By Rich Lowry
Tuesday, March 09, 2021
It’d be fitting if Democrats
undertook a radical procedural step to pass a radical piece of legislation.
That’s what the Left is pressuring Senate
Democrats to do by eliminating, or significantly curtailing, the filibuster
to pass H.R. 1, the sweeping voting proposal that is one of the most
execrable bills to pass the House in a very long time.
H.R. 1 would federalize the conduct of
elections and codify what were supposed to be emergency voting procedures
during the pandemic, in frankly partisan legislation sheathed in the rhetoric
of “voting rights.”
According to advocates of the bill,
anything to tighten up or maintain good practices regarding ballot security is
“voter suppression” worthy of the old Jim Crow South.
By this way of thinking, Republican
efforts at the state level to, say, reduce the days available for early voting
— Iowa is reducing its early-voting period from 29 days to 20 days — will
disenfranchise millions, never mind that deep-blue New York State allows only
about a week of early voting.
Voter-identification laws, a bogeyman of
supporters of H.R. 1, were recommended by a 2005 bipartisan commission jointly
led by Jimmy Carter and James Baker, neither of whom will ever be mistaken for
Bull Connor. Not too long ago, it was a feature of big bipartisan voting bills
to require states to periodically clean up their voter rolls, another
commonsense measure that is now considered tantamount to wielding billy clubs
and police dogs.
There may be many problems besetting
American democracy, but people turning out to vote isn’t one of them. Turnout
exploded in the 2018 midterms before the pandemic, and turnout exploded in 2020
during the pandemic, with both Democrats who availed themselves of early voting
and Republicans who voted same day showing up in historic numbers.
In response largely to a non-problem,
Democrats want to trample on the prerogatives of states to conduct elections,
mandating their electoral priorities throughout the land.
States would have no choice but to accept
same-day registrations. People applying for various government programs or for
college would be registered automatically. States couldn’t turn away the
registrations of 16-year-olds, even though they can’t legally vote.
States couldn’t require voter ID. They
couldn’t remove inactive voters from the rolls. They couldn’t work with other
states to try to find duplicate registrations six months before an election.
It would be pandemic-era mail-in voting forevermore,
with no ID or witness signatures required and ballot-harvesting and drop boxes
mandatory everywhere.
Felons could no longer be barred from
voting. The federal government would pay to train high-school students how to
register people to vote and fund “campus voter coordinators,” as well as give
colleges grants to register students.
To truly bring home that the states are
being divested of powers that go back to the founding of the republic, state
legislatures would no longer draw congressional districts; instead the task
would be taken up by purportedly independent commissions. The FEC would no
longer be bipartisan, and sundry provisions would prohibit or chill unwelcome
political activity.
That many Democrats say that the
filibuster should fall for this bill is a symptom of the fevered state of the
party, which despite holding or winning every elected branch of the federal
government has conjured out of nothing a vast conspiracy to stop people from
voting that allegedly justifies one of the most blatant federal power grabs in
memory.
Early voting isn’t going away, but there
should be protections against potential abuses, and voting on Election Day
should be encouraged — it’s the most secure and private, and least error-prone,
way to vote.
It’s a symptom of what a wrecking ball
H.R. 1 is that, in the course of mandating the opposite on all counts, it could
kneecap both the states and a longstanding Senate procedure in one fell swoop.
No comments:
Post a Comment