By Michael Brendan Dougherty
Wednesday, October 02, 2019
It is often said these days that if any other president —
Obama, Bush, Clinton — said the things President Trump says, we would be much
more upset.
Of course, it is true. We would be more upset if other
presidents had said the things Trump says — because they might have meant those
things if they’d said them.
Journalists, those hyper-verbal strivers whose words
count so much in their lives, struggle to cover a president who says so much
that means so little.
First, there are the phrases Trump coins and repeats like
mantras without bothering to define them. “Presidential harassment” is a
legally and almost politically meaningless phrase. Trump loves it.
Then, there are the approving citations of his
supporters’ most incendiary statements, which we can trust Trump likes because
they are approving, rather than because they are incendiary. When he quotes
some hyped up political pastor saying that impeachment of the president will
lead to a civil-war-like fracture in our republic, we know he is just rewarding
an empty, if hysterical, flatterer, rather than giving us a judgement about the
body politic that we should consider.
And then there are the statements whose meaninglessness
is underlined by Trump’s willingness to discard them just as easily as he
utters them. “Lock her up” he says of Hillary Clinton, until deciding that “she
went through a lot and suffered greatly.” “And Mexico is going to pay for it” he
says of the border wall, until the U.S. Air Force does.
Saleno Zito famously said that Trump’s supporters “take
him seriously, not literally.” There is something to that. But even among those
inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt, his statements can cause
confusion. He made a habit at campaign rallies of saying things like, “If you
see somebody getting ready to throw a tomato, knock the crap out of them, would
you? Seriously, OK? Just knock the hell . . . I promise you I will pay for the
legal fees. I promise. I promise.” At one point, referring to a protester, he
told a crowd of supporters that, he’d “ like to punch him in the face, I’ll
tell you.” A few weeks later, a protestor was being taken out of a rally in
Fayetteville, N.C. when John Franklin McGraw got up and sucker punched him. If
McGraw expected Trump to pay his legal fees, he’d made the mistake of taking
the president literally twice.
The most meaningless words Trump ever spoke were on a
phone call with President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey. Trump asked Erdogan
if Turkish forces could finish the job against ISIS. Erdogan said yes, and
Trump, speaking down into the line, told his then-national-security adviser,
John Bolton to “start work for the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Syria.” He
would follow up that instruction with equally meaningless words: “Our boys, our
young women, our men — they’re all coming back, and they’re coming back now. We
won, and that’s the way we want it, and that’s the way they want it.”
Over the following two months, the White House announced
that the exact opposite of a troop withdrawal was happening. Our boys, our
young women, our men — they were all staying in Syria, after all.
Why doesn’t Trump pay more of a political price for his
carelessness in speech? Because Americans have a very odd folk morality, in
which being authentic is as important or more important than being appropriate
or good. He makes sure his audience knows he is a jokester, an occasional thug,
a self-serving cad, and even a liar. He lives up to his own billing — and
Americans appreciate getting the genuine article.
If a President Kamala Harris or Elizabeth Warren said
“lock her up” from the West Wing, one could safely assume that someone would be
imprisoned that very night. When President Trump says something like that, I
wait for some kind of confirmation or action from the White House or the
executive branch.
Most of the time, it never comes.
No comments:
Post a Comment