By Andrew Roberts
Thursday, May 16, 2024
Zero hundred hours, Tuesday, June 6, 1944
British and American airborne troops, flown in on more
than 1,000 aircraft, began to land in occupied Normandy in order to secure key
objectives before the landings by sea. Elite Pathfinder units arrived first,
marking out the terrain. “The first Skytrains appeared,” one observer later
recalled, “silhouetted like groups of scudding bats.” German flak hit the
planes “like large hailstones on a tin roof” as the paratroopers trod floors
slippery with vomit and readied themselves before jumping down and down, thousands
of feet, sometimes through cloud and fog. They were weighed down by up to 80
pounds of weapons, ammunition, and supplies. They knew that when they reached
the ground, there would be merciless opposition — some of those whose
parachutes got caught in trees were burned alive by flamethrower. They fought
in fields and hedgerows lit only by the moon and by tracer fire.
What men they were. How can we not, reading of their
actions that extraordinary day, hold our manhood cheap when we contemplate what
they attempted, and achieved. It makes us wonder how we would have fared had it
been our generation that had to liberate Europe from Nazism.
“Every man thinks meanly of himself for not having been a soldier,” said
Dr. Johnson, “or not having been at sea.” To contemplate the experiences of the
men who fought on D-Day 80 years ago this month is to appreciate the true
nature of what we, sometimes all too glibly, call “the Greatest Generation.”
0215
Part of the vast invasion fleet of more than 6,800
vessels was spotted by the Germans in Cherbourg, but the Germans were already
fighting Allied airborne troops and could not react to the threat of the
largest seaborne assault in history as it sailed toward Normandy. One German
noncommissioned officer said the ships looked like “a gigantic town on the
sea.” The defenses at Cherbourg were so powerful that the Allied planners had
to choose five beaches on which to land, in what was to be the greatest campaign
of the western war.
Unlike the strategy of any other military operation in
the 20th century, this one depended for success on a single day’s fighting. If
what the planners described as a “satisfactory foothold” had not been gained by
nightfall, it very likely wouldn’t be gained at all. It was therefore a
desperate, war-defining risk that justified the commitment of no fewer than ten
Army divisions, going ashore in two great waves.
British prime minister Winston Churchill fully recognized
the dangers. In the fifth volume of his history of the Second World War, he
wrote about the demands for an early “second front” in western Europe:
The Channel tides have a play of more than twenty feet,
with corresponding scours along the beaches. The weather is always uncertain,
and winds and gales may whip up in a few hours irresistible forces against
frail human structures. The fools or knaves who had chalked “Second Front Now”
on our walls for the past two years had not had their minds burdened by such
problems. I had long pondered upon them.
An overhasty return to the Continent, before the battle
of the Atlantic was won and complete air superiority gained, could have
resulted in disaster. As Churchill recalled telling Joseph Stalin at the
Kremlin in August 1942 when he demanded an immediate second front, “War was war
but not folly, and it would be folly to invite a disaster which would help
nobody.”
“If the Germans decided to bring their maximum forces to
the beachheads,” estimated the historian Sir Martin Gilbert, “the Allied armies
could have been defeated on the shore.” There had already been a long history
of failed or faulty amphibious operations in both world wars — Gallipoli,
Dakar, Dieppe, Salerno, and Anzio among them. Landing troops on hostile shores
against determined enemy resistance is the hardest of all military maneuvers.
Field Marshal Gerd von Rundstedt, the German commander in
chief in the west, believed that the Allies would require four consecutive days
of good weather to conduct a successful cross-Channel operation, and none of
his forecasters could see such a clear period. The cypher that he used for
discussions about the weather had been broken by the Allies and decrypted at
Bletchley Park, where more than 12,000 people were employed; not one leak
emerged. Fortunately, the Germans had no access to the reports from a single
weather station at Blacksod Point in County Mayo, Ireland, which indicated to
the RAF’s meteorologist, Group Captain Dr. James Stagg, that despite a storm on
June 5, the weather would improve for long enough for the invasion to take
place the next day.
Supreme Commander of the Allied Expeditionary Force
General Dwight D. Eisenhower, who was smoking 80 Camel cigarettes a day and had
blood-pressure levels indicating hypertension, took the momentous decision to
launch the invasion. He watched with tears in his eyes as the 101st Airborne
Division took off from Greenham Common that night.
The stakes could hardly have been higher: If D-Day had
failed, it would have postponed the liberation of western Europe by at least a
year. With the Germans developing new weaponry, such as rockets with one-ton
warheads, refuelable U-boats, jet aircraft, and advanced underwater mines, the
war could have dragged on far longer, especially since large numbers of
Wehrmacht troops would have been redeployed to the east to fight the Red Army
in Belarus. Equally, if the Russians had destroyed the German armies there,
nothing could have prevented most of western Europe — perhaps even as far as
Paris — from falling under Stalin’s Communist grip.
D-Day was the result of two years’ diligent planning
between American, British, and Canadian staffs. When Lieutenant General Sir
Frederick Morgan arrived at the planning headquarters at Norfolk House in St.
James’s Square to start it, all he found in his new office was a pencil that
someone had dropped on the floor. “Well, there it is,” General Alan Brooke said
of the operation. “It won’t work, but you must bloody well make it.”
The highly talented Anglo-American-Canadian staff did
make it work, and ultimately Operation Overlord was to be the supreme
expression of the cooperation, strength, and determination of the
English-speaking peoples. The debacle at Dieppe in August 1942 — in which 3,900
men of a mainly Canadian assault force of 5,100 had been killed, wounded, or
captured — stood before the planners as a terrible warning. Mistakes would be
made on D-Day, as in every military operation before and since, but taken
overall, the choice of the specific beaches, the timing of the attack, the
overall strategy for the days after, and the commitment of resources were a
triumphant success.
Yet that was by no means certain when the aerial bombing
began at:
0300
Using the almost complete air superiority that had been
hard won over the previous months, especially since the P-51 Mustang had
started to clear the Messerschmitts from the skies of western Europe from
January 1944, Allied bombers began their massive raids against German defenses
across Normandy. While the Luftwaffe flew 319 sorties over Normandy that day,
the Allies flew 13,688. In all, some 11,500 Allied warplanes of various types
took part in D-Day, of which only four were shot down. It was as much of an
armada in the air as the naval one that was now dominating the English Channel.
Allied air superiority was an absolute prerequisite for
victory on D-Day, for without it, the Germans could have counterattacked far
more powerfully than they did. There is nothing inevitable in history, except
for German counterattack. It had been seen many, many times in World War II
already and was to be again in the Battle of the Bulge at the end of 1944.
Yet in 1944, while Britain produced 28,000 warplanes and
Russia and Germany produced 48,000 each, the United States produced no fewer
than 98,000. The extraordinary industrial capacity that allowed America to
fulfill President Franklin Roosevelt’s promise of making the U.S. “the arsenal
of democracy” was such that whenever a GI saw a plane flying above him on
D-Day, there was a 99.2 percent chance that it would be an Allied plane.
The United States’ ability to turn over its vast
industrial might to crush Nazism meant that by 1944 there were no fewer than 18
shipyards across the country, producing three ships every two days. In southern
England, the amount of covered storage space for the supplies needed for D-Day
was 57 million square feet, and it housed more than 450,000 tons of ammunition.
It was partly the vast size, but also the heavy
responsibility of the operation, that reduced one squadron of RAF pilots to
utter silence after they received their briefing about what was going to happen
on D-Day. “There was no conversation, no laughter,” wrote one overawed officer.
“No one lingered and we filed out as though we were leaving church. Expressions
remained solemn. The task ahead outweighed all our previous experiences and
sent a shiver down the spine.”
After a late night with a visiting Hungarian delegation,
Adolf Hitler went to bed at the Berghof above his mountain residence in
Berchtesgaden. He was not told about the events in Normandy, and his orderly
had strict orders not to wake him the next morning. So the Führer was fast
asleep when the armada arrived off the coast of Normandy at:
0400
The moment when the troops climbed off the ships and onto
the 3,000 specially designed landing craft was a nerve-wrackingly vulnerable
one, especially since the sea was extremely choppy. Nonetheless, the men were
successfully transferred, and the landing craft, most of them designed and
built at the Higgins dockyards in New Orleans, set off toward the five
designated beaches.
“You are about to embark upon the Great Crusade, towards
which we have striven these many months,” Eisenhower told the men shortly
before their departure. “The eyes of the world are upon you.” Similarly,
General Bernard Montgomery, the commander of Allied land forces, told them, “To
us is given the honor of striking a blow for freedom which will live in
history, and in the better days that lie ahead men will speak with pride of our
doings. We have a great and righteous cause.” No one doubted it.
Yet for all their public optimism, several senior figures
had severe reservations about D-Day, which were more than justified by the
risks involved. “It may well be the most ghastly disaster of the whole war,”
noted General Sir Alan Brooke, the chairman of the British chiefs of staff, in
his diary. Back on July 11, 1943, Winston Churchill had told Henry Stimson, the
U.S. secretary of war, “I see the Channel being full of corpses of defeated
Allies.” As the operation began, even the usually cheery and optimistic
Eisenhower said to his staff, “I hope to God I know what I’m doing,” and he
wrote a resignation letter that he kept in the top pocket of his tunic in case
the operation failed. The true measure of that great man can be read in its
selfless wording:
Our landings in the Cherbourg-Havre area have failed to
gain a satisfactory foothold, and I have withdrawn the troops. My decision to
attack at this time and place was based on the best information available. The
troops, the air and the Navy did all that bravery and devotion to duty could
do. If any blame or fault attaches to the attempt, it is mine alone.
The difficulties of putting tanks into the water became
apparent at:
0535
Of the 29 tanks launched into the Channel and destined
for Omaha Beach, no fewer than 27 sank in the rough seas, and only two got
ashore. This made the American assault there all the harder, especially as all
20 artillery pieces sank too, along with the 13 amphibious trucks carrying
howitzers. It was one of many disasters, which had begun with the rehearsal for
D-Day undertaken at Slapton Sands in Devon on April 29, 1944, when seven German
torpedo boats killed up to 700 Americans — the exact numbers are still
disputed.
Immensely high casualty rates were widely expected for
D-Day. Indeed, the planners anticipated there being around 20,000 killed or
wounded. Sapper Captain Logan Scott-Bowden of the Special Boat Section had swum
ashore at Omaha Beach in the dead of night back in January to collect sand
samples for the planners. When he took them to Norfolk House and reported to
General Omar Bradley, he said, “Sir, I hope you won’t mind my saying it, but
this beach is a very formidable proposition indeed and there are bound to be
tremendous casualties.” Bradley put a hand on his shoulder and said, “I know,
my boy: I know.” It was, however, the only beach between Utah Beach on the
right and the British beaches to the left. There was no alternative if the
landings were going to take place in Normandy. “Don’t worry if you do not
survive the assault,” one officer jocularly told his men. “We have plenty of
backup troops who will just go in over you.”
With large numbers of paratroopers drowning in flooded
fields, more friendly-fire incidents than were officially recorded, and the
tank and artillery crews capsizing in heavy waves, many things continued to go
badly wrong. General Lesley McNair was killed in a friendly-fire incident that
left his body “unrecognisable except for the three general’s stars on his
collar.” One plane dropped its paratroopers too low and their corpses were
found in a neat line where all had died on impact. A sergeant reported of the
deaths of another 18 paratroopers as sounding “like watermelons falling off the
back of a truck.” Some of the 18,000 paratroopers dropped behind Sword and Utah
Beaches landed miles off target, and three-quarters of the three battalions of
British sappers who went ashore to clear mines were killed by German
machine-gun fire. The fog of war was evident on D-Day, as it is in all wars.
One of the other major failures of the day took place at:
0600
As dawn approached, the U.S. Eighth Air Force bombed the
landing areas at Utah and Omaha Beaches half an hour before the troops landed.
Thirteen thousand bombs were dropped, which did some damage on Utah even though
bad visibility meant that only 67 of the 360 U.S. bombers were able to drop
their bombs. At Omaha the situation was far worse. Because they did not want to
hit the oncoming armada, the bombers flew in across the beaches rather than
along them. So virtually no bombs landed on the German emplacements on Omaha
Beach, meaning that the defenders were ready when the American V Corps went
ashore at:
0630
German machine-gunners wreaked terrible destruction as
the landing craft disgorged their men onto Omaha Beach. “Men were tumbling like
corn cobs off a conveyor belt,” one sergeant from Wisconsin recalled. The
opening scene of the movie Saving Private Ryan captures very well
the terror, courage, and chaos of the assault, with German mortar-shell
explosions turning beach pebbles into grapeshot. The Americans lost almost 800
men on Omaha alone, and no fewer than 30 pairs of brothers killed in Overlord
are buried side by side in the cemetery there. Despite the losses, they managed
to land 18,772 men on Omaha and Utah Beaches once tanks and destroyers finally
managed to blast through the defences and the infantry captured the high
ground. Some naval guns grew so hot from constant firing that they had to be
continuously hosed down with water.
Back in Germany, Field Marshal Erwin Rommel, who had
returned home for his wife’s birthday party, was woken with news of the attack.
He drove to France immediately. The speed of the German response was further
complicated by confusion over who had the right to move the Panzer units
stationed in and around Normandy. From February 1944, Field Marshal Gerd von
Rundstedt (commander in chief of Army Group West) and Rommel (commander in
chief of Army Group B) had overlapping commands, and neither had command over
the Luftwaffe or Kriegsmarine (German navy), while the antiaircraft corps
stayed under the control of Hermann Göring.
Rommel controlled three Panzer divisions and Rundstedt
six, but personal orders from Hitler, who was sleeping, were necessary for
their release, and because the German army commanders still suspected that the
Allied attack might be only diversionary, Hitler was not woken until 10 a.m.,
when his munitions minister, Albert Speer, arrived at the Berghof.
The Allies, despite consisting of three major countries
on D-Day, had a well-established unity of command under Eisenhower, who was
answerable to the combined chiefs of staff. By contrast, the German high
command, despite having one Führer, had confusingly overlapping structures and
reporting lines. Hitler also showed a blind faith in the defensive capacities
of the Atlantic Wall, built over four years by 2 million slave laborers, a
faith that was perplexing in someone who had so easily outmaneuvered the Maginot
Line four years earlier.
0725
British forces landed at Sword and Gold Beaches, and
shortly afterward the Canadians landed at Juno Beach. They met resistance,
though not so fierce as at Omaha, and managed to move inland. It is a moot
point whether the progress of the British and Canadian forces was ultimately
helped or hindered by RAF’s heavy bombers’ systematic destruction of the inland
town of Caen, which started at:
1345
Montgomery had earmarked Caen for capture in the first
three days of the campaign, but it did not fall until July 9. This might have
been in part due to the bombing of the town, which gave the Germans ample
opportunity to hide their machine-gun nests amid the rubble. Montgomery’s
strategy failed at Caen, but the German concentration on it did at least ease
the American breakthrough farther west.
The population of Caen had already been reduced from
60,000 to 17,000 by evacuation, but the destruction on D-Day and D+1 led to the
death of around 800 French civilians there. About 3,000 French people died on
D-Day, mostly from their liberators’ bombs and shells rather than the Germans’,
and in all around 20,000 civilians were killed during the Normandy campaign,
which Antony Beevor and other historians have denounced as “almost a war
crime.” Caught in the cross fire between the biggest amphibious assault in
history and tough German resistance, even bombarded by their own Free French
Navy, the people of Normandy paid heavily for their liberation.
Of the 4,572 Allied soldiers killed on D-Day, 2,500 were
American, 1,641 were British, 359 were Canadian, 37 were Norwegian, 19 were
Free French, twelve were Australian, and two were from New Zealand. Even though
the French took little part in the invasion, around 3,000 French Resistance
fighters did invaluable work in cutting rail lines in some 950 places, which
held up Panzer divisions being sent from southwest France.
When, on June 4, Churchill briefed Charles de Gaulle, the
leader of the Free French, about Operation Overlord, de Gaulle insisted on a
series of conditions for his support even though the landings were only two
days off. Negotiations got so heated by the early hours of June 6 — with de
Gaulle calling Churchill “a gangster” and Churchill calling de Gaulle “a
traitor” — that Churchill ordered de Gaulle to be sent back to his headquarters
in Algiers, “in chains if necessary,” adding, “He must not be allowed to enter
France.” It took the best diplomacy from the British foreign secretary, Anthony
Eden, to have the order revoked.
De Gaulle first set foot in France on June 14, and then
for only a one-day visit to Bayeux. While he was there, a local cried out,
“Vive le Maréchal!” — confusing him with the collaborationist president,
Marshal Pétain. “Another person who does not read the newspapers,” de Gaulle
muttered to an aide. After his visit to Bayeux, de Gaulle left for Algiers and
did not return to French soil until August 20, five days before the liberation
of Paris.
Operation Overlord finally blew away the collaborationism
that had infected so much of Occupied France since its surrender in June 1940.
Otto Abetz, Hitler’s envoy to Paris, recalled that of the 20 French politicians
who visited him every day in 1940, 19 would ask for petrol coupons, rationing
exemptions, special favors for friends and family, and so on, and only “the
twentieth spoke of France.” The actress Arletty, star of the movie Les
Enfants du paradis, had her own way of escaping rationing, by sleeping with
a Luftwaffe officer who lived at the Ritz. When she died in 1992, the criticism
of her was not over her collaboration horizontale but the fact that
she and her lover had eaten so well during the war while her countrymen had
starved. (Ironically enough, the Luftwaffe officer later became a West German
diplomat and was eaten by a crocodile while ill-advisedly swimming in the River
Congo.)
For all his rows with de Gaulle, and his fears for the
success of the operation, Churchill never lost his sense of humor. When a
member of Parliament asked him on June 8 to promise to ensure that the same
mistakes would not be made after World War II as were made after World War I,
Churchill replied, “That is most fully in our minds. I am sure that the
mistakes of that time will not be repeated. We shall probably make another set
of mistakes.”
1400
Despite slow progress in the heavy fighting at Omaha
Beach, the first exit was cleared there by American forces. On the other four
beaches, Allied troops were pushing inland. The Canadians who landed at Juno
covered seven miles by end of day and were the only ones to reach all their
objectives. (One reason might have been their older average age compared with
that of the British and Americans — 40 years against 20.) However hard the
training had been — U.S. Airborne troops had to crawl through hogs’ entrails as
part of their toughening-up procedure — it was nothing like actual conflict. As
Professor Sir Michael Howard, who won the Military Cross in World War II, put
it, “No amount of training on the gentle Yorkshire dales could prepare green
troops for the ghastly experiences that confronted them when they saw their
mates having their heads blown off by shellfire or had to scrape their remains
out of brewed-up tanks with mess-tins and spoons.”
Local German counterattacks were well under way by:
1500
After hours of Hitler’s dithering, and in the face of
Allied aerial dominance, the counterattacks were nothing like so effective as
had been feared by the planners. The Panzers were able to impede the momentum
of the invasion and prevent Caen from falling, but they could not by then drive
the Allies back into the sea. At 2015, a German counterattack aimed between
Sword and Juno Beaches was halted once the Allies captured the Hillman
strongpoint.
The relative lack of Panzer reserves behind the beaches
was in part due to the Allies’ two ingenious deception plans, Operation
Fortitude North and Operation Fortitude South, which had been years in the
making and made the German high command believe that the attack would be taking
place in the Pas de Calais, across the narrowest, 22-mile stretch of the
English Channel, rather than 140 miles to the south in Normandy. The deception
was the most impressive in the history of warfare. Fortitude North tied up 372,000
German troops in Norway, while Fortitude South kept half a million German
troops in the Pas de Calais until June 26.
Key to Fortitude South was Juan Pujol García, a Spanish
double agent who duped the Abwehr (German Intelligence) into believing that he
was running a network of no fewer than 29 sub-agents in Britain, even though
all were fictitious. He was the single most important spy of the Second World
War, because it was he who fooled the Germans into thinking that his espionage
network had discovered that the invasion point would be the Pas de Calais. His
imaginary sub-agents included a Venezuelan student, a Dutch commercial pilot, a
Gibraltarian waiter, merchant seamen, Indians, Canadians, and even a Welsh
Aryan Nazi. (The story was later used by Graham Greene for the plot of Our
Man in Havana.)
So successful was García — codenamed “Garbo” by his MI5
handlers because he was “the world’s best actor” — that the Germans were
continuing to reinforce the Pas de Calais even long after D-Day instead of
committing their full resources to countering the Normandy landings. On top of
his efforts, a fake First U.S. Army Group was created. Made up of dummy tanks
and aircraft and stationed across the Channel from the Pas de Calais under the
command of General George S. Patton, it was visited by King George VI. The
Germans could not believe that Patton, the best tank commander of the U.S.
Army, would not be in a key position in the invasion. In order to continue the
ruse, an actor posing as Montgomery was also sent to Gibraltar.
To keep the invasion secret, all diplomats in the weeks
prior to the invasion were prevented from leaving Britain, military leave was
canceled, movement around southern England was banned, and even the postal
service stopped. Not a word leaked.
1720
The situation on Omaha Beach was now such that wheeled
and tracked vehicular traffic could be accepted on most of the area below the
high-water mark. A relieved General Leonard Gerow, the commander of
V Corps, proceeded to set up his headquarters ashore, and by midnight on
that “longest day” the Allies had landed more than 156,000 men in Normandy by
air and sea who could not now be dislodged from their beachheads. More than 2
million men would follow them to the Continent over the next three months.
Once the troops were ashore, the fighting in the
hedgerows of the Norman bocage was immensely fierce, and Anglo-American losses
ran at 2,000 men per division per month after D-Day. The bodies in the
hedgerows became so swollen that the burial teams had to knee them in the back
to release the gas before they could be taken away for burial.
The story of the American breakout from Normandy and the
wholesale slaughter of the German armies in the Falaise Gap has been well told
in books by distinguished historians such as Stephen Ambrose, Antony Beevor,
Peter Caddick-Adams, Carlo D’Este, Martin Gilbert, Max Hastings, and John
Keegan. On August 2, 1944, Churchill spoke for the whole House of Commons in
“expressing its unstinted admiration for the splendid and spectacular victories
gained by the United States troops under General Bradley, both at Cherbourg and
in the southward march, now become almost a gallop down the peninsula.” He
continued: “The Germans have certainly had remarkable opportunities of revising
the insulting estimate which they put upon the military value of the American
army at the time they declared war upon the great Republic.”
***
Operation Overlord represents the greatest single service
that the English-speaking peoples rendered civilization. Although it took
almost another year to extirpate Nazism, Hitler’s downfall was now a matter of
when, not if. Montgomery predicted that, when contemplating the men who
undertook the operation, future generations would speak with pride of their
doings, and he was right.
Yet are we not also in a sense mocked by the doings of
the Greatest Generation on D-Day? Although Eisenhower’s language about a
“crusade” might not pass modern inclusivity or sensitivity tests, was not the
certainty of their belief in the superiority of democracy and liberty and the
benefits of Western civilization something noble, and something we are in the
process of busily throwing away? They knew what was worth fighting and dying
for, whereas today we seem to be unsure of everything, even down to the pronouns
we should use for one another.
The men who stormed the beaches of Normandy knew that
they had nations behind them that would keep them in ammunition till they
bearded the Nazi beast in its lair. By stark contrast, the United Kingdom today
barely has enough 155mm shells to defend itself for three days, its military
capacity has been entirely hollowed out, and the Royal Navy numbers 19 surface
warships but 41 admirals. Britain will not even allow the inflatable small
boats used by illegal immigrants to cross the English Channel to be given to
the Ukrainian army to cross the Dnieper River because, the government says,
they are “unseaworthy.”
Meanwhile, the United States is slicing back its navy
just as the world gets ever more dangerous, and intellectuals and journalists
sneer at the “special relationship” between the United Kingdom and the United
States that provided such comradeship and support for the soldiers of World War
II. The men of Operation Overlord had leaders such as Winston Churchill and
Franklin D. Roosevelt, while today the world’s greatest democracy has thrown up
two presidential candidates who are palpably unfit to hold high office — one
owing to defects of character and the other to failing cognitive function.
We were handed a fine inheritance by the Greatest
Generation, which we have squandered, frittering away our moral superiority
through an obsession with the (undoubted) crimes of well over two centuries
ago. Faced with the essentially Nazi ideology of Hamas — whose sole object is
to complete in the Middle East what Adolf Hitler nearly achieved in Europe — we
crave cease-fires, hypocritically lecture Israel on “proportionality” and
embargo her armaments, repeat Hamas propaganda on casualty figures, and allow students
to terrify innocent Jews on our university campuses.
Similarly, faced with a totalitarian Russian dictator who
is clearly in the Rhineland-Sudetenland phase of his revanchist
empire-rebuilding, the isolationist heirs of Charles Lindbergh seek to deny
Ukraine the weapons she desperately needs to defend herself. What moral pygmies
we are compared with the giants of 80 years ago. We salute the Greatest
Generation on this anniversary, while we shame their sacrifice and shun their
example.
No comments:
Post a Comment