Tuesday, February 9, 2021

Max Boot Has Turned So Hard on the Right, He’s Now Attacking Himself

By Isaac Schorr

Monday, February 08, 2021

 

Max Boot is more machine than man. His Washington Post column is a space not for a writer with a distinct or coherent worldview to make arguments about varied political and cultural topics but for a contradictory and single-minded robot to try to make the same point over and over and over again. It’s the journalistic equivalent of “we programmed a bot to write 1,000 columns about how Republicans are bad™ using headlines from the previous two days and disregarding any previous arguments it’s made.” Democrats cancel Abraham Lincoln? Republicans are at fault for pushing back. Trump-skeptical Republican senator announces he’s retiring? Good riddance, he’s worse than Marjorie Taylor Greene. Highly regarded former Republican statesman passes away? Use his memory to bash the GOP.

 

This last, most recent example makes for the perfect specimen of the Boot Bot at work — the platonic ideal of its remarkable willingness to adapt and improvise in the service of its ultimate aim. The great George Shultz, President Reagan’s second and final secretary of state passed away on Saturday at the age of 100 (do yourself a favor and read National Review’s editors on Shultz’s remarkable life). Naturally, where most of us saw an opportunity to celebrate a uniquely American life, Boot — a sincere adherent of the old “the only good Republican is a dead Republican” adage — saw a hook for his next column.

 

Most of the piece is Boot’s typical fare: simplistic and incomplete arguments conveyed awkwardly. He includes a throwaway line implying that the worst portion of today’s GOP can trace its roots back to Barry Goldwater, a founding member of the Arizona NAACP. He calls Shultz an advocate for “progressivism.” He even asserts that Shultz and Reagan represented a bulwark against the “far right” because of their willingness to sit at the negotiating table with Mikhail Gorbachev during Reagan’s second term. His evidence is that a single New York Times article from 1988 quoted a conservative activist who accused the president of being “a useful idiot for Soviet propaganda.” That Reagan’s hard line on the “Evil Empire” during his first term, a posture decried by Democrats at the time (Walter Mondale called his support of the Strategic Defense Initiative “madness”), was what brought the USSR to the table goes unmentioned.

 

His typically superficial treatment of history aside, this column is remarkable because it represents the final evolution of Max Boot from Bush-era, flag-waving, third-wave neoconservative to beliefless machine. In the penultimate paragraph, while lamenting the end of responsible (again, dead) Republicans, Boot writes: “Republicans such as [Dick] Cheney and [Don] Rumsfeld, once seen as sensible conservatives, were radicalized by the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks and sent the United States blundering into ‘forever wars’ that discredited the Republican elite much as the Vietnam War had discredited the ‘best and brightest’ Democrats.” This comes from the man best known for writing an October 2001 cover story for the late great Weekly Standard called “The Case for American Empire,” in which he argued that “the September 11 attack was a result of insufficient American involvement and ambition” and that “the solution is to be more expansive in our goals and more assertive in their implementation.” More specifically, he submitted that the solution was the “invasion and occupation” of Iraq. Once his wish was granted, Boot became one of the war’s most outspoken defenders, telling anyone who would listen that it was not only justified but necessary. It’s no crime for Boot to have changed his mind, but his (again, simplistic) explanation of how Republicans (not him, though) were “radicalized” by 9/11 is not just uncharitable but dishonest. So too is his dismissal of his previous policy preference as “forever wars,” a buzzword used only by the most unserious of isolationists.

 

Boot had his reasons for arguing that the United States should wage an ambitious war on terror in the aftermath of the attacks, and I’m not fully convinced he was wrong. It can certainly be defended. Indefensible, though, is his buzzword-quality smear of everyone else who backed it, which included George Shultz, by the way. His use of Shultz’s memory to execute the smear is indefensible, indeed downright ghastly. It’s not the first, and I’d venture to say won’t be the last, time Boot makes moral compromises to fill his quota.

The Hidden Costs of Biden’s $15 Minimum Wage

By Andy Puzder & Jon Hartley

Tuesday, February 09, 2021

 

The Biden administration’s $1.9 trillion COVID-19 relief proposal included a handful of partisan measures completely unrelated to pandemic relief, including increasing the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour from the current level of $7.25 an hour. Lacking sufficient bipartisan support to meet the 60-vote majority required under the Senate’s filibuster rules, Democrats are using a legislative process known as budget reconciliation to pass their bill. Reconciliation requires a simple majority vote for passage but is limited to bills on spending, revenue, and the federal-debt limit. A minimum-wage bill clearly does not qualify.

 

The problem for Democrats is the Senate’s “Byrd rule,” under which the nonpartisan Senate parliamentarian is authorized to strip “extraneous” provisions out of such legislation. Provisions are extraneous if they fail to produce a change in outlays or revenues or produce a change that is “is merely incidental.”

 

President Biden recently conceded that a minimum-wage increase is an unlikely candidate for a budget reconciliation. In a pre-recorded interview on Friday with CBS host Norah O’Donnell, Biden stated that he didn’t believe the minimum-wage hike was “going to survive” as part of the bill. You could almost hear America’s struggling small businesses emit a sigh of relief.

 

Senate Democrats tacitly acknowledged the problem on Friday when they used reconciliation to pass a COVID-19 relief bill that did not include the $15 minimum-wage hike. However, the vote was nonbinding and such a provision could be added to subsequent versions of the bill.

 

Never fearful of plowing sand, even with an abundance of serious problems to address, the newly appointed chair of the Senate Budget Committee, Socialist senator Bernie Sanders (I., Vt.), continues to push for the wage hike. On Sunday, Sanders told CNN’s Jake Tapper, “We have a room full of lawyers working as hard as we can to make the case to the parliamentarian that, in fact, raising the minimum wage will have significant budget implications and, in fact, should be consistent with reconciliation rules.”

 

In his attempt to overcome the Byrd rule, Sanders has cited new studies from two sources with a history of highly partisan research in support of minimum-wage hikes. Authored by the Economic Policy Institute and Berkeley economist Michael Reich these studies claim that a $15 federal minimum wage would positively impact the federal budget by tens of billions of dollars per year through increased tax revenue and reduced costs for public-assistance programs. Reich claims hiking the minimum wage to $15 an hour by 2025 would positively impact the federal budget to the tune of $65.4 billion a year.

 

But would that really happen? Clearly not.

 

On Monday, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office issued a report stating that, should Sanders’ $15 minimum-wage bill become law, “the cumulative budget deficit over the 2021–2031 period would increase by $54 billion.” That sure doesn’t sound like a budget windfall.

 

In addition, the CBO’s average estimate was that, in the year the minimum wage hit $15, “the effects on workers and their families would include” a reduction of 1.4 million jobs. That’s a lot of jobs for an administration that claims it will focus on “getting back to full employment, as quickly as possible” because it “will make a major difference in the lives of tens of millions of people, particularly those most at risk of being left behind,” according to a White House blog post by Council of Economic Advisers members Jared Bernstein and Heather Boushey.

 

So how would a $15 minimum wage impact those people “most at risk of being left behind”? According to the CBO’s report, “young, less educated people would account for a disproportionate share of those reductions in employment.” That’s not a surprise.

 

In January, economists David Neumark and Peter Shirley issued a study on the employment impact of minimum-wage increases. It assembled the “entire set of published studies” and “identified the core estimates that support the conclusions from each study.” It found “a clear preponderance” in the literature that increasing the minimum wage negatively affects employment, particularly with respect to “teens and young adults as well as the less-educated.”

 

Sanders’ claim that a $15 minimum wage would reduce budget deficits is based on partisan research, at best grossly misleading and at worst simply wrong. Including such a provision in a budget-reconciliation bill would make a mockery of the Byrd rule and open up the process to significant future abuse. It would also seriously reduce job opportunities for the people who need them most.

 

Perhaps Democrats might consider spending more time on the negative impact their proposed federal minimum-wage hike would have on the teens, young adults, and the less-educated that the CBO and NBER studies found are most adversely affected by increasing the minimum wage — particularly those in poorer parts of the country. Let’s not forget we are recovering from a recession that disproportionately hurt businesses with hourly workers. That’s one reason we need a COVID-19 relief bill in the first place.

Monday, February 8, 2021

At Long Last, Defiance from a Position of Strength

By Noah Rothman

Friday, February 05, 2021

 

Republican voters, the pollster and analyst Kristen Soltis Anderson observed, respond to strength. Critics of GOP voters confuse this instinct with a hunger for authoritarianism. And while this disposition can manifest in unhealthy ways, that is a shallow and mistaken impression. What Republican voters spoil for, Anderson writes, is “a fight.”

 

Say what you will about Donald Trump; he brought that fight. The former president surely lost more than he won, but he picked many battles and stood on the strength of his convictions when his Republican opponents, by and large, did not. Trump and the movement around him became so synonymous with political pugilism that adherents of MAGA theology continue to operate as though they are an ascendant coalition even as they sift through the wreckage of two consecutively disappointing election cycles.

 

At the state and national level, the Republican Party’s committees have not taken stock of their losses. Indeed, those losses reinforce a persecution complex that has become an animating feature of the MAGA movement. That’s understandable. At a certain decibel level, churlishness and a crippling sense of inferiority can seem like strength. But that is an illusion that should be challenged. And some Republicans seem inclined to test the proposition.

 

Rep. Liz Cheney was the first. Though she was one of ten House Republican conference members to vote in favor of Donald Trump’s impeachment, she was singled out by her fellow members because she occupies a leadership role. Cheney, her more Trumpy critics alleged, could not continue to serve as the chair of her conference because her impeachment vote shows that she does not represent most of her fellow members’ views. Cheney wanted that theory put to the test, welcoming a referendum on her leadership. But in so doing, she did not throw herself upon the mercy of her colleagues. Quite the opposite; she practically dared them to strike her down.

 

“Several members have asked me to apologize for the vote,” Cheney said in a pre-vote address to her colleagues. “I owe you honesty, I owe you the truth, I cannot do that.”

 

“We cannot look away or ignore what happened on January 6,” the GOP conference chair continued. “We cannot sit by and let the Republican Party be taken over by Q-anon conspiracy theorists, white supremacists, Holocaust deniers or a cult of personality .… We are the party of truth. We are the party of law and order, justice, limited government and, most importantly, the primacy of our Constitution.”

 

In the end, Cheney’s role in leadership was reaffirmed by the vote of nearly two-thirds of the House Republican conference. This is no small thing. It is a rebuke—albeit an anonymous one, as the balloting was secret—of the party’s pro-Trump wing that includes Donald Trump himself. The former president actively whipped members to vote against Cheney and avenge him, and the party’s personality cultists postured as though they had the wind at their backs. But they did not.

 

Cheney is not alone. Sen. Ben Sasse joined her last night in defying the pressure placed on the GOP by Mar-a-Lago  in a blistering address to the Nebraska GOP. Sasse’s party back home had already censured the senator once for failing to pay proper obeisance to Trump, and it seems set to do it again. In a recorded message to his fellow Republicans, Sasse dared his party to do it again.

 

Here, too, the senator was operating from a position of strength. He beat back a primary challenge in 2020, won reelection in November. And he, like so many down-ballot Republicans, outperformed Donald Trump in his state. Armed with evidence that he better represents the state’s voters than the party does, Sasse unloaded on the Nebraska central committee.

 

“[T]he anger’s always been simply about me not bending the knee to one guy,” he told committee members. “It’s because I still believe–as you used to–that politics isn’t about the weird worship of one dude.” Their problem, Sasse alleged, is that a “personality cult” had seduced them. The committee has been stirred to inchoate anger by the same environmental forces that animated the mob that ransacked the Capitol: a “lie” propagated by the president. “Nebraskans aren’t rage addicts,” Sasse insisted. “We’re going to have to choose—between conservatism and madness, between just trolling versus actually persuading the rising generation of Americans again.”

 

It isn’t just the substance of Cheney and Sasse’s message which threatens the core premise of Trumpism; it is their defiant posture. These are not martyrs delivering a final sermon before the gallows. They have not held a moistened finger into the breeze in the desperate effort to save their political hides. These are combatants spoiling for a fight, brimming with the confidence that comes with the knowledge that their ranks are fuller than their opponents think.

 

That’s precisely the same “fight” that Donald Trump brought in 2016. It is the heroic myth that still clings to him, even in defeat. Indeed, the Republican Party has avoided reckoning with its losses only by embracing the delusional fantasy that Donald Trump did not, in fact, lose. He cannot lose because, in loss, Trump’s Achillean mythos would be shattered.

 

Sasse and Cheney will get what they’re asking for. The proposition they are betting on will be tested, and they may yet lose that bet. Make no mistake: They are outnumbered. But these politicians act as though they, not their opponents, control the commanding heights. That is both intimidating and inspiring.

Reflections on the Riot in Washington

By John Podhoretz

Monday, February 08, 2021

 

The question before us now is whether and in what fashion the Republican Party will survive Donald Trump and the insurrectionist riot of January 6, 2021, for which he was impeached by the House of Representatives.

 

Unlike the first impeachment of Donald Trump, this second impeachment was appropriate and necessary. Congress had to do what it could to intervene to forestall the rise of a new era of political lawlessness and violence in the United States—in which political leaders treat the constitutionally mandated procedures that undergird our representative government as entirely conditional, only worthy of being followed if the results come out the way they like them.

 

The idea was a novel one, to be sure—sending a mob to intimidate Trump’s own toadyish vice president into magically refusing to accept the electoral count and forcing Mike Pence to announce, through a power he did not possess, that someone else had won the election. But it’s only novel once. The unthinkable is no longer unthinkable once it has been tried. That is why a door to nihilistic evil, once opened, must be locked, nailed shut, epoxyed as a seal, and bricked up—and then, after all that, the aperture must be hardened from assault like a nuclear silo.

 

That is the justification for the impeachment. It also speaks to the need for the Senate’s conviction based on the House’s indictment, no matter when or how long it takes. The events of January 6 were incepted, encouraged, galvanized, and implicitly directed by the country’s most powerful single person, out of his disappointment and rage at the imminent loss of his power.

 

The horror had to be anathematized. The political and social wound it opened had to be cauterized. And all present and future leaders had to be put on notice that any such action taken in the future will be met with the only kind of political force we do sanction—the force of impeachment and the potential removal from office.

 

So vital is this remedy, and so serious, that we can see just how foolish it was to use it with questionable intent both in Trump’s first impeachment and in the case of Bill Clinton in 1998. Had those self-defeating efforts been avoided, it would have been far more difficult for Republicans to vote no on this open-and-shut case, as most did in the House either out of an instinct of political self-preservation or as a result of their own partisan—or literal—madness.

 

I say literal madness because at least one newly elected Republican member of Congress, Marjorie Taylor Greene of Georgia, issued the following statement a week after the Electoral College tally of 306–232 had been certified and Joseph Robinette Biden had formally become the president-elect: “President Trump will remain in office. This Hail Mary attempt to remove him from the White House is an attack on every American who voted for him. Democrats must be held accountable for the political violence inspired by their rhetoric.” The only way President Trump could, at the time she issued the statement on January 12, remain in office would have been through a literal coup d’etat.

 

It’s possible that Greene, who endorses the many-tentacled conspiracy called QAnon, might be clinically insane. But if so, what of the 137 members of her party in the House who, the week before, joined her in contesting the electoral results in Pennsylvania? The argument made on their behalf is that they believe the election was stolen and their belief is their truth and their truth must be honored. Yeah, well, people believe in lots of things. And genuinely. Arthur Kopit, a notable American playwright, once said in no uncertain terms that he’d seen the Loch Ness Monster. I admire Kopit’s play Wings. That doesn’t mean I think he actually saw a sea creature in a Scottish lake.

 

There is such a thing as electoral fraud. I can think of elections that might well have been stolen. The Minnesota Senate race in 2008 saw the mysterious discoveries of missing ballots and the likely participation of ineligible voters turn a 215-vote lead for incumbent Republican Norm Coleman into a 312-vote victory for Democrat Al Franken, out of more than 2.8 million cast. But the margin of victory in Pennsylvania was 80,555 out of 6.8 million. You can see how an effectively tied contest election can be gently pushed in the wrong direction by fraud. But not a race won by 1.2 percent.

 

Any fair-minded dive into the supposed “vote-fraud” controversies of 2020—by which I mean ones that do not involve either the rantings of soon-to-be-disbarred lawyers or the factitious intellectual droolings of slavering MAGA apologists—gets you nowhere. The only grounds to claim the election was run irregularly have to do with changes to liberalize methods of voting due to the pandemic.

 

The fact that those seem to have favored Democrats has more than a little to do with the intervention of one Donald J. Trump, who loudly insisted and preached that voting early or voting by mail was some kind of evil act. In only one state—Florida—did he bow to the wishes of a friendly governor and cease his lobbying against voting ahead of time. He won Florida by two points, in part because Florida Republicans participated in early voting to a far greater degree than in other states—especially Pennsylvania. In this way, as in so many others, Trump’s behavior played a central role in his own defeat.

 

Then he instantly demanded other Republicans take up the cudgel on behalf of his stolen-election excuse, even though it was he who cost the party the White House and then, in January, the Senate with the losses in the two Georgia Senate runoff races. (A credible study found that 115,000 Republican voters stayed home rather than participate in the runoff due to Trump’s theft claims; the margin of victory in the more decisively won race in Georgia was 75,000.)

 

Trump’s demand here was one of the most chutzpahdik in political history, but he knew what he was doing. He was demonstrating how he had turned the GOP into a party of one—the party of Trump. Even in defeat, he remained and, in the wake of impeachment remains, the most powerful figure on the American right, and power in this instance isn’t just metaphorical. It’s literal. He summoned a vast crowd to Washington on January 6, promising them it would be “wild.” And then he said they should go to the Capitol and let Mike Pence know how they felt.

 

The crowd he summoned was real, representing the political threat to those who would oppose Trump in the House and Senate—in the form of grassroots activism that might lead to primary challenges and election losses in the future. The violent evildoers in the crowd, much smaller in number but still several hundred strong at the last, were real, too. But the threat they posed, and that those who likely admire them for their zeal pose, was and is more immediate.

 

Representative Peter Meijer told Reason magazine, “I had colleagues who, when it came time to recognize reality and vote to certify Arizona and Pennsylvania in the Electoral College, they knew in their heart of hearts that they should’ve voted to certify, but some had legitimate concerns about the safety of their families. They felt that that vote would put their families in danger.”

 

Courage is an exceptional quality; one cannot expect people to exhibit it, and being unable to do so does not mark those who fail to show it as bad or sinful. Kevin McCarthy, the top-ranking Republican in the House of Representatives, said during the impeachment debate that Joe Biden won the election. A week earlier, he had voted to object to the electors because he didn’t want to be outflanked on his Trumpian right by the number-two Republican, Steve Scalise. That is normal political behavior. It is understandable. As I say, we cannot expect people to be brave. But we can make note of who stepped up and who didn’t. The Republicans who voted for impeachment, led by Liz Cheney in Wyoming, showed bravery of a rare sort for the reasons I’ve just outlined. They have put their political careers at risk, and perhaps they have put their lives at risk as well.

 

It is painful for me to think that the circumstances of 2021 have compelled me to write these words about elected politicians in the United States, and what these words might portend for this country’s future. And it is painful for me to think as ill as I am thinking today about politicians whose ideological perspective is closer to my own than the politicians who cast what I believe to be the right and proper vote to impeach Donald Trump. But the truth is the truth, and we must look the truth in the face. The Republican Party is in an existential fight for its own survival as a positive force in American politics and American society.

 

At his rallies, Donald Trump loved to recite the lyrics to “The Snake,” in which a “tender-hearted” woman finds a half-frozen poisonous asp. She nurses it back to health. Then it bites her. Dying, she asks why he would do such a thing. “The Snake” concludes: “‘Oh shut up, silly woman,’ said the reptile with a grin. ‘You knew damn well I was a snake before you took me in.’”

 

Trump claimed “The Snake” was a metaphor for illegal immigration, with America as the kind but fatally naive woman and the snake as a stand-in for the illegal immigrants who were supposedly poisoning us. The analogy was labored, but that didn’t matter, because that’s not what the words really meant to Trump or his acolytes. The way Trump recited the lyrics, the snake was not the villain but its hero—and that is how the crowds reacted, roaring with delight at the snake’s grin and the honest and pitiless cynicism his words revealed. Trump loved reciting it, and his throng loved hearing it, because they both knew the truth: He, Donald Trump, was the snake.

 

Trump’s pitiless cynicism was and is the quality they and he most prize in him. He doesn’t stand on ceremony; he squats atop it like a man over a toilet. Asked in a 2015 debate how he could claim he was a true rival to Hillary Clinton when he had made sure she would attend his wedding in 2005, he replied, “She had no choice because I gave to a foundation. I gave to many people before this. When they call, I give. And you know what, when I need something from them two years later, three years later, I call them. They are there for me.” Bill O’Reilly asked Trump how he could say he respected Vladimir Putin, given that he is a killer, and Trump replied, “We have a lot of killers. Well, you think our country is so innocent?”

 

Not any longer I don’t.

Joe vs. the Perpetual Pandemic

By Noah Rothman

Monday, February 08, 2021

 

Of the many rationales that justified a vote for Joe Biden in 2020, the one the president’s campaign preferred most was that he would rein in the out-of-control pandemic and restore a sense of normalcy.

 

“As president,” Biden said at the Democratic Party’s nominating convention, “the first step I will take will be to get control of the virus that’s ruined so many lives.” Specifically, he observed, we could not restore the economy, get kids back in the classroom, and take “our lives back” until the pandemic had been checked. “I will take care of this,” Biden promised during an October presidential debate. “I will end this. I will make sure we have a plan.”

 

According to the Washington Post, that plan was “a far more muscular federal approach” than the one preferred by Donald Trump. His advisers insisted that it was ready to go on day one. And even though it did not differ much from the Trump plan, it nevertheless emphasized a singular objective that was both desirable and imminently achievable: contain the pandemic and reopen society.

 

Since Inauguration Day, however, the Biden administration has telegraphed mixed signals about when or even if we will ever be able to enjoy post-pandemic America. This White House and its allies rarely speak with one voice on the matter. Indeed, executive-branch agencies and appointees regularly contradict one another. And some have even begun to lay the rhetorical groundwork that would justify pandemic-related restrictions in perpetuity.

 

As Dr. Anthony Fauci often insists, the accelerating pace of COVID-19 vaccine distribution suggests that “by the fall of 2021, we can start approaching some degree of normality.” It’s not terribly comforting that we will only be “approaching” a “degree” of normality, but, despite the self-indemnifying ambiguity, at least Fauci articulated a clear goal: “normality.” Others within the public health community aren’t so confident.

 

“Going through the five phases of grief, we need to come to the acceptance phase that our lives are not going to be the same,” insisted former Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Thomas Frieden. “I don’t think the world has really absorbed the fact that these are long-term changes.” That could mean everything from pandemic-related restrictions on social interaction to public masking, testing and temperature-taking regimes, and indoor ventilation standards. As the Wall Street Journal reported, all of this contributes to a “potentially lucrative COVID-19 industry” that, while onerous for most, has been very good to a few.

 

So far, the Biden administration has tried to have it both ways—coddling those who appear to welcome a perpetual pandemic while assuring those who don’t that deliverance is near at hand. In a pre-Super Bowl interview with CBS News, President Biden said that it was necessary and possible for schools to reopen safely in accordance with CDC guidelines, which will be forthcoming shortly (never mind that the CDC produced just such a set of guidelines as far back as last August). But a sprawling White House COVID-19 strategy memo released by the Biden White House last month also provides for the possibility that “new coronavirus variants that may have a higher transmission rate” might forestall the resumption of full-day, in-person education. And, in a late January call with teachers’ unions’ representatives, Fauci said that those variants, which “may” be more resistant to vaccines, are likely to scuttle the president’s desire to see K-8 classrooms reopen nationally.

 

The confusion doesn’t end there.

 

“It’s not just a vaccine [which is] obviously an incredible medical breakthrough, and we want everyone to have one,” said Press Secretary Jen Psaki last week. “But even after you’re vaccinated, social distancing [and] wearing masks will be essential.” But according to the CDC, the efficacy of vaccines that have received emergency FDA approval is such that it “protects you from getting sick with COVID-19.” There may be social benefits in behaving as though being fully immunized does not confer any protection to the virus—for example, communicating to non-vaccinated people that masking is appropriate. But this is a political message, not a scientific one.

 

Likewise, Psaki took the abnormal step of undermining CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky’s authority after the latter had the audacity to say what we know to be a fact: “There is increasing data to suggest that schools can safely re-open and that safe reopening does not suggest that teachers need to be vaccinated.” The notion that “vaccinations of teachers is not a prerequisite for opening schools” may comport with the data, but it also weakens a negotiating position adopted by some especially obdurate teachers’ unions. Dr. Walensky, Psaki insisted, was only speaking in her “personal capacity.” Oddly, the White House elected to make this supposedly personal statement, which Walensky made during a press conference with reporters from behind the James Brady Briefing Room’s lectern, part of the public record.

 

And as some states begin to relax COVID-related restrictions and the winter surge of cases subsides, Biden officials are retreating to the language that typified the earliest days of the pandemic. “100 Days of masking to bend the curve,” Chief of Staff Ron Klain remarked. “Is that too much to ask?” Not only is his reversion to the rhetoric of last March disconcerting, it seems utterly untethered to the metrics around the pandemic, which include not just case rates but deaths and hospitalizations as well. The “curve” is not just bending. It is collapsing. That trajectory is surely aided to some degree by the rapid dissemination of vaccines. It would be unwise to take a premature victory lap, but it is inexplicably hidebound to pretend as though there has been no progress at all over the last month.

 

Underlying all this is an arguably prudent fear that the disease will mutate in a way that renders it uncontrollable again, and anyone who had one optimistic word to say today will be made to account for their faulty predictions at some terrible point in the near future. But soon enough, that prudence will conflict directly with President Biden’s self-set political imperative to restore the pre-pandemic status quo. Whether he wants one or not, a fight is coming, and Biden will have to choose sides.

Sunday, February 7, 2021

The Fracturing of the American Ideal

By Andrew A. Michta

Sunday, February 07, 2021

 

The idea of the self-constituting citizen, endowed with rights and constrained by law, has been indispensable to the forging of a stable democratic political system in America, legitimizing its institutions and ultimately birthing a cohesive nation bereft of the prerequisite of an underlying common ethnicity. This principle has been the source of America’s unprecedented success for over two centuries.

 

In contrast, each time in recent history that governments have favored group-based systemic solutions, despotism has followed and, ultimately, the implosion of the state built upon it. And yet this is where America’s elite class seems hell-bent on taking the nation.

 

The past several decades have witnessed an implacable drive by our leadership class to make group identity the dominant category in our thinking about and practice of politics. Few at the top seem to care how the public is likely to respond to collectivist solutions that not only preference one group of people over another but, in effect, would bury once and for all the quintessentially American assertion that ultimately history can be redeemed only by the individual, for it rests with the content of one’s character and not on government action.

 

The oligarchization of American elites and the parallel pauperization of the citizenry is the real but uniformly suppressed story behind the country’s ongoing Balkanization, while the preferred narrative has been that alleged racial and gender injustice must be overcome by executive fiat. The relative impoverishment of the American middle class has degraded the power of the citizenry to self-govern and has emboldened an increasingly detached elite to indulge in group-based political experiments, with the reengineering of the nation in accordance with ever-shifting notions of “equity and social justice” the ultimate goal.

 

Just before the COVID pandemic hit, almost one third of all Americans lived in lower-class households, with the median income of just over $25,000 a year, less than two-thirds the national median. In 2015 the number of middle-class households dipped below 50 percent. With the lockdowns destroying small businesses, it continues to spiral downward. In contrast, in the 1950s, two thirds of American households were comfortably middle-class. Most importantly, while barely half of all households today belong to the middle class, according to Pew, already in 2014 the gap between the earnings of middle-income and upper-income families was the widest ever recorded in American history.

 

The fading of the middle class has been the predictable byproduct of the corporate off-shoring of our industry and has diminished its influence, a trend accelerated by the persistent disavowal of its values and lifestyles by our nation’s opinion-makers. In a nation where 80 percent of the population has seen its relative economic position decline and, with it, its ability to influence the country’s politics increasingly marginalized, the ruling oligarchy’s continued disregard for their concerns, values, and preferences is a prescription for deepening polarization, political instability, and further unrest.

 

Collectivism in any guise, including its postmodern progressivist variety, has been historically antithetical to a free society, for it ultimately disempowers and muzzles the individual. The foundational assumption of Marxism has been its preference for group categories as the building blocks of society, in an all-out rejection of the post-Enlightenment and quintessentially American ideal of the self-constituting individual. This radical disavowal of the free citizen in favor of class categories was captured by Lenin’s devotee Vladimir Mayakovsky when he declared that the individual human being was an irrelevance in the modern world, for only the proletariat organized for action by the Communist Party could achieve social justice for all. To this day, Marxist social engineers worldwide recoil from the notion that an individual can make sovereign personal choices and remain empowered by law to shape his or her life. Such a self-constituting citizen — and, by extension, society — directly contradicts the “immutable laws of progress” that in the view of the collectivist, have chartered the course of history.

 

What makes America’s flirtation with collectivism striking is that race and gender, rather than class, have become the dominant mode of discourse about group grievance, in blindness to the more prosaic reality of what is driving the fracturing of the American nation. For years, Americans have been indoctrinated in their schools and universities, and conditioned through the media they consume, to look at one another not as members of a community of self-reliant citizens bound together by a commitment to individual freedom under the law, a shared national identity, and mutual obligation, but increasingly as a collection of aggrieved groups, each validated by its own grievance — real or imagined — and poised to exact retribution for the misdeeds of generations past.

 

Today the process of re-racializing American history has nearly reached its climax. We are poised to begin to decompose as a nation along geo-ideological lines, reflecting the territorial alignment of exclusive ideologies, or to witness the triumph of the American Left over a progressively disenfranchised citizenry. If the decline is not stopped soon, the final outcome is likely to repeat the experience of other nations that at some point in their history veered in the direction of group-based social engineering as a pathway to an allegedly more just society.

 

No one can predict how the abandonment of the American ideal of the individual citizen’s rights under the law will ultimately play out, but one thing is certain: When rhetoric and reality fundamentally misalign, chaos reigns.

Joe Manchin Can’t Beat Republicans . . . So He Should Join Them

By Kevin D. Williamson

Sunday, February 07, 2021

 

The West Virginia Senate seat currently held by Joe Manchin should be a Republican seat, and there is every reason to think that Republicans could take it in 2024.

 

But why wait?

 

Senator Manchin is vulnerable. He barely won reelection in 2018, squeaking through with less than 50 percent of the vote against the state attorney general. He is politically moderate, but he is nonetheless effectively Chuck Schumer’s man in a state that gave almost 70 percent of its votes to Donald Trump. Joe Biden, another familiar Democrat presenting himself as a political moderate, could not break 30 percent in West Virginia.

 

Senator Manchin is out of step with his own party. That speaks well of him, but it is awkward for a Democrat to oppose a $15/hour minimum wage, publicly funded late-term abortions, etc. He already is butting heads with Kamala Harris.

 

To no one’s great surprise, Progressive PAC — the people who brought you Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez — are raising money to recruit a Democratic primary challenger to Senator Manchin. Arizona’s Kyrsten Sinema is on the hit list, too. The PAC’s promise is that Senator Manchin and Senator Sinema “will be primaried and replaced in 2024 if they join with Republicans to shrink their own party’s pandemic, climate, and economic plans.” So much for the spirit of independence.

 

Being the last moderate Democrat in the Senate hasn’t made Senator Manchin a king-maker — it has made him a target.

 

Republicans are for obvious reasons thinking more about the 2022 Senate elections, in which picking up a single additional seat would change the balance of power in the Senate, providing a much-desired check on the Biden administration, which has come out of the gates looking like the Bernie Sanders administration. Senator Manchin is not up for reelection until 2024.

 

But that doesn’t mean Republicans have to wait until 2024 to take the seat.

 

In 2024, Manchin will be facing an electorate with a strong Republican advantage in a presidential-election year, and he probably will be doing so after a bruising primary challenge from his left. Republicans should make it clear to him that taking the West Virginia seat is their top 2024 Senate priority, not because Senator Manchin is the worst of the Democrats — he is far from that — but because he presents a target of opportunity. There is unlikely to be another seat that represents as promising a pick-up for Republicans, assuming that they apply some care and intelligence in recruiting a good candidate for the race. (That Republicans cannot always be relied upon to do such things is Senator Manchin’s great hope for survival.) Nothing personal, Senator, just business.

 

This would be one way to convince Senator Manchin that his best shot at staying in the Senate in 2024 is doing what he probably should have done years ago: switching to the Republican Party now. Republicans should do what they can to ease his path.

 

Of course, he’ll ask for the moon. Republicans will have to ask themselves how much putting a brake on the Biden-Harris runaway train is worth to them. I would guess that it will be worth quite a bit.

 

This is not only about Senator Manchin’s reelection hopes, and it isn’t even only about tamping down the worst of what the Biden administration and congressional Democrats will try to do. Senator Manchin has an opportunity to shape American politics in a meaningful way for years to come.

 

For better and for worse, the shape of the Democratic Party’s future is known, and it looks a lot more like Kamala Harris than it does Joe Manchin. He is a 73-year-old, white, male moderate from a largely rural constituency in a party that is dominated by moneyed elites from a handful of big cities, most of them practitioners of an identity politics that would bound Nancy Pelosi in a nutshell.

 

The future of the Republican Party, on the other hand, is up in the air. The populism of the Trump years has revivified Republicans’ interest in certain economic ideas and points of view that they had long overlooked. The GOP doesn’t have to go out and recruit those populist voters, because those voters already are in the party — e.g., about 70 percent of Republicans today support raising the minimum wage. The Reagan-Bush era is well and truly over, free-trade Republican internationalists are on the ropes — and the future of the party is up for grabs.

 

A moderate former Democrat from a solidly Republican state, with an interest in energy, national-security issues, and a more activist health-care policy, could provide a few bridges between a few important factional divides in the GOP.

 

And if it matters at all, there is a very good case to be made that the interests of the people of West Virginia would be better served by having Senator Manchin in a position of genuine influence rather than in the position of looking over his shoulder.

 

There is no shame in Senator Manchin’s having a price — and no shame in Republicans’ paying it. Let’s make a deal — because that seat probably is going to go Republican with or without Joe Manchin.