Saturday, March 23, 2024

GOP Meets Limits to Donald Trump’s Victimhood Appeal

By Chris Stirewalt

Friday, March 22, 2024

 

Conventional wisdom among Democrats holds that President Joe Biden is being victimized by the mainstream media. 

 

Republicans—for whom disdain for the media is practically an article of faith—may be surprised to hear Democrats complain about “press coverage that unduly reflects GOP frames.” 

 

And yet, as many Democrats try to puzzle out why the incumbent is locked, even slightly behind, in a tight race with former President Donald Trump, many come back to the idea of “false equivalency” in coverage of the two presumptive nominees. In this telling, it is not that Biden’s age isn’t an issue, but that the news media gives equal weight to Biden’s infirmity and Trump’s misconduct. 

 

It is, of course, an easy climb from that not entirely unreasonable, if academic, assertion to one that regards such coverage as the principal reason voters are uncomfortable with having a sometimes doty 81-year-old seeking another four years in office. This position compounds the problem of Biden’s age by inviting Democrats to underestimate their candidate’s real liabilities.

 

Republicans, meanwhile, are suffering from the inverse delusion.

 

As the consequences of Trump’s many legal difficulties start to come down on the former president’s head, Republicans have a long-rehearsed answer: It actually helps him with voters.

 

Being charged with crimes helps him with black voters who understand the idea of a two-tiered justice system. It helps him with fed-up independents who see him being attacked by elites. It helps him because, in an inverted embrace of the same Democratic notions about Biden coverage, it gets Trump more airtime.

 

As with the blue team’s complaints about equivalency, these claims are not entirely meritless. There’s hardly a better way to reestablish a former president’s brand as a disruptive outsider than to have him play the role of the system’s victim. Like a banned book, Trump, a retread and party boss, gets an advantage from seeming like a transgressive figure.

 

Where that was particularly true was … among Republican voters. The criminal and civil charges against Trump did wonders for reuniting the majority of the GOP behind their former nominee. The 2024 Republican primary campaign wasn’t so much between Trump and his inter-party rivals, but between Trump and his many enemies, chiefly Biden. Even many Republican voters who would have preferred a change in leadership didn’t want to abandon Trump as he was fighting to stay out of jail.

 

But here’s where the problems come in. Republicans are now applying their self-talk to the broader electorate, imagining that the arguments that were persuasive to millions of two-time Trump voters apply to those swing voters who defected in 2020 and many more who saw January 6, 2021, as an unforgivable offense.

 

Trump’s big problem right now is that he can’t afford to pay his legal bills, an interesting predicament for a fellow whose claim to fame is being a billionaire. Trump, of course, doesn’t want to admit that’s the truth. Instead, much to the presumed chagrin of his lawyers, he claims that he has the cash on hand to pay his own way, but that he doesn’t want to do so because he wants to spend that money on his campaign—which is also undoubtedly false.

 

So where can Trump get the dough? One of his lawyers left the door open to accepting money from foreign powers, including  “Saudi Arabia or Russia.” Woof. Or there’s a Wall Street maneuver in which Trump could balloon his balance sheet by billions if his MAGA supporters run up the price of his fizzle of a media company. But that wouldn’t deliver a short-term solution. Neither Saudis nor stonks are ideal financing moves for a presidential candidate.

 

A more direct approach is to wring the cash out of Republican donors. This applies to Trump’s army of small-dollar supporters, who might be moved with lines like “KEEP YOUR FILTHY HANDS OFF TRUMP TOWER!” For the whales, it’s a more personalized touch, with a big soiree in Palm Beach. 

 

But however Trump gets the fish on the line, the money goes the same place, according to the Associated Press: 

 

“The invitation’s fine print says donations to the Trump 47 Committee will first be used to give the maximum amount allowed under federal law to Trump’s campaign. Anything left over from the donation next goes toward a maximum contribution to Save America, and then anything left from there goes to the RNC and then to state political parties.”

 

Trump and his legal fees get taken care of first, then whatever is left trickles down to the party. This is how the new Republican National Committee—led in part by Trump’s daughter-in-law—can say that the committee isn’t going to pay his legal fees. The RNC is going to help Trump raise the money directly and then take the scraps.

 

For donors who don’t feel pangs of sympathy for Trump being at risk of losing his 15-bedroom Westchester County estate, the appeal of victimhood will have its limits. 

 

Biden has already pounced on Trump’s predicament, joking to his own fatcat backers

 

“Just the other day, a defeated-looking guy came up to me and said, ‘Mr. President, I need your help. I’m being crushed with debt. I’m completely wiped out.’ I had to say, ‘Donald, I can’t help you.’”

 

Trump’s mad scramble for cash is just the beginning of what will be many long months of mania, all of which will reasonably invite questions about Trump’s priorities and doubts about his independence. If Trump could previously say that he was too rich to be bought off, it won’t be so easy now.

 

There is truth in both Democrats’ and Republicans’ delusions about the way negative coverage works for or against their candidates. But right now, it looks to be the GOPers who are in for an education on the limits of soothing self-talk.

No comments: