By Tom Rogan
Wednesday, June 29, 2016
Brexit and the rise of European conservative politics is
receiving derision from liberal outlets ranging from Vox.com to the Washington Post. The vote to leave the
European Union, the U.S. media say, is the product of xenophobia and little
more. CNN’s Christiane Amanpour claimed that the Brexit movement testified to a
deeply concerning vein of European hatred for others (caveat: Amanpour’s
husband is one of those all-too-rare Americans who stands up for our country
when abroad). Such accusations flow in the wake of Edward Said’s otherness principle — the idea that the
West dehumanizes foreign strangers. While such claims resonate in university
lectures, they do not connect with reality. Because the truth of contemporary
European conservatism has far more to do with economics and social mobility
than it does with xenophobic hatred.
Of course, this is not to say that xenophobia isn’t a
problem on the European continent. It is. More specifically, it is a problem on
the far Right. At the violent end, the problem manifests most clearly with
terrorists such as the Norwegian mass-murderer Anders Breivik. At the lower
(but serious) end, we see France’s National Front party, Austria’s Freedom Party,
and Denmark’s People’s Party. These movements are growing in popular support
and parliamentary representation. But they are not conventional conservatives.
For a start, unlike their conservative competitors,
Europe’s far-right parties are fervent supporters of bloated welfare states as
well as opponents of free trade. Additionally, where European conservatives
call for immigration reforms, the far Right calls for outright (often religious
or-nationality specific) bans on foreign immigration.
And that speaks to a broader point. The rise of
right-wing politics in Europe isn’t a function of the far Right but rather the
result of steady gains by the mainstream European conservative right. The best
example here is what occurred in Britain last summer, when David Cameron’s
Conservative government defeated the odds and won a small but highly
significant parliamentary majority. Cameron secured victory because he
responded to the Great Recession with targeted spending cuts that helped
restore economic confidence. He succeeded, in other words, because he governed
as a sensible conservative.
In the same way, Chancellor Angela Merkel’s Christian
Democrats have now governed Germany for nearly 11 years. While there are
far-right movements in Germany, they have not been able to attract anywhere
near the levels of support that Merkel has. In France, although Marine Le Pen’s
National Front leads socialist President Francois Hollande in opinion polls for
next year’s election, she trails conservative frontrunner Alain Juppe by a 7-10
point margin. Meanwhile in hapless Greece, beset by an ongoing economic crisis
and led by a hardline socialist government, opinion polls show the conservative
New Democracy party with a sustained 6-8 percent lead. And last weekend in
Spain, facing the confident left-wing Podemos party, conservative Prime
Minister Mariano Rajoy increased his party’s share of parliament.
The takeaway: First, conservatives are winning in Europe.
Second, were European conservatism dependent on xenophobia; far-rightists would
be winning far more.
Of course, all of this raises the question of why
traditional conservatives are winning. Again, the answer is simple. As Opportunity Lives has explained,
Europeans are waking up to decades of socialist mismanagement and choosing
alternatives. Consider a few of the critical problems the European socialist
delusion has wrought: the economic dysfunction of the European Union;
immigrant-integration failure; Europe’s entrepreneurial reliance on the United
States; and the idea-less anger of the European far Left. Even Scandinavia
suffers from this pandemic of socialist malaise.
Ultimately, the rise of European conservatism isn’t about
xenophobia or anger. It’s about the increasingly obvious and systematic failure
of socialist ideology. An ideology of good intentions that transforms the
wealthy nations into toilet paper-ocracies. Having run out of patience,
Europeans are turning to conservative alternatives.
No comments:
Post a Comment