By Kevin D. Williamson
Tuesday, May 05, 2020
Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is feeling a
little blue. One sympathizes.
In her first year in office, Representative Ocasio-Cortez
showed all the signs of someone making the callow error of believing her own
publicity: She was arrogant, vain, petty, foolish, and vindictive, to say
nothing of embarrassing and ignorant. You remember: “We’re in charge — and
you’re just shouting from the cheap seats,” it’s more important to be “morally
right” than “being precisely, factually, and semantically correct,” her
cocksure illiteracy on Middle Eastern issues. Perhaps you would have done a
great deal better if you had taken a seat in the House at 29. I am not
confident that I would have.
Since then, she has suffered a one-two punch: She arrived
in Washington thinking she was going to be a force for radical change but ran
into the immovable object that is Democratic complacency, discovering that she
was an idealistic young Latina representing the Bronx and Queens in a party run
by Nancy Pelosi and other rich old white people who like things the way they
are — politicians second, socialites first. And then she learned that a great
many of the non-white middle-to-lower-income voters she believes to be her
semi-private fief do not share her taste for socialism and boutique radicalism
on the Bernie Sanders model and threw their support to Joe Biden instead.
She was the only Democrat to vote against the $484
billion coronavirus bill. This troubles her.
“Our brains are just designed to experience a lot of
excruciating pain at the idea of being alone,” she tells the New York Times,
in an excellent profile written by Mark Leibovich. “When you cast those lonely
votes, you feel like your colleagues respect you less, and that you are
choosing to marginalize yourself.” Naturally, she lapsed into her
self-romanticizing mode, imagining herself starring in a movie called The
AOC Story: “I walked home in the rain,” she said. Of course she
walked home in the rain. “I was very in my feelings, big time, and I felt very
discouraged . . . . I was just, like, heartbroken,” she said. “I have, like,
existential crises over it.”
Those final “likes” make mockery all too easy. But take
her seriously for a moment.
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez holds an elected office, but she
is not a creature of politics — she is a creature of media, from cable
news to Twitter. She has much more in common with fellow New Yorkers Sean
Hannity and Bill O’Reilly than she does with such House predecessors as Sam
Rayburn and Tip O’Neill. And even as she imagines adolescent little cinematic
vignettes for herself, soulfully walking home through the rain and all that
silliness, she is not the lead writer on The AOC Story — only an
actress. She cannot control the media story arc any more than anybody else can.
“I felt like my colleagues were making opinions about me based on Fox News,”
she told Leibovich. “It almost felt like instead of them actually talking to
the person who was next to them, and physically present in front of them, they
were consuming me through television. And I think that added a lot to the
particular loneliness that I experienced.”
Like most people in the media business, I am familiar
with what she is trying to talk about.
We are all caricatures in the monkey-minded discourse of
social media and cable news. The human brain has only so much processing power,
and so we tend to shove people into categories and then to treat them
categorically rather than understand them as individual human people with
individual human minds, just like us. (That is the subject of my book The
Smallest Minority.) The first category we are inclined to push people into
is “Enemy.” If you are on the enemies’ list, then that is all we need to know
about you. Everything else can be tailored as necessary. As William Makepeace
Thackery put it in Vanity Fair: “One of the great conditions of anger
and hatred is, that you must tell and believe lies against the hated object, in
order, as we said, to be consistent.” That’s the root of the Left’s “Everybody
who disagrees with me is a racist!” canard. Ocasio-Cortez, who indulges in that
sort of thing herself all too often, should give that some thought. She is part
of the problem.
A very few politicians are the sort who do not need
politics. Senator Ben Sasse, for example, seems to enjoy politics, but he does
not seem to need it. You get the sense that he could be happy doing any
number of other things with his life. George W. Bush would have had a great
life if he’d never been a governor or president. Condoleezza Rice has made it
very clear that she does not need politics. Daniel Patrick Moynihan never quite
gave himself over to elected office. But much more common are the Lyndon
Johnson type, the Hillary Rodham Clinton type, the Al Gore type, who
desperately need to act out their dramas in the theater that politics provides
for them. They are the sort of people who fear that they will stop existing if
people stop paying attention to them — tedious in a party guest, crippling in a
political class.
“Even if you are a minority of one, the truth is the
truth,” Mohandas Gandhi advised. Some people find that advice easy to accept
but difficult to live. To be alone can be hard. It is difficult to learn to be
appropriately indifferent to criticism, but it is even more difficult, and even
more necessary, to learn to be appropriately indifferent to praise.
Representative Ocasio-Cortez has obviously enjoyed her 15 minutes of Warholian
celebrity and has developed a mild addiction to praise — not from the people
dying in droves in her district in New York City, but from the man on the
television, the faces on social media, the New York Times, the
celebrities. She liked doing those fashion spreads with Kerry Washington. And
who could blame her?
But unless she learns to meet praise and criticism with
exactly the same scorn, she will never be of any real use to the people in her
district, who have been dying of COVID-19 in shocking numbers.
And surely they deserve an occasional thought, too.
In Closing
Funny thing about snobbery: The insecurities that cause
it very often exist only in the mind of the person afflicted. In that Times
profile, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez says this about her time at Boston
University: “The first week everyone was asking each other, ‘What school did
you go to?’ And I was like, ‘Uh, public high school.’” Public school! Her
anxiety was unfounded: The great majority of BU students, about two-thirds of
them, come from public high schools. The great majority of freshmen admitted to
the Ivy League colleges come from public schools, too. But The AOC Story
needs some drama, and she is committed to the character she has chosen for
herself.
No comments:
Post a Comment