By Jonathan Marks
Monday, June 22, 2020
I have written before about the case of Rutgers professor
Jasbir Puar, lionized
by academics on the left despite or because of her anti-Semitic attacks on
Israel.
Recently, the most egregious of Puar’s claims resurfaced
in an incident at Florida State University. The Student Senate President, Ahmad
Daraldik, reportedly built a website that, among other things, accuses Israel
of organ harvesting. But she adds a twist: Just as
“the Nazis conducted many different types of experiments on the inmates of the
concentration camps,” so, too, do the Israelis harvest organs.
In Puar’s case, the charge goes back to unsourced rumors
concerning Israel’s activities during the “knife intifada” of 2015-16. In our
student’s case, the charge goes back to the 1990s and concerns a single
facility in which corneas, heart valves, and skin grafts were taken, sometimes
without family permission, from approximately 150 cadavers. Among those bodies
were, as Daraldik’s web site tells you, Palestinians. Also among them, as it
does not tell you, Israeli soldiers and civilians.
To compare this incident, in which a pathologist broke a
law and thereby harmed Jewish and non-Jewish families, to Nazi experimentation
is gross Holocaust minimization and inversion. As Miriam Elman of the Academic
Engagement Network says, the comparison is “unequivocally anti-Semitic.” Yet a
Student Senate that quite recently, in an overwhelming vote, removed its
president over remarks he’d made in an online group chat—he’d stressed the
incompatibility between his Catholicism and queer and transgender politics on
the other—voted to keep Daraldik in office. Perhaps they were motivated to do
so by a letter,
signed by numerous purportedly progressive organizations, that mentions
Daraldik’s First Amendment rights, doesn’t mention the website, and pretends
that Daraldik is the victim of a “smear campaign” to suppress legitimate
criticism of Israel.
In fact, critics are instead perpetuating the view that
Daraldik can be held to account for noxious views that—though it is unclear
when exactly the website went up—he has not disowned.
John Thrasher, FSU’s president, has issued a statement
affirming the university’s opposition to anti-Semitism. While he initially
wrote merely of “offensive anti-Israel rhetoric,” the statement has since been
modified to read “anti-Semitic rhetoric.” That is a heartening correction.
As a rule, I am not in favor of taking the extraordinary
measure of removing someone from office over troubling remarks, even in student
governments. Nor am I in favor of picking on young people who may well know
better when they’re a little older. What we should object to and be concerned
about is this: Even in a time of heightened scrutiny of people’s utterances and
actions, even in a time when admissions offers are being rescinded for racist
social media posts, anti-Semitism wins plaudits.
When it comes to anti-Semitism, the “woke” are fast
asleep.
No comments:
Post a Comment