By Elliott Abrams
Wednesday, February 02, 2022
All over the world, from China to Russia and Iran to
Venezuela, men and women lie in foul prison cells for the “crime” of peacefully
protesting oppression. In 1961, well-meaning people founded Amnesty
International to advocate for the release of such patriots.
But Amnesty International (AI) has left that focus far
behind, and has now produced a vicious attack on Israel that is reminiscent of
nothing so much as the Soviet anti-Semitic and anti-Israel tracts from the
height of the Cold War. AI’s report, Israel’s Apartheid Against
Palestinians: Cruel System of Domination and Crime Against Humanity, is a
shockingly dishonest document whose biases against the Jewish State leap off
each of its 280 pages. Some young diplomat in the Israeli Foreign Ministry will
no doubt go through it paragraph by paragraph, and assemble a pile of lies that
reaches the Ministry’s roof. But for our purposes, a few examples will suffice.
If I said that World War II started when “conflict broke
out in 1939” rather than saying that it started when the Nazis disassembled
Czechoslovakia and invaded Poland, you’d say I was a Nazi propagandist and
either a liar or an ignoramus. But that’s essentially what AI does in this
document when it refers to “the 1947-49 conflict before and after the May 1948
declaration of the State of Israel,” stating that “thousands of Palestinians
and Jews were killed and more than 800,000 Palestinians were displaced from
their homes in the context of attacks on civilians.” That Israel accepted
partition and the Arab states all then attacked it is of course unmentioned; to
hear AI tell it, the “conflict” just happened, more or less like an earthquake
or some other natural disaster. That Arab leaders urged Arabs to flee is also
unmentioned, as is the desire of some to escape war and violence. No — everyone
who left did so “in the context of attacks on civilians.”
Another good example is Gaza. Israel left the territory
in 2005 — removing every single Israeli settler, every soldier, and every
military base. Yet AI refers to it as “occupied” by Israel about a hundred
times in this document. If keeping the border closed to prevent infiltration by
terrorists constitutes “occupation” of Gaza, then Gaza is occupied by Egypt as
well — but that is a point AI does not wish to make.
What about the terrible conditions under which AI says
Israeli Arabs live? The report’s authors somehow manage to avoid mentioning
that while Arabs are 20 percent of all Israelis, they are 35 percent of Israeli
pharmacists. Already in 2015, 16 percent of all medical students in the country
were Arab; at the Technion medical school, perhaps Israel’s most prestigious,
Arabs comprised 38 percent of students by 2015, and at Ben-Gurion University of
the Negev, they comprised 31 percent. Today, an Arab party is part of Israel’s
governing coalition for the first time in the country’s history — hardly a sign
of unbreakable apartheid and oppression.
Throughout this document, Israeli Arabs are referred to
as “Palestinians.” Amnesty’s goal here is clear: It wishes to suggest that they
are not really Israeli and are instead oppressed and treated as foreigners.
According to Amnesty, Jews are Israelis; Arabs are “Palestinians.” But that is
not what Israeli Arabs say: a 2020 poll by the Jewish People Policy Institute
in Jerusalem reported “a dramatic rise in the share of Arab Israelis who define
their primary identity as ‘Israeli,’ and a concomitant sharp decline in the
share who self-identify as ‘Palestinian.’” Amnesty, of course, is not
interested in anything that contradicts its party line. This “report” on Israel
is 280 pages long. If you’re looking for the 280-page Amnesty report on China,
or Iran, or Russia, don’t bother; only Israel gets this kind of treatment.
This document is laced with invective: It relies heavily
on charges of “crimes against humanity,” “racism,” “apartheid,” “oppression,”
and “domination.” All this is eerily redolent of the worst anti-Israel
propaganda of the past. On April 1, 1983, Pravda, the official
newspaper of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, ran a full front-page
article titled “From the Soviet Leadership.” Here is what it said about Israel:
By its nature, Zionism concentrates
ultra-nationalism, chauvinism and racial intolerance, excuse for territorial
occupation and annexation, military opportunism, cult of political
promiscuousness and irresponsibility, demagogy and ideological diversion, dirty
tactics and perfidy.
Amnesty could use those lines as a summary of its report.
Amnesty’s own website explains how the organization
began: “In 1961, British lawyer Peter Benenson was outraged when two Portuguese
students were jailed just for raising a toast to freedom. He wrote an article
in The Observer newspaper and launched a campaign that provoked an incredible
response.” But it also explains that “after more than 50 years of
groundbreaking achievements, Amnesty has been through a major transformation.”
On that much, AI is right: It has been transformed into a propaganda arm of the
global struggle against the Jewish State, which uses language taken from the
Soviet playbook and holds Israel to standards no other country is asked to
meet.
No comments:
Post a Comment