By David Harsanyi
Friday, May 20, 2016
Never have so many people with so little knowledge made
so many consequential decisions for the rest of us.
A person need only survey the inanity of the ongoing
presidential race to comprehend that the most pressing problem facing the
nation isn’t Big Business, Big Labor, Big Media or even Big Money in politics.
It’s you, the American voter. And by weeding out millions
of irresponsible voters who can’t be bothered to learn the rudimentary workings
of the Constitution, or their preferred candidate’s proposals or even their
history, we may be able to mitigate the recklessness of the electorate.
No, we shouldn’t erect physical barriers to ballot
access. Let’s purchase more voting machines, hire additional poll workers,
streamline the registration process, mail out more ballots for seniors and
produce more “Rock the Vote” ads imploring apathetic millennials to embrace
their civic duty.
At the same time, let’s also remember that checking a box
for the candidate whose campaign ads you like best is one of the most overrated
obligations of the self-governed. If you have no clue what the hell is going on,
you also have a civic duty to avoid subjecting the rest of us to your
ignorance.
Unfortunately, we can’t trust you.
Now, if voting is a consecrated rite of democracy, as
liberals often argue, surely society can have certain minimal expectations for
those participating. And if citizenship itself is as hallowed as Republicans
argue, then surely the prospective voter can be asked to know just as much as
the prospective citizen. Let’s give voters a test. The citizenship civics test
will do just fine.
How many screeching proponents of the two major
candidates would pass this quiz? Here are some of the questions, which run from
easy to preposterously easy:
“If both the President and the Vice President can no
longer serve, who becomes President?”
“There were 13 original states. Name three.”
“What is one right or freedom from the First Amendment?”
“What is freedom of religion?”
I have tempered confidence that at least a majority of
the voting public could pass such a test — though I couldn’t say the same for a
majority of presidential candidates. Certainly, this should be a breeze for
citizens so intensely involved in the process that they feel compelled to
plaster bumper stickers on their cars and attend the rallies of their favorite
candidates.
Or am I being too optimistic? When Newsweek asked a
thousand voters to take the official citizenship test a few years back, nearly
30 percent couldn’t name the vice president. More than 60 percent did not know
the length of U.S. senators’ terms in office. And 43 percent couldn’t say that
the first 10 amendments to the Constitution are known as the Bill of Rights.
Only 30 percent knew that the U.S. Constitution is the
supreme law of the land.
In another study, by the Annenberg Public Policy Center,
we learned that only 36 percent could name all three branches of the U.S.
government. Only 62 percent knew that the U.S. Supreme Court was tasked with
determining the constitutionality of legislation. Fewer than half of Americans
knew that split decisions in the Supreme Court have the same effect as 9 to 0
decisions.
These are the people who pick the people who define the
basic fabric of the legal system — and often our lives.
To be fair, the contemporary electorate is probably no
less ignorant today than it was 50 or 100 years ago. The difference is that now
we have unlimited access to information. As James Madison wrote, “A popular
Government, without popular information, or the means of acquiring it, is but a
Prologue to a Farce or a Tragedy; or, perhaps both.”
And it literally takes seconds to learn about the fundamentals
of our republic and the positions of candidates. If you forsake the power of
information, you have no standing to tell the rest of us how to live our lives.
Don’t vote.
Now, some of you will accuse me of peddling crass
elitism. But I say the opposite is true. Unlike the many who depend on ignorant
voters to wield and secure their power, I refuse to believe that working-class
or underprivileged citizens are any less capable of understanding the meaning
of the Constitution or the contours of governance than the supercilious
1-percenters. I believe this despite the widespread failure of public schools
to teach children basic civics. It’s still our responsibility as voters.
Of course, we also must remember the ugly history of poll
taxes and other prejudicial methods that Americans used to deny black citizens
their equal right to vote. Any effort to improve the quality of the voting
public should ensure that all races, creeds, genders and sexual orientations
and people of every socioeconomic background are similarly inhibited from
voting when ignorant. For the good of our democratic institutions.
No comments:
Post a Comment