind until May 10, stands out as foolish and disastrous — especially because New York was warned of the danger. Cuomo still refuses to say whose idea the order was.

 

So more than 12 percent of New York nursing-home residents have succumbed to the virus. In New Jersey, where a policy similar to Cuomo’s was enacted, the death toll was similar: 12 percent of nursing-home residents felled by the virus. In Florida, where nursing homes were forbidden to accept people with coronavirus, that figure is 1.6 percent.

 

Neutral observers, as opposed to Cuomo’s many unpaid publicists in the news media, were unsurprised by the new development, widely if mistakenly labeled “shocking” in the press. New York, which has suffered by far the worst COVID death toll of any state and is among the hardest-hit regions on the planet, has lost 34,742 to the disease, or 43,093 if you include suspected as well as confirmed cases, as does the Johns Hopkins University tracker.

 

Throughout this crisis the media have praised Cuomo’s supposed forthrightness and respect for facts. Last summer the New York Post, one of the few media outlets to show any interest in finding the true nursing-home figures, began calling for an independent investigation. Cuomo called that paper’s questions partisan attacks and invited New Yorkers to direct their anger toward President Trump; the rest of the media largely shrugged. Cuomo also resisted inquiries from fellow Democratic members of the state legislature and the U.S. Congress, insisting there was no need for anyone to check his numbers.

 

On March 2, the day after the first New Yorker tested positive for the novel coronavirus, when, as we now know, the virus was tearing through the Empire State, Cuomo explained at length why New Yorkers need not be worried, via empty slogans and macho posturing: “The facts defeat fear.” “The reality is reassuring.” “It is deep breath time.” “This is not our first rodeo.” He averred, “We should relax because that’s what’s dictated by the reality of the situation.” Incompetent government kills people indeed. More to the point, Cuomo said correctly on March 29, “Coronavirus in a nursing home is like fire in dry grass.” His mistakes played a role in fanning the flames.

Friday, January 29, 2021

Against Ad-Hocracy

By Kevin D. Williamson

Wednesday, January 27, 2021

 

Politics is supposed to be a means of solving problems that do not have their origins in politics but instead arise from what Hobbes called the “state of nature.” How do we go about protecting ourselves from marauding bandits? How do we prevent our crops from being stolen by the people across the river? How can we solve disputes about property or injuries without resorting to vendettas and blood feuds? If we build a wall around our village to protect us, how should the expense be borne? These are the original problems of politics.

 

Eventually, politics reaches a point of sufficient entrenchment where it begins to create severe problems of its own, which is where we find ourselves at the moment.

 

Politics sometimes is thought of as a kind of lid that sits atop the boiling pot of society. That is one assessment of modern liberalism, cynically (or pragmatically) understood as a system in which the well-to-do and the powerful share just enough of their wealth and power to keep the peasantry from rising up in arms against them. You heard a lot about that over the summer, in those ancient days when our friends on the left still were lionizing mobs and armed militias that destroyed life and property for political ends and worked toward the overthrow of government. Riots, they lectured us, are the weapons of the powerless, and justly wielded. That is what is meant by the slogan, “No justice, no peace.”

 

But if justice is to mean anything other than the state in which those most willing to engage in political violence are given what they demand, then justice must be defined — which is another way of saying we must put limits on it. (Defined comes from the Latin definire, meaning to impose limits.) The need for such definition is the reason we write down our laws rather than putting every dispute and controversy to a plebiscite, and it is why we have constitutions — which is to say, it is why we have limited government.

 

Limited government is not some libertarian concoction — if you prefer to keep the Bill of Rights, then you believe in limited government. If you prefer unlimited government, then history and a few unhappy corners of the modern world offer many examples.

 

The long project of making the king subordinate to the law was the great achievement of British political thinking, and it laid the philosophical foundation for the American founding, in which British subjects in North America did away with kings altogether and substituted a different model of political life. It is that model of politics that American conservatives seek to conserve — not necessarily in its every jot and tittle (we did away with the Articles of Confederation, slavery, and much else, and it has been a good while since the U.S. government has issued letters of marque and reprisal) but in its principles, its philosophy, its intellectual structure, and, especially, its constitutional architecture. And here it is regrettably necessary to distinguish between conservatives per se and the Right more broadly, many of whose current leading lights and ascendant radical factions take a distinctly kingly view of presidential power and understand the law as just another instrument of domination.

 

Some of our political disagreements are about ends, but most of them are about means. Most of us desire widespread prosperity, physical security, social mobility, peace, a clean environment, well-administered courts of law, the happiness of minority groups, etc. But how do we achieve those ends? Conservatives believe that peace and prosperity come from organic social development enabled by a foundation comprising individual rights, including, especially, property rights; the rule of law, with legislatures acting within the bounds of well-defined constitutional limits and independent courts committed to the law itself rather than a freelance socio-political agenda; prudent and thrifty public administration; a thriving civil society and religious life that provide the things government cannot, such as community and moral orientation; entrepreneurship, free enterprise, and trade; and the distillation of ancient human experience that we call tradition.

 

When Senator Elizabeth Warren proposes to effect a soft takeover of American corporations, dictating to them everything from the composition of their boards to the range of their political activism, conservatives object — not because we are worried that Microsoft’s shareholders will get a raw deal, but because Senator Warren’s proposal represents a fundamental change to the property-rights regime upon which American economic prosperity is founded, a fundamental change in the relationship between citizen and state. Conservatives who object to “cancel culture” are mindful of the legal distinction between private corporate action and state censorship, but are also mindful of the fact that civil society can be made into a cat’s-paw of politics, and recognize that what is proposed by Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez et al. would constitute a kind of soft Jim Crow for political minorities. Our solicitousness of the undemocratic character of many of our institutions — the Senate, the Bill of Rights, the Electoral College — is rooted in an understanding that there is more to peace and justice than majority rule.

 

Against this, the progressives offer ad-hocracy, willy-nilly social engineering in response to whatever the demand of the second is. That is why we went from “Nobody is talking about gay marriage!” to “Gay marriage is a constitutional mandate!” to “We’re going to put you in jail if you won’t bake a cake for a gay wedding!” in about ten years. The times, they are a-changin’: Planned Parenthood was founded by a dedicated eugenicist who claimed to abhor abortion and has become an organization of dedicated abortionists who claim, somewhat dubiously, to abhor eugenics — and both positions were considered, in their respective times, the incontrovertibly rational position of scientific progressivism. Self-evident truths freshly minted yesterday and bolstered by a Vox article headlined “Study says . . .” are not good enough on their own, because we have seen them come and go.

 

So of course we conservatives are always repeating ourselves. History repeats itself. We must always begin, and begin again, at the beginning.

The American Left’s Love Affair with FARC & Friends

By Kevin D. Williamson

Friday, January 29, 2021

 

A special court has been convened in Colombia to try eight leaders of the Marxist-Leninist terrorist outfit known as FARC — Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias de Colombia — on war crimes and crimes against humanity charges. Perhaps justice will be done upon these eight — will it ever be done for their enablers in the United States and elsewhere?

 

FARC is one of the many murderous offshoots of that “real socialism” that our leftist friends always insist “has never been tried.” Like the Taliban, it is part political movement and part drug cartel; like Hamas, it has sought legitimacy by repackaging itself as a political party, now known as Comunes.

 

FARC never enjoyed quite the celebrity status of, say, the Sandinistas in Nicaragua, the communist militia that enjoyed the support of, among others, Bill de Blasio, who returned from a visit to the war-ravaged country in his late 20s with “a vision of the possibilities of an unfettered leftist government,” in the words of the New York Times. (And how are you enjoying it, New York?) The Sandinistas got a Clash triple-album named after them, whereas FARC was always more an enthusiasm of cloistered academic Marxists and left-wing activists with a commitment to worldwide revolutionary movements. They were trained by IRA bomb-makers, and their interests were advanced in the U.S. Congress by elected Democrats, with American activists acting as back-channel go-betweens. Left-wing activists have long agitated for the release of FARC terrorists held in U.S. prisons.

 

If FARC has always had friends in the United States, friends of FARC abroad have had even more friends in the United States. The late Venezuelan socialist dictator, Hugo Chávez, was a longtime sponsor of the Marxist-Leninist-narco-terrorist outfit next door, going so far as to allow them to operate from Venezuelan safe havens. Chávez was the American Left’s second-favorite Latin American dictator, behind Fidel Castro, enjoying the support not only of Hollywood’s champagne radicals but also that of congressional Democrats, including Chaka Fattah and Barney Frank. Those two were not exactly paragons of good judgment: Fattah went down on 23 felony counts comprising racketeering conspiracy, bribery, bank fraud, mail fraud, and money laundering, while Barney Frank at one point had a bisexual prostitution ring being run out of his home but was never charged with any crime.

 

(My main objection to Representative Frank’s taking the gavel as chairman of the House Financial Services Committee was that he had somehow managed to lose money hosting a whorehouse in Washington.)

 

Representative Fattah was an eager dupe for Chávez in the heady days when Venezuela was buoyed by rising oil prices — Boss Hugo sent discounted heating oil to Representative Fattah’s constituents in chilly Philadelphia. He also kidnapped, tortured, and murdered political opponents. But the Left has no enemies to the left.

 

The Left’s love affair with FARC in Colombia and Chávez in Venezuela was an echo of its ongoing romance, now post-mortem, with Fidel Castro. Celebrity progressives such as Danny Glover, Robert Redford, and Oliver Stone made the trip to Havana to sit at the feet of Fidel Castro. Celebrity journalists such as Andrea Mitchell talked up Castro’s achievements in health care even as Cubans were deprived of simple antibiotics and basic medical services. Upon the great tyrant’s death, Barack Obama spoke of “the countless ways in which he altered the course of individual lives, families, and of the Cuban nation,” which is one way to describe the career of a mass-murdering dictator who ran a garrison state so cruel that its subjects set out to sea on tire tubes in hopes of floating off to a better life.

 

And so it goes and has gone: Jane Fonda made her pilgrimage to Hanoi, and, more consequentially, Bernie Sanders, who nearly won the Democratic nomination twice, made his pilgrimage to Moscow and Leningrad, where he spent his time “extolling the virtues of Soviet life and culture,” notwithstanding that Soviet life and culture had included a gigantic gulag state whose outrages included, among many other crimes against humanity, starving 4 million people to death to make a political point. Even Pol Pot had his apologists in the United States, with left-wing radicals such as Noam Chomsky dismissing the Cambodian genocide as exaggerated or wholly invented “propaganda.”

 

The worldwide communist enterprise murdered 100 million people in the 20th century. Eight men will be tried in Colombia. Sales of Che Guevara T-shirts remain brisk.

Congress Bows to the Pen and the Phone

By Rich Lowry

Friday, January 29, 2021

 

President Joe Biden has proved that, if nothing else, he has a pen and a phone.

 

According to The Economist, he signed more executive orders in his first two days than President Donald Trump signed in nearly his first two months.

 

And he was just getting started.

 

Republicans have no standing to complain about Biden’s spate of unilateral measures, given they were fine with Trump using exactly the same means. But that presidents of both parties govern this way doesn’t make it better — it makes it worse.

 

Some executive actions starkly usurp congressional authority, while others are firmly within the executive’s ambit. Yet the sheer amount of activity that presidents undertake on their own isn’t in keeping with the spirit of our constitutional system.

 

The presidency has overawed a legislative branch that is only too willing to sign over power and responsibility. Congress has been an eager participant in its own neutering.

 

James Madison thought the legislature would be insatiable, steadily accumulating power. Instead, it is the least self-respecting branch, led by people who identify with the interests of presidents and their own parties over and above the interests of their own institution.

 

This means that Congress is essentially cut out of the action on important questions of national policy.

 

Obama blocked the Keystone XL pipeline, Trump blessed it, and Biden blocked it again.

 

Obama took us into the Paris climate accord, Trump took us out, and Biden is taking us back in.

 

Consider what Biden did on his own the other day. He directed the Interior Department to stop new oil and gas leases on federal land and to identify steps to double renewable-energy production by 2030.

 

He created a special presidential envoy for climate, as well as a White House Office of Domestic Climate Policy, a National Climate Task Force, a Civilian Climate Corps Initiative, an Interagency Working Group on Coal and Power Plant Communities and Economic Revitalization, a White House Environmental Justice Interagency Council, and a White House Environmental Justice Advisory Council.

 

On top of this, he established a Justice Initiative to steer 40 percent of relevant federal investments to disadvantaged communities.

 

And on the seventh day, Biden rested (after tucking his pen back in his pocket).

 

If Congress had passed a bill doing all this, it’d be considered a pretty active day. Instead, Congress stood on the sidelines . . . and commented.

 

“I’m proud that President Biden is announcing a slew of executive actions on climate,” Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer tweeted.

 

Schumer’s only complaint is that Biden isn’t doing more on his own authority.

 

This is the same Chuck Schumer who has been a legislator since 1975 when he took a seat in the New York State Assembly, who has been in Congress since 1981 and the Senate since 1999, and who ascended to majority leader about a week ago, representing the apex of a national legislative career.

 

And yet Schumer has urged Biden to declare a national climate emergency because it would allow him to do things “without legislation.”

 

This would be like Chief Justice John Roberts giving Biden advice on how to pack the Supreme Court — except it’s unimaginable that a Supreme Court justice would be so openly disdainful of the legitimacy and prerogatives of his or her own institution.

 

This is a particular congressional disease. As Yuval Levin of the American Enterprise Institute wrote in an essay for Commentary magazine, Congress has been delegating its authority to the executive branch for some time. What’s new is that partisanship has created a loyalty for members of Congress that transcends their attachment to Congress itself, while more and more members consider their office merely a platform to get attention.

 

“Congress is weak and dysfunctional because that suits its members,” Levin writes. “It could renew itself only if its members wanted such renewal.”

 

All indications are that, no, it is perfectly content to be supplanted by the pen and phone.