By Alexander Zubatov
Friday, September 23, 2016
If you spend any time online, whether on mass media or
social media, you might be forgiven for believing that an overwhelming majority
of Americans believes in political correctness, affirmative action, and
identity politics.
But the reality is that most Americans have a very
different view of these issues, even though they do not voice that view. They
stay silent.
Well, take this as my appeal to all of you: it’s high
time for your voices to be heard.
I live in New York City—the place Ted Cruz famously
denounced as having “New York values.” I don’t know exactly what that means,
but I have a sneaking suspicion it means “liberal.” As is typical in this
diverse melting pot of a city, I have friends who are white, black, Asian, and
Hispanic … and most of them are, indeed, “liberal.”
But here’s the thing: among all my friends,
acquaintances, family members, and extended family members living in this
notorious bastion of liberalism, I can think of a grand total of one person who is a fan of so-called
“political correctness” and identity politics. Again, in case you missed it,
that number was one.
We Aren’t As
Politically Correct As We Pretend To Be
I know that isn’t exactly a scientific survey. You want
science? Here’s science. According to a
Pew Survey on the topic of political correctness, 59 percent of Americans
believe “too many people are easily offended these days over the language that
others use,” while only 39 percent think “people need to be more careful about
the language they use to avoid offending people with different backgrounds.”
Among whites, those numbers are 67 percent versus 32
percent respectively, while among blacks, the numbers are more or less reversed
(30 percent versus 67 percent). Older people are actually more likely to support political correctness than their younger
peers: Seventy percent of Democrats 65 and older “think people should take greater
care to avoid offending others”—compared to 58 percent of 30 to 49-year-olds,
and 56 percent of Democrats under 30. Meanwhile, “a majority of Republicans
across age categories say people today are too easily offended by language.”
Now let’s consider race-based preferences. Surely, now
that even the Supreme Court has come down squarely on the side of permitting
race-based university admissions, it must reflect the beliefs of most
Americans, right?
Not only is that dead wrong—it’s wrong for Americans of
all races. According to a Gallup poll, 65 percent of Americans disapproved of
that 2016 Supreme Court decision (Fisher
v. University of Texas), with only 31 percent approving. According to the
same poll, 70 percent of Americans believe college admissions should be based
solely on merit (with 76 percent of whites, 50 percent of blacks, and 61
percent of Hispanics sharing that view). Sixty-seven percent of whites, 57
percent of blacks, and 47 percent of Hispanics said race or ethnicity should
not factor into college admissions at all.
We Aren’t Huge
Fans of ‘Multiculturalism,’ Either
What about multiculturalism? Haven’t most Americans
embraced the party line that says we ought to accentuate our vibrant racial and
ethnic identities, focusing on what makes us unique?
If you believe that, here’s another Pew Survey to
disillusion you: “Among whites, more than twice as many say that in order to
improve race relations, it’s more important to focus on what different racial
and ethnic groups have in common (57 percent) as say the focus should be on
what makes each group unique (26 percent).” Even among blacks, a slightly
higher percentage (45 percent) believes the focus should be on “commonalities”
rather than on “differences” (44 percent).
So what gives? If popular opinion leans so clearly in one
direction on these issues, why does public dialogue lean so clearly the other
way?
The dispiriting answer is that political correctness is
succeeding in its objective: it’s shutting people up. Political correctness
bullies, shames, and silences those who have dissenting views on various
sensitive issues—even if those with dissenting views represent a majority.
Prominent moral psychologist Jonathan Haidt believes that
in “liberal” environments—elite East- and West-Coast schools and universities,
academic institutions and think-tanks, major coastal cities such as New York
and San Francisco, left-leaning media organizations, etc.—whites,
conservatives, men, straight people, and others who were way too historically
oppressive feel like they are “walking on eggshells.” They don’t feel they can
discuss topics such as race, gender, or homosexuality, and tend to stay silent.
Opposing Political
Correctness Poses A Huge Risk
This should not be surprising. The consequences of not staying silent can be devastating.
Making racially insensitive remarks in private conversation, using the N-word
during a decade-old sex tape, admitting to using the N-word at some point in
the past, using a word that sounds like
the N-word but has nothing to do with it, writing an e-mail telling
university students not to be so politically correct, or writing a single
misinterpreted tweet with racial overtones: these things can get you fired and
ostracized. In such an environment, why would it shock anyone if people choose
not to speak out?
Once again, I can furnish some anecdotal support for this
suggestion. A Pew Survey has revealed, for instance, that white people tend not
to talk about race on social media: “Among black social media users, 28% say
most or some of what they post is about race or race relations; 8% of whites
say the same. On the other hand, roughly two-thirds (67%) of whites who use
social media say that none of [the] things they post or share pertain to race.”
It could be that this racial gap reflects the fact that
race matters more to blacks than it does to whites—and surely this is part of
the picture. But with our media’s 24-7 focus on racial issues in America, I do
not believe only eight percent of white people have thoughts on the subject.
Clearly, something else is going on—and political correctness is the number one
candidate for that “something else.” These white people are afraid to say what
they really think.
Why You Shouldn’t
Stay Silent
Consistent with this conclusion, among all my family,
friends, and acquaintances — among whom, again, only one is generally
supportive of identity politics — no one, other than that one (and he is
black), speaks publicly on this topic. Many of those same people have advised
me to stop sharing my views about these issues, for fear something I say will
come back to bite me.
This is my response to them, and to all of you who stay
silent: if political correctness is a toxin to the health of our body politic,
then political cowardice is the auto-immune disorder through which it spreads.
By refusing to be bullied, by defying intolerance, by standing up to this new
illiberal McCarthyism, by opposing those who want to divide and judge us based
on the color of our skin, by choosing a real diversity of ideas over a
superficial diversity of pigments, by rejecting the principle that there is
anyone here entitled to stifle the speech of those with whom they disagree, we
join the proud tradition of Americans and others worldwide and throughout
history who have had the courage to oppose injustice.
Let this be a rallying cry. Don’t toe the line. Don’t
hide on your silent island. Feel the wind at your back. Come sail on the rising
tide that will carry us all forward into the more open waters that lie ahead.
No comments:
Post a Comment