National Review Online
Monday, February 20, 2017
The Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC),
organized by the American Conservative Union, is regularly the most anticipated
event on the conservative calendar. Although it has become increasingly
circus-like in recent years, it remains the year’s foremost gathering of
conservative activists, several days of speakers normally include leading
officeholders, and it is considered a testing ground for prospective
presidential candidates.
Over the weekend, CPAC invited Milo Yiannopoulos to speak
at this year’s event, happening later this week in Maryland. Of late,
Yiannopoulos, a “tech editor” for Breitbart
News, has been a regular guest on college campuses and a constant source of
irritation to campus liberals. Recently, the University of California–Berkeley
greeted his arrival with riots. Despite the fact that Yiannopoulos holds a
number of noxious opinions, we have defended his right to air them against
those who would shout him down or worse.
CPAC is different. The annual event helps to define and
broadcast the priorities of grassroots conservatives. Whatever Yiannopoulos’s
politics, they are not conservative in any meaningful sense. Indeed,
Yiannopoulos has said so himself. Appearing on HBO’s Bill Maher Show just last week, Yiannopoulos said that he was not
sure he would call himself conservative.
What Yiannopoulos has
called himself is a “chronicler of, and occasional fellow traveler with, the
alt-right,” that various group of “reactionaries,” ethno-nationalists, white
supremacists, and others, who have set themselves against Reagan-style
conservatism and who have developed a robust online presence over the last
year. The latter is in no small part thanks to Yiannopoulos, who wrote an essay
largely praising the alt-right last spring; according to him, the alt-right is
generally composed of “dangerously bright” “intellectuals” and “mischievous”
“rebels.” While Yiannopoulos has tried to distance himself from Richard Spencer
and other, more unabashed white nationalists, he has had no qualms making
common cause with the hordes of Twitter users who photoshop Jewish conservative
writers into ovens. Yiannopoulos — who has himself hurled anti-Semitic slurs
(he recently described a Jewish BuzzFeed
reporter as “a typical example of a sort of thick-as-pig s**t media Jew”), and
who helped to popularize the term “cuckservative” — defends himself against
charges of bigotry by reminding everyone that he has Jewish ancestry and is
gay. The latter is part of his excuse for defending pederasty on a podcast in
September 2015, then again during an interview in January 2016. Recordings of
those statements were unearthed this weekend, shortly after CPAC’s
announcement.
On Monday morning, the ACU cited those recordings as its
reason for rescinding Yiannopoulos’s invitation. But that Yiannopoulos did not
have a place at CPAC, or at any forum that describes itself as “conservative,”
should have been obvious from the start. Instead, the ACU put conservatives in
a no-win situation. Had they permitted him to speak, it would have been
considered a tacit endorsement of his opinions. Now, having rescinded his
invitation, CPAC will be portrayed by Yiannopoulos’s many fans as one more
organ of leftist-style speech-policing. Whatever happens later this week, CPAC
has diminished true conservatism’s appeal.
It has become fashionable in conservative circles to
cheer every apparently right-leaning gadfly. But “trolling” is not
conservatism, and there is no virtue merely in upsetting campus Democrats.
There are many conservatives who do regular battle with left-wing agitators —
but who also are of high character, and advance conservative arguments and
defend conservative principles with poise, wit, and good cheer. If CPAC wants
to highlight the challenges for conservatives on campus, there are dozens of
respectable options.
The alt-right and its “fellow travelers,” meanwhile,
openly detest the “conservatism” that the ACU was founded to defend. CPAC
should have taken them at their word.
No comments:
Post a Comment