National Review Online
Saturday, July 09, 2016
Thursday night’s attack in Dallas marks the deadliest day
for American law enforcement since September 11, 2001. An ambush that started
just before 9 p.m. local time, toward the end of a peaceful Black Lives Matter
demonstration, left four members of the Dallas Police Department and one member
of the Dallas Area Rapid Transit authority police department dead, and seven
other officers and two civilians injured. The gunman, 25-year-old Micah X.
Johnson, who told a hostage negotiator that he “wanted to kill white people,
especially police officers,” was so successful only because of the bravery of
Dallas’s finest, who spent the evening monitoring Black Lives Matter
protesters, then rushed to shield demonstrators when shots rang out. On a week
marked by intense hostility against our law enforcement, Dallas police reminded
us of the courage and selflessness displayed by the vast majority of America’s
men and women in uniform.
Police have yet to release the identities of the three
suspects in custody, who are believed to have conspired in planning the attack.
But about the motivations behind this episode there can be little doubt. Dallas
police chief David Brown has said that the perpetrators clearly “planned to
injure and kill as many law-enforcement officers as they could.” Johnson, who
appears to have been the lone gunman, was a Facebook fan of the African
American Defense League, which regularly called for violence against cops.
Recent posts encourage readers to “ATTACK EVERYTHING IN BLUE EXCEPT THE MAIL
MAN” and “sprinkle Pigs Blood.”
Responsibility for this vicious, cowardly act lies solely
with the killer. But this tragedy is another reminder that the temperature
should be lowered in the debate over policing and race.
Of course, Black Lives Matter almost exists to do the
opposite, and a poisonous minority of it has even encouraged violence against
police. In New York City in late 2014, protesters chanted: “What do we want?
Dead cops. When do we want them? Now.” Not long after, Ismaaiyl Brinsley
assassinated two NYPD officers, Wenjian Liu and Rafael Ramos, in their patrol
vehicle.
The reactions to the recent officer-involved shootings of
Alton Sterling in Baton Rouge, and Philando Castile in Falcon Heights, Minn.,
which prompted the demonstrations in Dallas and elsewhere, have been typically
inflammatory. It is far from clear whether the officers acted justifiably, and
the available evidence raises serious questions. We understand the passions
evoked by these tragic encounters, partially captured in graphic videos.
Nonetheless, Black Lives Matter activists immediately labeled the deaths
“murder,” and appropriated them to a well-known narrative of an “epidemic” of
police violence against black Americans. Meanwhile, Minnesota governor Mark
Dayton blamed Castile’s shooting partly on “racism,” and President Obama
decried “racial disparity in the justice system.” Events in Ferguson and
Baltimore, where the facts did not support the instant Black Lives Matter
narrative, have shown the imprudence of these sorts of knee-jerk
pronouncements.
That is not to say that there are no legitimate criticisms
of police. There are bad cops, whose recklessness — or worse — should be
subject to more-vigorous discipline or, if necessary, prosecution. And there
are sensible reforms on offer from more thoughtful activists to which law
enforcement should be open. In fact, the Dallas Police Department has evidently
been a model for police reform. Excessive-force complaints against the
department dropped by 64 percent between 2009 and 2014, and arrests and
officer-involved shootings also declined, in tandem with a decline in the
city’s murder rate, which reached an 80-year low in 2014.
In contrast, the venom of Black Lives Matter may have
given us a “Ferguson Effect” in major cities, where less-robust policing
appears to have created the conditions for a spike in the murder rate (although
more data is necessary for definitive conclusions). The conduct of Dallas’s
police is a reminder of why the cops shouldn’t be hounded and smeared: Whatever
the unfortunate truth in a handful of individual cases, the vast majority of
law enforcement are honorable public servants, who put their lives on the line,
day in and day out, for their fellow citizens — white, black, and otherwise.
No comments:
Post a Comment