By David Harsanyi
Tuesday, April 02, 2019
In progressive America, an official elected in a
predominantly Jewish district in the country’s largest city can be punished for
asserting an indisputable historical fact if it happens to offend the
sensibilities of hard-left activists. In this case, Kalman Yeger, a councilman
from Brooklyn, in a back-and-forth about Rep. Ilhan Omar, tweeted that,
“Palestine does not exist. There, I said it again. Also, Congresswoman Omar is
an antisemite. Said that too.”
Mayor Bill de Blasio quickly issued an ultimatum to Yeger
demanding he apologize, or else. After he refused, NYC Council Speaker Corey
Johnson booted Yeger from—what I assume is a wholly useless—city immigration
committee. “I found Council Member Yeger’s comments completely unacceptable…”
Johnson explained. “They were dehumanizing to Palestinians and divisive, and
have no place in New York City.”
One of Yeger’s statements might be debatable—perhaps some
of you don’t find Omar’s numerous attacks on American Jews anti-Semitic—but the
other contention is a historical and present-day reality. Despite this, nearly
every media story covering the kerfuffle frames the councilman’s contention
about the status of the West Bank and Gaza as some kind of appalling attack on
decency. What other Howard Zinn-like historical fantasies must we adopt to
participate in debate?
“Now, if he comes out and he apologizes, and says, ‘Look,
I was wrong and I realize what I did was hurtful and I’ve got to change,’
different discussion,” de Blasio said. Pointing out that there’s no nation
called Palestine might be provocative and argumentative, but the contention is
no less accurate because of the emotional reaction it provokes. The American
left’s censorship mission creep already deems numerous words and ideas off
limits if enough people act insulted. Now, they’re trying to impose limits on
speaking out about incontestable geopolitical truths.
Although one day it might, Palestine doesn’t exist today.
An independent Arab Palestine has never existed. It didn’t exist under the
Ottoman rule or the British Mandate or, in the end, under a United Nations
Partition Plan that was rejected by every single Arab state and Palestinian
leadership. It didn’t exist when the Palestinians were governed by governments
in Jordan and Egypt (a time when there was virtually no international pressure
to create an independent Palestine) and it didn’t come into existence when the
Arab states rejected Israel’s peace gestures after the 1967 and 1973 wars.
Yasser Arafat ultimately rejected peace in every
negotiation he ever participated in, embracing Intifada instead. Palestine
didn’t exist after Israel granted Gaza autonomy and the populace turned to the
terrorists of Hamas, and it won’t exist until Hamas and Fatah stop engaging in
and supporting terrorism and drop their absurd demands for Jerusalem and the
Right of Return.
Rashida Tlaib can put as many sticky notes over Israel as
she likes, and it won’t change this reality.
A number of media outlets covering this incident point
out that the United Nations and 137 states have “bilaterally” recognized
Palestine. While it’s nice that Botswana and Cuba (and scores of other nations
that suppress their own minority populations) have decided to act as if a
small, disputed territory in the Middle East is an independent entity, the
United States does not recognize a Palestinian nation. More significantly, the
only country that can make the Palestinian state a reality is Israel.
Contra Johnson, pointing out the fact that Palestinians
have never governed their own nation is not “dehumanizing.” Nor is pointing out
the fact that the Arab use of “Palestinian” is a relative historical neologism
mean there are no such people today. Simply because there’s no Kurdistan
doesn’t mean that 35 million Kurds (whose independence the UN doesn’t care one
wit about) do not exist. Nor does the absence of the Basque country or
Balochistan mean that there aren’t Basques or Balochs. The same goes for the
hundreds of other minority populations that have as good, if not far better,
claims to statehood.
The United Nations and other anti-Israel organizations
and activists have attempted to rewrite history and reality to create an
inevitability around a future Palestinian state. That’s why they’re so offended
by those who try to correct the historic record. The attempted regulating of
rhetoric, and the imposition of false history, is meant to stifle debate. None
of this is new. Watching elected New Yorkers like de Blasio and Johnson help
them, however, is.
New York has come a long way from the days when Mayor
Rudy Giuliani kicked Arafat, the father of modern terrorism, out of Lincoln
Center. Almost every mayor going back to the creation of Israel, in fact, stuck
up for the Jewish community—a community that has incrementally surrendered its
cultural history to progressivism. In the end, though, Yeger only stated truth.
Perhaps it’s an uncomfortable truth. But it’s not as if he claimed that
Palestinians were hypnotizing the world with evil deeds.
No comments:
Post a Comment