By William Z. Nardi
Friday, October 18, 2019
Since the sexual revolution of the 1960s, the feminist
movement has sought to condemn traditional sexual ethics as repressive,
misogynistic, and intolerant. As the 2010s come to a close, it might be fair to
say that mainstream culture has reached the logical endpoint of this
philosophy. Whereas older Americans perhaps still remember a time when our
society promoted mutual self-sacrifice over hedonism, we live in an age when
even children have access to limitless online pornography.
There’s an irony here. The behaviors featured and
sometimes encouraged by porn are the same behaviors third-wave feminists love
to hate. While activists on the left accuse college campuses of turning a blind
eye on “rape culture,” one study suggests that men who view pornography are
significantly less likely to intervene as a bystander in situations leading to
sexual assault and report increased behavioral intent to rape.
Conservatives have long argued that treating consent as
the only boundary in sexual matters overlooks matters of character, but
modern-day feminism has ignored this conversation. That wasn’t always the case.
The late radical feminist Andrea Dworkin was the last major intellectual of a
left-wing bent to engage the public on the immorality of porn consumption and
its nexus with sexual violence. Pleading with Americans to stop turning a blind
eye, Dworkin said in a 1993 speech:
Today there is a community of
people who have articulated the experience of what it means to be a woman, what
it means to be turned into pornography, what it means to be bought and sold . .
. call it what you want, call it speech . . . [but] it happens in real life,
women’s lives are made two-dimensional and dead . . . this is the crime of
dehumanization; we’re not talking about violence yet, we’re nowhere near
violence; this is what it means to be dehumanized.
Now many feminists have a selective memory when it comes
to Dworkin’s work. Johanna Fateman, who recently co-authored an anthology of
Dworkin’s work, told the New York Times
that “Dworkin lost the sex wars so decisively that we can now see beyond her
most extreme rhetoric. . . . You don’t have to be afraid that Andrea Dworkin is
going to take your pornography away.”
Instead, the “sex positivity” movement has won. Since at least
2013, colleges across the U.S. have hosted hundreds of “sex-week” seminars.
While individual feminists’ views on pornography may vary, a 2015 study of data
from the U.S. General Social Survey from 1975 to 2010 showed that both men and
women with pro-feminist attitudes are more likely to watch porn.
Suffice it to say that Dworkin would be horrified by this
development. She was especially scathing of “progressive men who linked sexual
libertinism with women’s emancipation, seeing them as no better than
conquistadors in hipster attire,” Jennifer Szalai wrote in a New York Times retrospective of her
work. “For all their critiques of capitalism, these men seemed remarkably
untroubled when the commodity was women,” Szalai added.
Far from boycotting the industry, however, the more
progressive corners of the feminist movement encourage watching pornography. “Viewership is notably growing
among women, some of whom are giving porn a second look through a sex-positive
lens,” Lucia Graves wrote in the Guardian.
(To be sure, some lonely feminists are still challenging the porn industry.)
Academics such as Madita Oeming, a self-proclaimed
“public porn scholar” and “sex-work-inclusive feminist,” go so far as to claim
that the notion of porn addiction is a fallacy invented by “the media, church
and self-help industry.” As Oeming wrote in Vice,
“To pathologize certain sexual identities or practices is almost a tradition
for us. Porn addiction continues this tradition.”
But the numbers paint a more sobering picture. A 2014
study showed 79 percent of men in the U.S. ages 18 to 30 reported viewing
pornography at least monthly. By age 14, 94 percent of kids will have seen
pornography. What’s more alarming is that, according to Peter Kleponis, a
clinical therapist treating porn addiction in Pennsylvania, “By the age of 15,
80 percent of teenagers will have had multiple exposures to violent
pornography.” The younger a man was “when he first viewed pornography,” the
American Psychological Association has noted, “the more likely he was to want
power over women.”
Yet perhaps some progressives are beginning to rethink
their no-judgment attitude toward the porn industry. New York Times columnist and staunch liberal Michelle Goldberg
wrote recently about renewed interest in Andrea Dworkin’s work — “a sign,” she
said, “that for many women, our libidinous culture feels neither pleasurable
nor liberating.” The next step is investigating the roots of our pornified
culture, which enslaves men and women to their basest appetites.
No comments:
Post a Comment