By Brendan O'Neill
Tuesday, March 02, 2021
Is Joe Biden a Nazi? I only ask because he’s doing a
lot of the same things that the previous incumbent of the White House did, and
that guy was always being called a Nazi.
Remember when Donald Trump’s administration
incarcerated kids who had illegally crossed the Mexican border? That was
literally fascism. These children-packed detention centres were ‘concentration camps’, said Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. Trump is taking the world ‘back to the
1930s’, said a breathless scribe at the Guardian.
Or how about when Trump dropped bombs on the Middle
East? He was branded an insane warmonger. This is the imperial logic of his alt-right
leanings, we were told. As for his administration’s targeting of Iranian forces
– in particular Iran’s top military commander, Qasem Soleimani, killed by an
American bomb in January last year – that was held up by some leftists and
liberals as proof of just how deranged Trumpism had become. #WorldWar3 trended
on Twitter. ‘Could tension between the US and Iran spark World War 3?’, asked one headline. Trump was always either embodying the evils of the Second World War or
propelling humanity into a third.
As for his bully-boy tactics with the press – for
journalists in particular this was technicolor evidence of his fascistic
tendencies. Trump’s mockery of CNN and the New
York Times – whom he frequently wrote off as ‘fake news’ – was straight out
of 1930s Germany, apparently. (If someone can dig out footage of German
journalists questioning and ridiculing the Fuhrer to his face in daily press
conferences, I’d love to see that.)
Trump’s war of words against ‘fake news’, his niggling desire to punish and
censor the press for allegedly promoting ‘misinformation’, made him Literally
Hitler. Hitler also used ‘the idea of the “Lügenpresse”
(“fake news”) to attack journalists’, Yale prof Timothy Snyder solemnly informed us.
And now? Well now, Biden and some of his top advisers
and supporters are doing all of the above – caging kids from Mexico, bombing
the Middle East, demanding that the fake-news media be ‘reined in’ – but
apparently it isn’t fascism anymore! It’s normal politics. It’s sensible
policy. Isn’t that amazing – that policies can switch from being literally
Nazism to being standard American government action depending on the name and
party of the person signing them off?
Yes, the Biden administration really is doing all of
the above. Unaccompanied youths who cross the border from Mexico are being incarcerated. Kids aged 13 to 17 are being banged up. Towards the end of February
the Biden administration reopened detention centres for immigrant kids in both
Texas and Florida. ‘Kids in cages?’, I hear you ask. Of course not. These are
now youths in ‘overflow facilities’.
That’s the language being used. Out has gone CNN’s
handwringing over ‘kids in cages’ and those staged photos of AOC weeping
outside ‘concentration camps’ and those broadsheet editorials about how putting
child migrants into camps has ‘echoes of the 1930s’, etc etc. Now all the talk
is of ‘overflow facilities’ designed to ‘assist’ unaccompanied young arrivals.
You couldn’t make this stuff up.
Democrat New York mayor Bill de Blasio described the Homestead facility in Florida as a ‘prison camp’ when the
Trump administration was putting unaccompanied youths in there. He hasn’t said
a word since the same facility was reopened by the Biden administration for the
same purpose. It’s almost as if he doesn’t actually have any principles.
And don’t fall for the claims being made by
self-styled fact-checkers – those modern-day monks who fancy that they are the
guardians of the truth – who insist there is a massive difference between what
Trump did at the border and what Biden is doing. The Trump administration
separated kids from their parents, as well as incarcerating unaccompanied kids,
whereas the Biden lot are only doing the latter, so shut up. That’s their
message. This is so unconvincing. The unhinged, 1930s-exploiting fury over the
Trump administration’s antics at the border was not only about family
separations; it was also about the very act of incarcerating young people. It
was about the ‘prison camps’ themselves, as de Blasio, AOC and thousands of
weeping journalists referred to them. And now these same people are saying
nothing, or are nodding along with the idea that it is fine to put children in
‘overflow facilities’. Those are the
facts.
Last week Biden bombed Iranian-backed forces in Syria.
At least 22 people were killed. World War 3? Nope. This was a nice military attack, one of those
decent Democratic ones. ‘So different having military action under Biden’, said
left-wing American author Amy Siskind. ‘No middle-school level threats on
Twitter. Trust the competence of Biden and his team.’ Hey, American presidents,
it’s fine to kill foreigners, just don’t write a childish tweet about it, okay?
One of Ms Siskind’s online followers agreed. ‘Such a quiet attack’, she said. I’m guessing it was actually a pretty noisy attack for the scores of
people killed and injured.
Even supposedly more radical people were soft on Biden
after he dropped his first bombs. They didn’t take to the streets to denounce
this evil president for potentially stoking up World War 3. No, they made memes
saying, ‘You should be writing me a stimulus cheque, not bombing the Middle
East’. The narcissism, hypocrisy and phoney anti-imperialism of the
Trump-obsessed left summed up.
Then there’s the Biden lobby’s assault on ‘fake news’.
They are literally doing this – waging a war of words against the lying press,
or the Lügenpresse, one might say –
and no one is kicking up a fuss. AOC says Congress must ‘rein in’ media outlets
that ‘spew disinformation and misinformation’. That’s an overeducated person’s way of saying ‘fake news’. Last week
two top Democrats – Anna Eshoo and Jerry McNerney – wrote to all the major cable companies demanding to know why they are hosting such filthy, lying news outlets
as Fox News.
These people make Trump look like a rank amateur when
it comes to reprimanding the press. Sure, he might have barked insults at CNN
correspondents and tweeted abuse about the MSM. But some Democrats seem
determined to cancel what they view as ‘fake news’, to have these alleged
lowlifes taken off the airwaves. And yet – it’s getting predictable now, I know
– there has been no pushback, no talk of the 1930s, no Timothy Snyder columns
about Hitler. When Trump slams the ‘fake media’, it’s fascism; when Democrats
do it, it’s fine.
This is the Orwellian duplicity of the world we live
in now. Political language, Orwell said, can be twisted ‘to make lies sound
truthful and murder respectable’. And so it is that ‘kids in cages’ are now
‘youths in overflow facilities’; and bombs are now ‘quiet’ and ‘competent’
rather than reckless and dangerous; and what was denounced as a fascistic
attack on the free press when Trump was doing it is repackaged as a necessary
‘reining in’ of ‘misinformation’ now that Democrats are doing it. Reality is putty
to the new elites, something they must mould to their own tastes and interests.
Their self-serving dishonesty and self-aggrandising propaganda must not go
unchallenged.
In answer to the question posed at the start of this
article: no, of course Joe Biden is not a Nazi. But neither was Trump. Those of
us who take a grown-up approach to politics know that it is wrong to brand
everything as fascism. We also know it is wrong to abuse language and truth in
order to depict yourselves as the good guys even when you’re doing exactly what
the ‘bad guy’ did.
No comments:
Post a Comment