By Rich Lowry
Tuesday, October 29, 2019
California is staying true to its reputation as the land
of innovation — it is making blackouts, heretofore the signature of
impoverished and war-torn lands, a routine feature of 21st-century American
life.
More than 2 million people are going without power in
Northern and Central California, in the latest and biggest of the intentional
blackouts that are, astonishingly, California’s best answer to the risk of
runaway wildfires.
Power — and all the goods it makes possible — is
synonymous with modern civilization. It shouldn’t be a negotiable for anyone
living in a well-functioning society, or even in California, which, despite its
stupendous wealth and natural splendor, has blighted itself over the decades
with misgovernance and misplaced priorities.
The same California that has been the seedbed of
world-famous companies that make it possible for people to send widely viewed
short missives of 280 characters or less, and share and like images of grumpy
cats, isn’t doing so well at keeping the lights on.
The same California that has boldly committed to
transitioning to 50 percent renewable energy by 2025 — and 100 percent
renewable energy by 2045 — can’t manage its existing energy infrastructure.
The same California that has pushed its electricity rates
to the highest in the contiguous United States through its mandates and
regulations doesn’t provide continuous access to that overpriced electricity.
California governor Gavin Newsom, who has to try to evade
responsibility for this debacle while presiding over it, blames “dog-eat-dog
capitalism” for the state’s current crisis. It sounds like he’s referring to
robber barons who have descended on the state to suck it dry of profits while
burning it to the ground. But Newsom is talking about one of the most regulated
industries in the state — namely California’s energy utilities, which answer to
the state’s public utilities commission.
This is not exactly an Ayn Rand operation. The state
could have, if it wanted, pushed the utilities to focus on the resilience and
safety of its current infrastructure — implicated in some of the state’s most
fearsome recent fires — as a top priority. Instead, the commission forced
costly renewable-energy initiatives on the utilities. Who cares about something
as mundane as properly maintained power lines if something as supposedly
epically important — and politically fashionable — as saving the planet is at
stake?
Meanwhile, California has had a decades-long aversion to
properly clearing forests. The state’s leaders have long been in thrall to the
belief that cutting down trees is somehow an offense against nature, even
though thinning helps create healthier forests. Biomass has been allowed to
build up, and it becomes the kindling for catastrophic fires.
As Chuck DeVore of the Texas Public Policy Foundation
points out, a report of the Western Governors’ Association warned of this
effect more than a decade ago, noting that “over time the fire-prone forests
that were not thinned, burn in uncharacteristically destructive wildfires.”
In 2016, then-governor Jerry Brown actually vetoed a bill
that had unanimously passed the state legislature to promote the clearing of trees
dangerously close to power lines. Brown’s team says this legislation was no big
deal, but one progressive watchdog called the bill “neither insignificant or
small.”
On top of all this, more people live in remote areas
susceptible to fires, in part because of the high cost of housing in more
built-up areas.
There shouldn’t be any doubt that California, susceptible
to drought through its history and whipped by fierce, dry winds this time of
year, is always going to have a fire problem. But there also shouldn’t be any
doubt that dealing with it this poorly is the result of a series of foolish,
unrealistic policy choices.
California’s overriding goal should have been safe,
cheap, and reliable power, a public good so basic that it’s easy to take for
granted. The state’s focus on ideological fantasies has instead ensured it has
none of the above.
No comments:
Post a Comment