National Review Online
Thursday, December 07, 2017
President Trump made the laudable decision Wednesday to
recognize reality: Jerusalem is the capital of Israel, and our embassy should
be in that city.
That is not a radical position. It has been the consensus
in the United States for more than two decades, despite a lamentable tradition
of presidential waivers deferring action on the matter. In 1995, Congress
passed the Jerusalem Embassy Act with massive bipartisan support, recognizing
Jerusalem as the capital of Israel and stipulating that the U.S. embassy should
be moved there from Tel Aviv. Since then, presidential candidates from both
parties have said they would fulfill the promise of the law. But every
president delayed its implementation on national-security grounds. In a
considered and well-crafted speech, Trump announced he would formally recognize
Jerusalem as the capital and begin the process of moving the embassy.
The move both corrects an error of American policy and
signifies our respect for Israeli sovereignty. Diplomatic tradition allows
sovereign states to name their capitals, and Israel has named Jerusalem as its
own. We understand the prudential concerns that have prevented prior
administrations from taking this formal step, but it shouldn’t be in dispute
that Jerusalem is Israel’s capital, and the forces that vociferously deny it
tend to oppose the very existence of the Jewish state.
Trump’s critics charge that his decision will destabilize
the Middle East and stoke violence across the Arab world. Tensions between
Israel and the Palestinian territories may well be inflamed by the move. The
Palestinian envoy to Britain says the decision amounts to a “declaration of
war,” and Palestinian Authority president Mahmoud Abbas says it will have
“dangerous consequences.” (For its part, Hamas says that Trump has opened up
the “gates of hell.”) That is all par for the course for the Palestinians, who
often resort to violence and threats of violence even when we aren’t allegedly
provoking them. We shouldn’t let the irrationality of the Palestinians dictate
our policy.
Another criticism is that the decision will alienate
Sunni states in the Middle East — Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Jordan — that we count
on as allies. Yet these and other Arab countries have long learned to deal with
the fact that we are pro-Israel. Israeli’s relations with Egypt, Saudi Arabia,
and Jordan have been on the upswing in recent years. This is because they all
consider Iranian expansionism a greater threat to the region than the Jewish
state.
The charge that this move will derail the peace process
is similarly unfounded. Right now, the fact is that there is no peace process
worthy of the name. Regardless, there is no conceivable peace agreement between
Israel and Palestine that wouldn’t recognize Jerusalem as the capital of the
Jewish state.
Moving the embassy will take time to carry out, and
Trump’s recognition is mostly a symbolic decision. Nonetheless, it is an
important one. We applaud President Trump for following through on this
promise, recognizing Israel’s rights as a sovereign state, and bringing
American practice in line with the American consensus
No comments:
Post a Comment