By David French
Monday, August 28, 2017
If 2016 is the year when our political parties failed,
inflicting on America arguably its worst presidential choice in our nation’s history,
then 2017 is when our broader institutions began to lose their collective
minds. This is the year when reasonable men surrendered to unreason — when
political tribalism trumped human decency.
The primary tragedy of Charlottesville was the loss of a
young woman’s life. The secondary tragedy was the distortion of our political
culture. The president of the United States actually declared some portion of a
collection of neo-Nazis, white supremacists, and alt-right white nationalists
to be “very fine people.” He just couldn’t bring himself to completely disavow
men and women who’d supported him since the day he descended down the escalator
at Trump Tower.
Yet rather than doing the easiest and most sensible thing
in the world — condemning white supremacy while also condemning political
violence on the far left — some portion of the left-wing intelligentsia
actually decided to embrace their own thugs. They supported Antifa. They decided to lionize some of the worst people
in American life. And in so doing, they actually compared them to the American
heroes who stormed Omaha Beach. The tweets below, as the saying goes, did not
age well.
First, here’s Jeffrey Goldberg, the editor-in-chief of The Atlantic, one of the best and most
respected political journals in American life:
Watching ‘Saving Private Ryan,’ a
movie about a group of very aggressive alt-left protesters invading a beach
without a permit.
— Jeffrey Goldberg
(@JeffreyGoldberg) August 16, 2017
In fact, this comparison of the “alt-left” with the
warriors of the Greatest Generation was hardly unique to Goldberg. Here’s CNN’s
Chris Cuomo:
Let’s not forget pic.twitter.com/q5wjVmZylR
— Christopher C. Cuomo
(@ChrisCuomo) August 16, 2017
And here’s CNN contributor and former Hillary Clinton
spokesman Brian Fallon:
Also confronted the Nazis without a
permit: pic.twitter.com/3c2f3X9slC
— Brian Fallon (@brianefallon)
August 16, 2017
Indeed, for a time the very notion that a person could
and should condemn both Antifa and the alt-right generated extreme rage online.
How dare you equate fascists and
anti-fascists! Outlets such as the Washington
Post and CNN published fawning apologetics and romanticized profiles of the
far left’s vigilante thugs. Antifa had its pop-culture moment.
It was disgraceful. All of it. And this weekend Antifa
struck again. A small group of peaceful right-wing protesters gathered in
Berkeley. Black-clad Antifa thugs attacked. The Washington Post has the story:
Their faces hidden behind black
bandannas and hoodies, about 100 anarchists and antifa — “anti-fascist” —
members barreled into a protest Sunday afternoon in Berkeley’s Martin Luther
King Jr. Civic Center Park.
Jumping over plastic and concrete
barriers, the group melted into a larger crowd of around 2,000 that had marched
peacefully throughout the sunny afternoon for a “Rally Against Hate” gathering.
Shortly after, violence began to
flare. A pepper-spray-wielding Trump supporter was smacked to the ground with
homemade shields. Another was attacked by five black-clad antifa members, each
windmilling kicks and punches into a man desperately trying to protect himself.
A conservative group leader retreated for safety behind a line of riot police as
marchers chucked water bottles, shot off pepper spray and screamed, “Fascist go
home!”
Even worse, the police literally stood aside and let
Antifa take over a public park. It allowed mob rule and then justified
abdicating its responsibility to protect the liberty and safety of Berkeley’s
citizens by claiming that it wanted “people to freely assemble.” This is a sad
joke. It gave control to Antifa. It
empowered the heckler’s veto.
The video evidence of violence is appalling. Antifa isn’t
heroic. It’s brutal:
Antifa beat down apparent
alt-righter. pic.twitter.com/WVdDJqLKmA
— Shane Bauer (@shane_bauer) August 27, 2017
As vicious as they are, in a functioning constitutional
republic, Antifa is a manageable, short-term problem. A vigorous police presence
followed by a wave of arrests and aggressive prosecutions would largely end the
threat. The men and women of Antifa aren’t insurgents; they’re little more than
a cowardly gang of left-wing thugs.
Far more serious is their effect on the rule of law and
political discourse. Has hatred for Trump so blinded America’s liberal elite
that it’s willing to romanticize violence? Is their respect for the First
Amendment so fragile that the thrill of watching alleged members of the
alt-right get punched in the face is worth more than preserving core
constitutional liberties? Have the police forgotten their role as guardians of
American liberty?
This isn’t #resistance, it’s lawlessness. It’s not
anti-fascism, it’s violent repression. Is the rule now that any gathering of
Trump supporters — alt-right or not — in any blue enclave risks a violent
response? Have authorities, through a combination of cowardice and political
correctness, ceded control of the streets in key American towns to a
Marxist/anarchist mob?
Antifa and its elite apologists are sending a clear
message of hate and loathing to millions of Americans who don’t have a fascist
bone in their bodies — to the millions of good people who voted for Donald
Trump. Antifa doesn’t occupy the moral high ground. Its apologists have no
grounds to sneer at anyone. Instead, they’re competing with the alt-right for
control of the political sewer.
Condemn Antifa now. Prosecute its members now. Or watch
America continue to tear itself apart. Violent Marxists are evil. Violent
fascists are evil. If we can’t understand both of those basic truths
simultaneously, then we have truly lost our way.
No comments:
Post a Comment