By Jonah Goldberg
Monday, October 14, 2013
Over at Politico, Roger Simon has written a fairly
trollish bit of “analysis,” which leads off with what he calls a joke about how
America would be better off if John Boehner and Ted Cruz drowned. It goes on
with the usual clichéd dreck about the shutdown being racist and so on. No doubt
many liberals think it’s right on target. But that’s not what interests me.
Simon’s column reminds me of a point I’ve been making for years. Most
mainstream journalists roll their eyes at the idea the MSM is biased. It’s a
tired argument, I know. But it’s simply remarkable that when supposedly
objective reporters move on to the opinion column racket they reveal themselves
as utterly conventional liberal Democrats. When any longtime New York Times reporter
rewarded with a column at the Times or elsewhere — Nick Kristoff, Bill Keller,
Maureen Dowd, Anthony Lewis, EJ Dionne et al. — rips off the mask it turns out
that they were exactly as liberal as conservatives suspected. It’s like that
Saturday Night Live skit where Obama takes off his Obama mask to reveal that
he’s Barack Obama.
Just going by the law of averages, some of these
reporters should turn out to be conservative or libertarian or at least
ideologically heterodox. But it almost never happens. Indeed, when the Times
needs to find a conservative columnist (Bill Safire, David Brooks, Ross
Douthat) it always has to hire outside its own shop.
Jay Carney got his job working for Joe Biden, and later,
Barack Obama because his employers knew from the get-go that the Time reporter
was ideologically simpatico with the administration. The same goes for Linda
Douglas, not to mention Richard Stengel, Shailagh Murray, and many others. I
wonder if any of them ever feel insulted when Democratic politicians just
assume that supposedly objective reporters would make great partisan hacks?
Sometimes the revolving door goes the other way. Tim
Russert was, I’ll grant, more of a straight shooter than David Gregory is
(which kind of proves my point), but he was simply plucked from the Democratic
machinery, as was George Stephanopoulos (who’s done a better job than most in
making the switch with intellectual integrity). Sure, there have been a handful
of straight reporters who’ve gone Republican, but their numbers are so tiny
their examples serves as the exceptions that prove the rule.
So here’s Roger Simon, who made his name as a straight
reporter at all the right outlets and it turns out that his worldview all along
was exactly what the conservative media critics would have expected. There’s no
crime here. Some of his work back then was legitimately very good and some of
his columns as a liberal pundit are quite good as well (though today’s column
is a mess). And one can even applaud the effort some of these people exerted to
cover their real views when they were supposed to be objective. But from the
conservative perspective it was a lot of wasted effort, because they didn’t
fool anybody — except maybe the journalists themselves.
No comments:
Post a Comment