By Michael Brendan Dougherty
Monday, March 23, 2020
The president of the Council on Foreign Relations,
Richard Haas, has been busy writing elegies to the Western world order every
time Trump sneezes. Now he sees what will follow that order. This week he
tweeted, “US standing taking a hit b/c of how badly we are handling
#coronavirus at home & how little we’re doing for others. China, despite
its being where the virus began & its dropping the ball at first, gaining
influence b/c it is meeting the challenge at home & offering help to
others.” A number of suddenly soft-headed analysts are saying the same — that
China is increasing its soft power in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic.
This is dangerous nonsense. Much of it is motivated by a
hatred of Donald Trump that extends beyond the legitimate criticisms of how he
handled the virus. It rests on grading China on a curve, on admiring the bully
and harasser for his occasional moments of charm or remorse.
China has been praised for sending “planeloads” of
ventilators to assist Italy when the European Union was blocking medical
supplies and ignoring pleas from that country. It is true that ventilators
came, but Italy’s hospitals paid for them. China has pretended that fulfilling
purchase orders is an act of unprecedented national solidarity. The United
States, meanwhile, does real acts of charity without fanfare. As early as the
first week of February, the U.S. committed to giving money to countries
affected by COVID-19, including China, and sending 17.8 tons of medical
supplies to China.
We should see China’s international efforts not as
enhancing its credibility and prestige but as a desperate bid to salvage an
international reputation from utter ruin. China has been a persistently bad
actor in the public-health arena, before and during the initial outbreak. They
are also transparent opportunists.
China made its first mistake more than a decade ago.
After the outbreak of SARS in 2003, China initially promised to close down its
“wet markets,” where exotic animals are slaughtered for human consumption.
Chinese consumers eat bats and pangolins for superstitious fad-health reasons.
But these markets are a vector for transmitting diseases from bats and other
animals to humans. Just one year after a SARS outbreak that panicked East Asia,
China reopened these markets despite many warnings from scientists and health
authorities that they were a public-health menace to the entire world.
Speaking of those authorities, this crisis has revealed
how China has suborned and corrupted the World Health Organization, which, for
political reasons, ignored credible warnings about the new coronavirus from
doctors in Taiwan and instead credulously repeated statistics from authorities
in Beijing, the ones downplaying the extent of the crisis. The World Health
Organization delayed calling the virus a health emergency and then criticized
U.S. travel restrictions placed on China, without reference to public-health
reasoning, only to vague ideology. The WHO was trying to save China its
embarrassment. And still, China wouldn’t cooperate transparently with the WHO.
China silenced whistleblowers who tried to warn the world
of the emerging disease. It censored news reports until it finally relented and
threw tremendous resources at fighting the disease in Wuhan. But experienced
and skeptical observers of China are throwing a great deal of cold water on
China’s announcements that it has defeated the virus and that work is about to
commence again, suggesting that the reported numbers about Wuhan’s infection
and death toll could be seriously understated.
Now, during the crisis, China is acting like a bully. The
state has threatened to withhold key pharmaceuticals to increase the pain on
Americans, saying that without them America will be “plunged
into the mighty sea of coronavirus.” Further, China is currently setting
restrictions on such American companies as 3M that manufacture medical-grade
masks and other safety equipment in China, barring them from exporting these
goods from China for use in America and other nations where there is a current
shortage. Worst of all, China is actively spreading propaganda that COVID-19 is
a bioweapon invented by the U.S. Army. Finally, China has expelled from its territory
all American national reporters working for the prestige newspapers of the
United States. Say what you will about the New York Times, it has had
the best coverage of the coronavirus in the world.
It is true that the Trump administration’s 30-day travel
ban on Europe gave an unwelcome surprise to European leaders. And it is true
that Trump, certain Republicans, and some conservative outlets spread
misinformation in the early days to minimize this crisis. That’s to their
eternal discredit. But a measure of real soft power isn’t made by totaling up
the credulous statements of foreign-policy mandarins and China-flattering
stories in the media. Look at the worldwide lurch
for and interest in U.S. dollars.
If the Chinese state had used its massive state capacity
to run a minimally functional equivalent to the Food and Drug Administration,
there would be no COVID-19 and the world economy would still be humming. If the
Chinese state had been minimally honest, the world would have had several weeks
longer to prepare. If it had not corrupted the international institutions
responsible for world health, we would have been more prepared. And they have
the gall to blame the United States military.
COVID-19 is the greatest act of geopolitical arson in six
decades. Every journalist and expert praising the pyromaniac for attempting to
save himself, blame others, and cover his tracks has made himself contemptible.
No comments:
Post a Comment