By Kevin D. Williamson
Sunday, December 26, 2021
The Democrats love the poor. The Democrats hate the
poor.
And the poor in West Virginia? They’re at the bottom of
the bucket, as Democrats see things.
Senator Joe Manchin, the moderate Democrat from West
Virginia who is one of the last of that breed, has derailed Joe Biden’s beloved
Build Back Better bill, a slop-bucket of progressive wish-fulfillment that
would add trillions in new spending to our already-bloated federal budget and
pile much more debt upon our already-considerable national heap. Senator
Manchin thought it was a bad package, though he supported some of what was in
it, and West Virginians thought it was a bad package, though they supported
some of what was in it, and so Senator Manchin announced — on Fox
News, in an extra “f**k you” to Chuck Schumer et al. — that he would oppose the
bill. Because Democrats and Republicans both have rejected the notion of
consensus-building and bipartisanship, every Senate Republican opposes the
scheme, which means that the Democrats need every Democratic vote to pass the
bill in the evenly split Senate.
Senator Manchin’s willingness to break with his party
makes him, for the moment, the most powerful man in Washington after the maître
d’ at le Diplomate. (Somewhere in the Senate, there must be at least
one Republican who is smart enough to realize that he could be the most
powerful man in Washington, after the maître d’ at le
Diplomate, if he were willing to do the same.) It also makes him the man
Democrats hate most — at the moment, anyway; Democratic hatred is an urgent and
plastic thing.
But like the unhappy worker who cannot face off against
his overbearing boss and so instead goes home to yell at his wife and kick the
dog (as Sigmund Freud once had it), progressives from Hollywood to Washington
to whatever abandoned gopher hole Robert Reich calls home have decided to lay
into the people of West Virginia. As Isaac Schorr already has reported here, the noted political philosopher Bette Midler and her
friends at Occupy Democrats denounced West Virginians as illiterates (the
Mountain State has a higher literacy rate than New York, California, or New Jersey),
Ilhan Omar suggested that Senator Manchin’s vote is the result of corruption —
a serious charge for which she should be made to answer — and Reich offered
this indictment: “Let me remind you that a full quarter of West Virginians 65
and older have no natural teeth.” Toothless hillbillies — who doesn’t love a
classic? In fact, the share of West Virginians over 65 without any remaining
teeth is not far off from the national average; the state’s slightly elevated
rate of geriatric toothlessness is almost certainly due to the fact that it has
a large population of people over 75 (who have a very high rate of total tooth loss), being the
nation’s third-most-elderly state. But facts don’t matter much when you’ve
worked up a good head of hate-steam.
I know as well as anybody that poor, rural, white America has its problems. But I do
not believe for one hot second that Ilhan Omar or Robert Reich knows one damned
thing about them, or cares to learn. Why would they? Senator Manchin is about
as far to the political left as today’s West Virginia is going to go. Owsley
County, Ky., home
of the poorest white people in America, is overwhelmingly Republican, and
Donald Trump got eight times as many votes as Joe Biden did there in 2020 —
Trump did slightly better in San Francisco than
Biden did in Owsley County. There’s a little factoid to meditate upon.
The most important domestic political development of the
21st century so far is the class-reversal of the Republican and Democratic
parties, a trend that began in the 1990s with Bill Clinton and now has reached
a state of genuine polarization. Democrats, once the party of poor farmers and
working-class “white ethnics,” as we used to call them, have become the party
of affluent, educated, metropolitan and suburban professionals — the people who
once were critical to the Republican coalition. One notable barometer, the five
counties of Southeastern Pennsylvania, for years exemplified a national
pattern: Philadelphia was overwhelmingly Democratic, and the four suburban
counties around it were overwhelmingly Republican; now, you don’t hit
Republican territory until Lancaster County, which is both Amish country and
heroin country, with almost 150 overdose deaths in 2020.
As far as today’s Democrats are concerned, voting
Republican is just one more pathology that afflicts the toothless hillbillies
of their imagination. They are perplexed — or at least pretend to be perplexed
— by the fact that there are poor and struggling Americans who do not
instinctively turn to welfare-statism as the answer to their problems, who are
uneager to sacrifice either their values or their liberties in exchange for a
government check. Democrats have responded to this by elevating the needs of
the relatively well-off to the top of their agenda, which is why they spend so
much time talking about the terrible burden of student loans for young lawyers
and underemployed Haverford graduates. You won’t hear them offer anything like
a serious solution to the public-education crisis in Los Angeles or Milwaukee —
those well-paid teachers are a core part of the Democratic base, and
semi-literate high-school dropouts do not vote in large numbers.
It is likely that Senator Manchin either will become a
Republican or will be replaced by one, eventually. At only 74 years of age, he
is a spring chicken by the standards of current Democratic leadership:
President Biden is 79, Nancy Pelosi is 81 (her hair is 46), and Dianne
Feinstein is within spittin’ distance of 90. But he isn’t going to be in the
Senate forever. Because the Senate gives equal representation to the
less-populous rural states and the densely populated urban states, it is always
going to be a problem for Democrats. Strangely, Democrats seem, at the moment,
intent on making it a bigger problem for themselves. Further shrinking the
universe of possible electoral coalitions may pass for smart in the great
echoing expanse of insipidity between Bette Midler’s droopy old ears, but it is
a losing strategy.
Somewhere, Mitch McConnell is cracking a bloodcurdling
smile.
No comments:
Post a Comment