By David Harsanyi
Wednesday, November 16, 2016
In the midst of this post-election moral panic the Left has
ginned, the FBI released its 2015 hate crime statistics this week. As you can
imagine, newsfeeds were littered with headlines like “New hate crime statistics
shows surge against Muslims” and “FBI: Hate crimes against Muslims in US surge
67 percent.” The key words, in case you missed them, were “Muslims” and
“surge.”
Though the numbers are from 2015, the report comported
neatly with the overwrought reaction that has followed Donald Trump’s
surprising victory. We should remain skeptical about this supposed surge in
violence by his supporters. Hundreds of stories launched into social media were
based on nothing more than accusations. As Reason magazine points out, many
have already turned out to be hoaxes.
Notwithstanding all its warts, the FBI’s hate crime
report actually offers us a useful reminder: despite the presence of a number
of idiotic and violent fellow humans — a plague on all cultures and races,
regrettably —Americans are generally tolerant of others in the ways that matter
most. When we consider the depth and sprawl of our diversity, it’s pretty clear
we are unique to history. Look at any place in the world. When races, faiths,
or ethnicities converge there is almost always strife and violence.
I wonder if the average American thinks about his country
in that way anymore. I wonder if the average American understands how rare
bias-motivated crimes are in his country. Since 9/11 we’ve been warned about an
impending violent backlash against Muslims. Yet even with a number of horrific
terrorist acts perpetrated by home-grown Islamists, it still hasn’t happened.
Of all hate crimes, 19.7 percent were reported as religious bias. Among that
group, 51.3 percent were reported as anti-Semitic and 22.2 percent were
anti-Muslim. (Also, 17.7 percent were committed against one of the Christian
faiths, which the FBI divides into multiple categories.)
A more factual headline might have read, “FBI finds Jews
most often the victims of rare faith-based hate crimes in America.” But
considering these numbers are pre-alt-right Twitter, that doesn’t fit neatly
into the narrative we’re looking for right now.
If reporting bias-crime numbers in overall percentages
seems unfair to you, fine. There are around 5 million Jews in the United States
and probably around 3.5 million Muslims. It’s difficult to calculate these
numbers with precision because, despite progressives’ hard work, Islam is still
not a race nor a nationality. But even measured proportionally, Jews were more
likely to be victims of hate crimes.
Speaking of percentages: To say there’s been a 67 percent
surge in bias crimes against Muslims between 2014 and 2015 is factual but
incomplete. To put the number in perspective, let’s remember that in a nation
of around 330 million people there were a total of 257 criminal incidents —
perpetrated by 228 offenders (not every police department reports hate crimes,
but most do) — that officials determined were motivated by anti-Muslim
sentiment.
Victims of a hate crime suffer in ways that most of us
can’t comprehend. Some of these crimes were deadly serious. Most were
misdemeanors, however. Among them were acts like vandalism, simple assault
(assault that does involve physical contact), and intimidation. None of these
crimes are tolerable, and the perpetrators should be fully prosecuted, shamed,
and rejected by all decent Americans.
In any event, these numbers, flawed or not, hardly align
with the hysterics we’ve been hearing from the Left these past few years. Hate
crimes are a blip when we consider all criminal activity. Even if these numbers
were quadrupled, they would still be a blip.
I already know what’s coming: But how about this incident! And how about this one! Look what this one
said!
No rational person would deny that racists and bigots
exist. Believe it or not, as a Jew myself, this election cycle isn’t the first
time my background has been attacked. When you start likening contemporary
political officials to Nazis, though, I tend to think you’re shortchanging the
people who decimated my family back in the Old Country.
It’s also undeniable that over the past year some
legitimately worrisome voices have found footing with Republicans. Maybe Steve
Bannon is going to be bad news. I wasn’t too crazy about Obama nominating
someone who claimed her favorite political philosopher was Mao, either. Still,
there was no Great Leap Forward.
If you believe one side is normalizing extremism, think
about this: Rep. Keith Ellison, a guy whose political career was launched as a
member the anti-Semitic and racist Nation of Islam, and who is one of the most
radically left-wing members of Congress, may soon be running the DNC. Just
juxtapose the stories and rhetoric surrounding Bannon and Ellison. Only one is
treated as if he’s outside the norm.
In the minds of many, the only reason someone could be
critical of Ellison is that he’s an African-American Muslim. Democrats have
become so fixated on race and identity that they’re unable to imagine anything
else could matter. Hannah Arendt once wrote that Western intellectuals had
adopted one of Communism’s most effective tactics: they made all debate about
motive rather than the merits of the argument. This outlook has consumed the
American Left.
Is there any contemporary political dispute today that
doesn’t come down to accusing conservatives of harboring deep-seated motives
about race or sex? Some (and I really, feel uncomfortable calling them
“liberals” anymore) have convinced themselves Trump’s victory confirms that
half the country is made up of white supremacists — as if voting and governance
were that simple.
In truth, the reason racism is treated as a grievous
social sin is because it is so rare and intolerable in everyday discourse. The
Left compensates for this by constantly expanding the description of bigotry to
include anyone opposing their policy preferences. When everyone is a racist, no
one is.
For years, President Obama made it a habit to conflate
criticism of Islam with hate speech. A majority of Americans harbor legitimate
apprehensions about Islamic terrorism and immigration, which while it brings
many good people to our country also brings a lot of illiberal ideas. Trump’s
boorishness on the matter doesn’t mean his voters are all pining to burn down
mosques or threaten their neighbors. It probably means most other politicians
weren’t taking their concerns seriously enough.
Anyway, the FBI has yet to come up with a “thought crimes
division,” although I’m sure the folks at Vox or Slate have some great ideas.
There is no real way to gauge how much love Americans have for all their
neighbors. Guess what? Even if some old-timer isn’t crazy about people who
speak Spanish in public, it doesn’t make him a member of the Schutzstaffel. What we do know is that
considering our sheer amount of religious, cultural, and racial diversity, we
live in a peace unmatched in human history. This is worth remembering as we
have an emotional breakdown over an election.
No comments:
Post a Comment